penentuan pemain inti tim bola basket menggunakan metode ahp dan promethee

8/19/2019 Penentuan Pemain Inti Tim Bola Basket Menggunakan Metode AHP dan Promethee

1/125

A A BA BA

AA D A DA

U eeh ebaga eaaa

eeeh gea Saaa Ke

D eh:

Fah R Fa

NIM: 115060807111040

PROGRAM STUDI INFORMATIKA / ILMU KOMPUTER

PROGRAM TEKNOLOGI INFORMASI DAN ILMU KOMPUTER

UNIVERSITAS BRAWIJAYA


2/125

MALANG

2015


3/125

AA

PENENTUAN PEMAIN INTI TIM BOLA BASKET MENGGUNAKAN METODE

AACA AC PROCESS AHP DAN PROMETHEE

SKRIPSI

Daa eeh ebaga eaaa

eeeh gea Saaa Ke

D Oeh :

Fah R Fa

NIM:115060807111040

S eah d da daaa ada10 Deebe 2015

Teah dea da de eh:

De Pebbg I

Rea Regaa MP.,S.T.,M.T.NIK:770414 06 1 2 0257

De Pebbg II

I. S,M.T.NIP: 19570325 198701 1 001

Megeah

Kea Pga SdTe Ifaa

D. Ma, M.T.

NIP: 19670801 199203 1 001


4/125

AAA AA

Saa eaaa dega ebeabeaa baha eaag egeaha

aa, d daa aah da edaa aa ah ag eahdaa eh ag a eeeh gea aade d a ega

gg, da da edaa aa aa edaa ag eah d aa

deba eh ag a, eca ag ecaa e da daa aah

da deba daa dafa aa.

Aaba eaa ddaa aah daa dba edaa

aga, aa beeda dgga da gea aade ag eah

aa eeh (aaa) dbaaa, ea de ea dega eaa

edagdaga ag bea (UU N. 20 Tah 2003, Paa 25 aa 2 da

Paa 70).

Maag, 1 Jaa 2015

Fah R Fa

NIM: 115060807111040


5/125

AA AA

Ahadah Rabbaa. P ehada Aah SWT ag eah

ebe aha da hdaahNa, e daa eeeaa ga ah ag bed Kafa T Pada S Bedaaa Jd da Aba

dega Mede C B

(TWCNB).

S d ebaga aa eeeh gea aaa ada

ga d Ifaa, Faa I Ke, Uea Baaa.

Daa eeeaa ga ah e eah edaaa baa

ba daa ha a aa aea da baa ha. Aa baa ag

dah dbea, aa e g eaaa eghagaa da caa

eaah eada :

1. Aah SWT aea aa da ahaNa aa daa

eeeaa ga ah .

2. Rea Regaa MP.,S.T.,M.T. ag beda ea Pebbg 1.

Teaah aa bbga ag dbea, a da aahaa

ea ceacea ag eba daa ecaa ga

ah ag bag.

3. I. S, M.T. ag beda ea Pebbg 2. Teaah

aa egaa eabaa da aha daa eaha da

ebbg ga ah aa eea.

4. Mhaad Ta F, S.K.,McSc. ea Peg 1 da

Sabaah Ra Aba,S.T.,M.Eg. ea Peg 2 agebea da aa eeba ga ah ag

daa.

5. S, I., MT, ea Kea Pga Teg Ifa da

I Ke Uea Baaa, da D. Mad, MT., ea

Kea Pga Sd Te Ifaa Uea Baaa.

6. Segea de da aff FILKOM ag eah eba, edd

da bebag eada e eaa aa ah.

7. Keda Oaga e Baa H. Sachdd, Ib A

Mhaah, Ka Yad Add Fah, Mba K Mah

Faaha da egea eaga bea eca. Teaah aaeaga da da ag eah daaa de eeeaaa

ga ah .

8. Teaea Baaa cabag Maag Ade Afa, Dd 3 Sea,

He Jaad, Made Waa, Cah Bebe, Rad Ke, E

BeB, Maba, Kh Kaa, Ra, Re Acg d ag


6/125

da ba deba ag eah ebea dga a,

aa ga, ebahagaa ebaga eaga eda d Maag.

9. Mhaad Taf,S.T.,M.Eg., Jd Aad,S.S., D.Baa A Ab

Wca, M.R Add, S.K.,P, ebaga ahaba agda aag bage ee a eagaa ah ea eea.

Gada aa. Sea ada baha ba eaa. Uda ada a

aaga ag ag gga eba daga a aa e

aaaa a ada eea baeg hahaha. Y c gae :* A

e Ka Jaa!!!

10. Yag eaag da ea ada aa dbh. Yag b ea

h g ad ebh beaa. Yag ea ead eag

daa bada daag. Yag ead bag daa ag gea da

g. Yag ad aaa da aa ead a

eaaa. Teaah ea bed dag. I e

fe ad bed, Ra R F☺.

11. Teeee eeaga a ag da baa bage

ba. Gada aa ga baa ea dah a. Be, Ia, Fda

, We, Ia, V, O Agga, ee TIFC Da, Dda, E

d, Ra, a, a, Fad, R, Dede, Agg, Ida, da a

baa ag ag a da ga ba deba a a.

12. Icha Ida, R Pag, Eg, Dfa Aaa, Pee, da aa

bba a ag baa be cae eba. Tea ah da

ad aah a da ea baa e ag gabaa da.

Pe ada ah edaa eaga daa aa ag

debaba eh eebaaa egeaha da egaaa e. Dega

beg, e aga eghaga da aa ag faa ebag

de ebaa ea da eaaa ada

eea eaa.

Pe behaa ega daa beafaa ebaca

da daa dab afaa da ag eadg daa ga ah .

Maag, 21 Deebe 2015

Pe

[email protected]


7/125

ABA

Oahaga eaa aah a egaa ag daa

egaa ebgaa f eeag. Baa ea e ahaga ag daadaa eeag ea dega eaa da baa ag d. D

Idea ed, bae ead aah ahaga ag ag da.

Uea Baaa ag eaa aah a Uea bea d a

aag, aa ga e bebeaa ba bae ag dga eh

U Aa Ba Bae Uea Baaa (UABBUB). Daa ea

aha, UABBUB ea eea edafaa agga ba bag ahaa

ag g begabg daa . Meha eebaga da beaa a

aa ha eba UABBUB egaa ea daa eea

ea aa daa aea ag d ha aa a aa

aa. U eeeaa eaaaha eeb aa dbaah ebah

e eea a ea dega eggaa edeAHP da Pehee. Mede AHP dgaa eaa ebba

ag ed da e eba a ebadga beaaga,

eghg aa a, eghg e da eghaa

bb ea e Pehee. Sedaga Pehee ed da e

eea a ea ea aeaf, eghg a aaee

( ), eghg a deaa efee, eghg a de

efee, eghg a , eghg a , da

eghg a . Daa ehga edaa 3 ea a:

eda ag e bea ehad daa aha da ea a,

a ag e bea a eada eah da a eada ea,

eaa e ag e bea , , ,, , da . Ha aa e ag ddaaa da ha

ega adaah ebea 80%.

: Peea Pea, bae, UABBUB, AHP, PROMETHEE


8/125

ABAC

.

. , .

B ,

A B B

B (ABBB). , ABBB

. B

B , ABBB

. A

A . A

,

, . A ,

,

(), ,

, ,

, . ,

, ; (1) ,

, (2) ,

, (3) ,

, , , , , .

80%.

: , , , ,


9/125

DAA

PENGESAHAN .....................................................................................................

PERNYATAAN ORISINALITAS ...............................................................................

KATA PENGANTAR ...............................................................................................

ABSTRAK.............................................................................................................

ABSTRACT..........................................................................................................

DAFTAR ISI ..........................................................................................................

DAFTAR TABEL....................................................................................................

DAFTAR GAMBAR ...............................................................................................

BAB 1 PENDAHULUAN .........................................................................................1

1.1 Laa Beaag .................................................................................... 1

1.2 Ra Maaah...............................................................................2

1.3 Baaa Maaah................................................................................. 3

1.4 Ta................................................................................................. 3

1.5 Mafaa .............................................................................................. 4

1.6 Seaa Pea .........................................................................4

BAB 2 DASAR TEORI .............................................................................................5

2.1 Bae.................................................................................................5

2.1.1 Def Bae ............................................................................ 5

2.1.2 Te Daa Bae....................................................................5

2.1.3 P Pada Bae ......................................................................9

2.2 A (A).................................................... 10

2.2.1 Lagah agah AHP................................................................ 11

2.2.2 P Daa AHP .....................................................................12

2.3

()............................................................................................15

2.3.1 Pe Pehee .................................................................... 16

2.3.2 Da Kea ......................................................................17

2.3.3 Reeda Fg Pefee ................................................ 18

2.3.4 Na Tehd............................................................................ 22

2.3.5 Ide Pefee Mea ................................................. 22


10/125

2.3.6 Pehee Rag .................................................................. 23

2.3.7 R Pega Aa..........................................................24

BAB 3 METODOLOGI.......................................................................................... 25

3.1 Sd Lea ................................................................................... 25

3.2 Sd Laaga..................................................................................26

3.2.1 Obea/Pegaaa............................................................. 26

3.2.2 Iee/Waacaa .............................................................. 26

3.2.3 Aaa Kebha Se......................................................... 27

3.2.4 Kebha Fga .............................................................. 27

3.3 Peacaga Se.......................................................................... 27

3.3.1 De Se........................................................................27

3.4 Ieea Se......................................................................... 28

3.5 Pega Se............................................................................... 29

3.6 Pegaba Kea da Saa.................................................. 29

BAB 4 PERANCANGAN ....................................................................................... 31

4.1 Aaa Kebha Peaga La ................................................. 32

4.1.1 Peea Pegga ( ) ..................................................... 32

4.1.2 Dafa Kebha ..................................................................... 32

4.2 Sbe Maaee Ba Pegeaha ............................... ........ 33

4.3 Fa Peeeaa Peaaaha.............................................. 36

4.4 Sbe Maaee Daa ............................................................. 38

4.5 Sbe Maaee Mde........................................................... 43

4.5.1 Daga A Se .................................................................. 43

4.5.2 Maaa .............................................................................. 53

4.6 Sbe Maaee Aa Ma ..................................................72

4.6.1 Peacaga Aa Ma Ad .............................................. 73

4.6.2 Peacaga Aa Ma Haaa Peah ............................... 77 BAB 5 IMPLEMENTASI........................................................................................ 80

5.1 Sefa Se .............................................................................. 81

5.1.1 Sefa Peaga Kea....................................................... 81

5.1.2 Sefa Peaga La...................................................... 81

5.2 Ieea Aga.................................................................... 81


11/125

5.2.1 AHP .......................................................................................... 81

5.2.2 Pehee................................................................................83

5.3 Ieea Aaa.................................................................. 89

5.3.1 Ieea Haaa ................................................... 89

5.3.2 Ieea Haaa Ad.................................................. 89

5.3.3 Haaa Peah .......................................................................94

BAB 6 PENGUJIAN.............................................................................................. 97

6.1 Pega Tga Aa ................................................................. 97

6.2 Aaa Ha Pega Tga Aa............................................. 98

6.3 Pega Te Pefee..................................................................99

6.4 Aaa Ha Pega Te Pefee ...........................................100

BAB 7 PENUTUP............................................................................................... 102

7.1 Kea ..................................................................................... 102

7.2 Saa............................................................................................... 102

DAFTAR PUSTAKA............................................................................................ 103

Laa ......................................................................................................... 105


12/125

DAA AB

Tabe 2.1 Ide Rad................................................................................... 12

Tabe 2.2 Ch a ebadga beaaga ....................................... 13

Tabe 2.3 Saa Peaa Pebadga Beaaga........................................ 14

Tabe 2.4 Daa Daa Aa Pehee........................................................... 16

Tabe 4.1 Peea Ue.................................................................................. 32

Tabe 4.2Dafa Kebha Fga .............................................................. 33

Tabe 4.3 Dafa Kebha N Fga...................................................... 33

Tabe 4.4 Kea Keda............................................................................ 34

Tabe 4.5 Kea Sa ...................................................................................... 35

Tabe 4.6 Kea Keaa Te................................................................ 36

Tabe 4.7 Tabe Ue ..........................................................................................38

Tabe 4.8 Tabe a AHP .............................................................................. 38

Tabe 4.9 Tabe bb a .......................................................................... 39

Tabe 4.10 Tabe Pea.................................................................................... 39

Tabe 4.11 Tabe Kea .................................................................................... 40

Tabe 4.12 Tabe P....................................................................................... 40

Tabe 4.13 Tabe Te_efee....................................................................... 40

Tabe 4.14 Tabe Rag_ea .....................................................................40

Tabe 4.15 Tabe cee ..................................................................................... 41

Tabe 4.16 Tabe gad ............................................................................. 41

Tabe 4.17 Tabe e fad ........................................................................ 42

Tabe 4.18 Tabe Shg Gad ....................................................................... 42

Tabe 4.19 Tabe a fad .......................................................................... 43

Tabe 4.20 Peea Ma Pebadga Beaaga P P Gad .. 54

Tabe 4.21 Peea Ma Pebadga Beaaga P Shg Gad

.......................................................................................................................... 54

Tabe 4.22 Peea Ma Pebadga Beaaga P Sa Fad

.......................................................................................................................... 54

Tabe 4.23 Peea Ma Pebadga Beaaga P Pe Fad

.......................................................................................................................... 55

Tabe 4.24 Peea Ma Pebadga Beaaga P Cee ................ 55


13/125

Tabe 4.25 Ma Pebadga Beaaga P P Gad ag

Dedehaaa da Daha...................................................................... 56

Tabe 4.26 Ma Pebadga Beaaga P Shg Gad ag

Dedehaaa da Daha...................................................................... 56 Tabe 4.27 Ma Pebadga Beaaga P Sa Fad ag

Dedehaaa da Daha...................................................................... 56

Tabe 4.28 Ma Pebadga Beaaga P Pe Fad ag

Dedehaaa da Daha...................................................................... 57

Tabe 4.29 Ma Pebadga Beaaga P Cee ag

Dedehaaa da Daha...................................................................... 57

Tabe 4.30 Naa a da eaha ea ba eaa

P P Gad.............................................................................................. 58

Tabe 4.31 Naa Ma da Peaha Sea Ba TeaaP Shg Gad........................................................................................ 58

Tabe 4.32 Naa Ma da Peaha Sea Ba Teaa

P Sa Fad ..........................................................................................58


P Pe Fad ........................................................................................ 59


P Cee...................................................................................................... 59

Tabe 4.35 Ha Bb Pa P P Gad........... ................................. 60

Tabe 4.36 Ha Bb Pa P Shg Gad ...................................... 60

Tabe 4.37 Ha Bb Pa P Sa Fad ........................................60

Tabe 4.38 Ha Bb Pa P Pe Fad....................................... 61

Tabe 4.39 Ha Bb Pa P Cee .................................................... 61

Tabe 4.40 Daa Pea Ba Bae .................................................................. 63

Tabe 4.41 Na da ea ......................................................................... 64

Tabe 4.42 Deaa efee ................................................................... 65

Tabe 4.43 Deaa efee e.................................................................... 66

Tabe 4.44 Deaa eefee ee .................................................................. 68 Tabe 4.45 Tabe a de efee e ............................................. 69

Tabe 4.46 Tabe a de efee e .............................................. 69

Tabe 4.47 Tabe de efee e ...................................................... 70

Tabe 4.48 Na da Rag Aeaf ......................................... 71

Tabe 4.49 Na da Rag Aeaf........................................71


14/125

Tabe 4.50 Na da Rag Aeaf ............................................... 72

Tabe 5.1 Sefa Peaga Kea Ke ................................................ 81

Tabe 5.2 Sefa Peaga La Ke ............................ ................... 81

Tabe 6.1 Pebadga Ha Kea Peah dega Se........................ 97

Tabe 6.2 Ha Pega Te Pefee ................................................. 99

Tabe 6.3 Ha Pega Te Pefee ............................................... 100

Tabe 6.4 Pega Te Pefee ................................................ 100


15/125

DAA ABA

Gaba 2.1 S hea a eaaaha............................................. 13

Gaba 2.2 Daga Pe .............................................................16

Gaba 2.3 Be Pefee Kea Baa...................................................... 18

Gaba 2.4 Be Pefee Kea Qa.....................................................19

Gaba 2.5 Kea efee e................................................................. 20

Gaba 2.6 Be Pefee Kea Lee...................................................... 20

Gaba 2.7 Be Pefee Kea Le da Aea ag Tda Bebeda....... 21

Gaba 2.8 Be Pefee Kea Gaa................................................ 22

Gaba 3.1 Daga A Pe ........................................................................ 25

Gaba 3.2 B Daga Se.......................................................................28

Gaba 4.1 Ph Peacaga........................................................................ 31

Gaba 4.2 D ...........................................................37

Gaba 4.3 Daga a Peea Pea T Uaa Ba Bae ...... 45

Gaba 4.4 Daga a ehga a eaa ................................. 46

Gaba 4.5 Daga a ehga bb a........................................ 47

Gaba 4.6 Daga a ehga ege a .............................. ...... 48

Gaba 4.7 Daga a ehga CI da CR ................................................ 49

Gaba 4.8 Daga a ehga e........................................................50

Gaba 4.9 Daga A Pehga Deaa Pefee .................................. 51

Gaba 4.10 Daga ehga Ide Pefee........................................ 52

Gaba 4.11 Daga ehga a , da

.......................................................................................................................... 53

Gaba 4.12 Halaman Login.............................................................................73

Gaba 4.13 Haaa .............................................................................74

Gaba 4.14 Halaman Data Kriteria .................................................................. 74

Gaba 4.15 Halaman Data Alternatif ............................................................... 75

Gaba 4.16 Halaman Pilih Posisi untuk Perhitungan Bobot ............................. 76

Gaba 4.17 Halaman Perangkingan Pemain .................................................... 76

Gaba 4.18 Halaman Susunan Pemain.............................................................77

Gaba 4.19 Halaman Login .............................................................................77


16/125

Gaba 4.20 Halaman Perangkingan Pemain .................................................... 79

Gaba 4.21 Haaa Sa Pea ............................................................ 79

Gaba 5.1 Pohon Implementasi ....................................................................... 80

Gaba 5.2 Taa haaa ................................................................. 89

Gaba 5.3 Taa Haaa ................................................................ 90

Gaba 5.4 Taa Haaa Daa Kea ..................................................... 90

Gaba 5.5 Taa Haaa Daa Aeaf.................................................. 91

Gaba 5.6 Taa Haaa AHP .................................................................. 91

Gaba 5.7 Taa Haaa Peha Bb ............................................... 92

Gaba 5.8 Taa Haaa Pehga AHP .............................................. 92

Gaba 5.9 Taa Haaa Pehga Pehee ................................... 93

Gaba 5.10 Taa Haaa Peaga ................................................... 93

Gaba 5.11 Taa Haaa Dea Peaga ......................................... 94

Gaba 5.12 Taa Haaa Sa Pea ............................................. 94

Gaba 5.13 Taa haaa eah...................................................95

Gaba 5.14 Taa Haaa Peaga ................................................... 95

Gaba 5.15 Taa Haaa Dea Peaga ......................................... 96

Gaba 5.16 Taa haaa a ea / ............................................ 96


17/125

1

BAB 1 DAA

1.1 B

Oahaga eaa aah a egaa ag daa

egaa ebgaa f eeag. Baa ea e ahaga ag daa

daa eeag ea dega eaa da baa ag d. D

Idea ed da ea baa e ahaga, bae ead aah a

ag ag dgea. Bae aa daa bahaa Igg eaa

ahaga bee ag ed aa da beaggaa agag

a ea ag beadg ecea dega eaa ba e

eaag. Oahaga dagga ebaga ahaga ag ef aea

e e eaa ag cee dbadga dega ahaga a

ee ea ba da [Mha, 2013].

U Afa Ba Bae Uea Baaa (UABBUB) eaaadah bag ahaa Uea Baaa eaa baaa

daa bdag ahaga bae ag ga ea eaba daa

egebaga aa da aa ea. D bae beebag e aah

fea da ha daga a eh eag ag fea. Ha

eghaa eah e daa eha baa eag ea da

eea ag ea dega eaa ag d. Dabah ag

dega beaa a ahaa begabg dega bae

ag ea aha ea beabah eba eha dafa

a e ead ebh . Kea daa dha da ea

ag aaaa e eaa ag ha eaa a aa a ehgga

beaba ada a eea ba ea ag aa a e daaebah . Tda haa eha da fa aa a ada fa fa

a ag eea eag ea daa a e daa , aah

aa adaah a. Sa eaa fa ag ag eg daa

eaa e aa ed. Seag ea ag e

eaa d aa aaaa a bea ag ba eada eah

a ea a daa eggagg efa aa beadg aea

da a beea aa aa eg ag dbea eh eah.

Pada aha eea ea ag aah daa a eadga

aa aa bedaa ada eaaa ea ag da aa da

daa beg eaaha.

Da eaaaha aa daa dba ebah e eea ea ba bae ag aa daa deaa daa

eba UABBUB daa eea ea ba bae eeb.

Peha ea ag daa a e daa eaa eaaaha

ea, ehgga daa deeaa dega ede ag ea daa

C D (CD). Mede ag dgaa

eba eacaga e eea ea adaah ede A


18/125

2

(A) ebba daa aaa adaah

ee aa daa ha adaah ag ag ege egea bae

aa eah da

() ag eaa a be ede edg

ea ag ddaaa ada egggaa a da hbga eaa eaga. Keda ede dh aea e ga

eaaa ag ebh ba dbadga dega gabga ede aa.

Sea , ede dh aea ebh efe, da ga dah

deaa daa eaa eaaaha ea.

Pada eea ebea eh He Saada, Wahd, da He

Sa ag bed Se Pedg Kea See Peeaa Sa

Ba Meggaa Mede A da ea ha ag ba.

Sae ada eea eggaa deaa daa ea. Keda da

bb ea ag dah ddaa aa daa e ega eea

ag aa eea aeaf ag a a eea eba dega ha

hgga ecaa ga aa 90%. Sehgga daa da baha

ede A da aga cc dgaa eha ea

daa ahaga bae.

Bedaaa aa beaag eeb, aa e g ebag

ebah eea ag bed Peea Pea I T Ba Bae

Meggaa Mede A (A) da

(). Dega

adaa eea dhaaa daa eba ebea ada U

Aa Ba Bae Uea Baaa daa eea ea ag

aa beadg dega ebh cea, ea da aa.

1.2

Bedaaa aa beaag ag dah deaa, daa da

eaaaha eea adaah ebaga be :

1. Bagaaa ede ( A) da

()

daa deeaa daa e eea ea ba

bae U Aa Ba Bae Uea Baaa (UABBUB) ?

2. Bagaaa ga aa ag dhaa e eggaa

ede A da daa eea daa b

ahaga bae?

3. Bagaaa ha ebadga ag dhaa da e efee

, , da ada ede A da ?


19/125

3

1.3 B

U eghda eaa ebahaa daa eea , aa

e adaa baaabaaa eedehaaa eaaaha, a :

1. Se eea dbag haa ebaga ebaU Aa Ba Bae Uea Baaa (UABBUB) daa

eea ea ag aa beadg bedaaa ea

ag eah dea. Na ea ah ea ada ha

eah.

2. Daa ag dgaa beaa da U Aa Ba Bae Uea

Baaa (UABBUB) Maag da ga eah.

3. Mede ag dgaa daa eea adaah ede AHP da

.

4. Na ea ea ag dgaa bedaaa eah adaah

ebaga be :

a. Keda :- Kehada daa aha

- Tea a daa aha

b. Sa :

- Sa eada eah

-

c. Keaa e :

-

- D

-

-

- A-

5. Ha ah da eea adaah a ea ag a

bedaaa a egg aa eedah,

6. Te efee ag dgaa ehga adaah

e , da .

1.4

Ta ag g dcaa daa eea adaah

egeeaa ede A ( A) da

()

daa eea ea ba bae ada U Aa Ba Bae

Uea Baaa (UABBUB).


20/125

4

1.5

Mafaa ag g dbea da eea adaah ebaga be:

1. Daa eba ebea eeda eada U Aa Ba

Bae Uea Baaa (UABBUB) daa eea ea bae.

2. Medaaa eahaa eag eacaga eea ea

bae eggaa ede A da .

1.6

Pea bedaaa eaa ea ebaga be :

1. BAB

Bab d dega aa beaag, a aaah, baaa aaah, a,

afaa, da eaa ea.2. BAB D

Bab eeaa eag e e ag dgaa ea aa aa ag

edg daa eacaga da ebaa Peea Pea I T

Bae Meggaa Mede A ( A) da

().

3. BAB

Bab egaa eag ede ag dgaa daa ea ag

ed da d ea, d aaga, da aaa ebha ag dea

daa eaa eea.

4. BAB

Bab ebaha eag eacag e fa ag ea dega

ebha e

5. BAB

Bab ebaha eag egeeaa da acaga eeb.

6. BAB A

Bab ebaha eag ha ega da aa ehada e ag

deaaa da ebaha aa.

7. BAB

Pada bab be ea da eea ag eah daa ea aa

egebaga ebh a


21/125

5

BAB 2 DAA

Pada , daa e ag dea bedaaa aa beaagda a aaah adaah: e daa ahaga bae, e daa

A (A) da e daa

(Pehee).

2.1 B

2.1.1 D B

Ba bae eaa a eaa ag daa eh da eg

ba a a ag agag eg ed da a ag

ea. Peaa bea eca a aa aga ebaa

baaa dega caa eaa ba e eaag aa bae ada aaa aa da ecegah aa edaaa aga aa a. Ba daa

daa dega caa edg ba, e ba dega eaa aga

eba, da eeaa ba aa eggg ba e egaa e d daa

aaga eaa. Ada ga aa daa bea bae a

a ea ag ga aaa adaah ecea dega eaa

ba e eaag aa, a ea ag ga aaa adaah

eaga ea aa aga ea aa ea eaa ba da

eah a ea ag ead h c eaa dega

ega a ba da aeg ag daa eh ea ea [Febaa,

2013]. Ba bae ea e daa ahaga ba bea ag befa

ef aea e eaa cedeg ebh cea a dbadgadega ahaga ba a ee ba da . Oahaga cc daa d

daa aga ( ) a d a aga ( ) [H, 2011].

2.1.2 D B

Peaa bae e e daa ag ha daha eh

ea ea aa bea bae. Be adaah ee daa daa

bae ag ha daa [Sa, 2002] :

1. Oea ()

Te ag eaa daa eaa ecaa beeg. Taa e

eaa da aa beaa. Na e deah bahabebeaa e ag daa bedaaa a eaaa.

Be bebeaa e ag ha daa :

a. Oea Dada (C )

C eaa e ea da aga egg dada

dega aha eaa aga eghada ea. Te

eea dga a. Ha eeb daa dhaa dega


22/125

6

a e dea ab eagaha a a e dea. Oea

daa ada aa aa a da daa eagaa aa.

b. Oea Paa (B )

B eaa e ea dega aa. Te geaha aa dega , haa eaa daaha e aa

ebe ba dea ea . Oea daa ada a

aa beada d aaa eea da eea ba dega

eafaaa gga daaa ega da ga eaga.

c. Oea Aa Keaa ( )

eaa ea dega aa ba da aa

eaa. Oea daa ada a eagaa aa ag

eghaba aa ea ba. Ha egeab

eagaa dega ege ba eea aa eaa aa.

d. Oea Sa Taga ( )

eaa ea a aga da aa eaa da

dgaa ea aa ah. Oea daa ee

eea ebg. Oea baa deaa ada a eea

ba aga ah eea bebeaa ea aa da ada

aha eeaga cea aa a.

2. Meggg ba ()

D aa eggg ba eaa aah a e

eghda eagaa aa. Mea e a daa eaa

eea e daeah eahaa aa. Ha ag ha dehaa

adaah e deaa ada aa dea aa, a aa

eea eagaa aa da eea edea g aa da

eaa eeeaa dega . Bebeaa e ada

a eaa d aaga d aaaa adaah :

a. C D

C eaa aah a e

egeab, eghda da eea aa. D daa

dega ebah aah egeaa egaaa ba da aga aa

e aga da ebaa. Te deaa ada a aa

eaa eagaa da e aah egeaa .

b. B B D

Te eaa e egeab eagaa aa

dega edaha egaaa ba ea beaag bada.

D daa ada a eagaa aa ag ea da

ed egeaa e a . Caaa dega

edaha egaaa ba aa ea aa V


23/125

7

eaga ag a ea beaag bada ehgga aa da

daa egab aa eggagaa egaaa ag a

aa eeaga.

3. Tebaa ( ) eaa e ag ag eg ebaga aha eeeaa

e eaa ag daa. Taa eeeaa ag ba, a

ah eaa ba bae eghaa baa da aa

ecaa. Na ha eeb da eea da dga ee

aa ee da daa eeaa eaa .

Be bebeaa e daa eaa ebaa :

a. Se Sh

eaa ebaa daa daa eaa ba bae.

Te dgaa ada aa da ada eagaa aa aga ah

da aaa..

Te eaa e eeba dega aa.

Te daa eghda eagaa ada aa aha

eaa ba e g.

.

eaa e eaa ba dega aaa

da agah aa . Te deaa ada aa

eaa egeaa e e g aa dega caa

eaa da agah aa eaa ba e g. Pada

a a aa eagaa aaa, egeaa eea

aa daa daa dega egeaa edea g aa

da eeaa e .

4.

eaa ebah aha egaa aa da

ga daa aha. dbag ead da e, a daa

aha adea da daa aha . Daa aha adea

aa daa aha ag da aa adaah eaa ag

(e eedaa daah) da aa (eaaa) befg

ecaa a aa eaa afa eha ha daa a c

aaaa egaa eeaha bea. Daa aha aga eg eag ea a dega egab ge ea

eaaa da ega e ag edag af aa

beea ea eedaa daah. Sedaga daa aha

eaa aaa eaa a ecaa e

ee ada ga ea b aa. Laha f dega

ea edah a beda aag daa egaa


24/125

8

aaa daa eea daa aha bh ea ehgga

daa eeagaa eaaa daa da aa aa

egaa eeaha. Ch aha adea ag daa

deaa adaah a dega aa a ga h e aa da

a dega eceaa ag beaa. Sedaga daa aha ed agac ada a e ag a eaa

a be a ag aa aa aha

da . Mea aha , ea daa ehda da bahaa cdea

aea egaa d (ebeaa e ) ea

eghaa ag a ag befg

aa a . Pada eaa ba bae

dgaa abaha a a ead ag aa ada

ae ea dega abaha a ae dega da a e.

5. A

A aa ecaha adaah eaa eeag daaegbah aah dega cea da ea ada a begea aa

ehaga eebaga. Fa ag eegah ecaha adaah

eceaa da eea. Kedaa ha e eebaga

aaa a dega ag aa aga daa begea dega eaa.

Keebaga dgaa eeahaa bh ba

daa a a da. Ha ha ag ha dehaa

daa eah adaah a efe, a ea, da eceaa

begea. Ada bebeaa aha ag daa egaa a

ea e (gag ), a baba (he ), gbed

(ah), da aaa.

6.

aa ah a adaah daa eeaa ea ea

daa bea dega ba, ebab daa ahaga bae aga

e eaa begea dega cea, behe dega

cea ebah aah dega cea, ega a ag ea aa

eeag a beaha aga daa eaa a e

eahaa aa eag daa beaha aa baa da

eaa geaa da e eeb aga egag ada

eaa ea ea eg geaa bha. Laha

ag daa daa egaa aa ah a

ha aa dega aha ecaha. Ch bebeaa aha agdaa daa daa egaa ah a aa adaah

ee , , , da . Iea ag gg

daa ebea eaa da ga ecaha a ag ba ehgga

daa eaa ee daa aa ag ada daa bae.


25/125

9

2.1.3 B

Daa eaa ba bae edaa a aa ea a

, , , da . Be

adaah eeaa da bebeaa daa bae [Mha, 2013]:1.

adaah aah a ada daa eaa ba

bae. Baaa ea ag eg e bh ag

ag ede daa . Keaa eag aa ebh

baa d bedaaa ah (a ag eghaa

) daada ah aga ag dba. Tga aa eag

adaah ega eaga dega eg ba da

egeaa e ea ag ea d aa ag ea

ecea .

2.

aa deb ga dega adaah ag

d dega eeba eba daa ebah .

dhaaa e eaa ba ag ba aea eea daa

bega eba da eggaa aa edag

eeag e g aa. Ua eaa

eeba ag ba da ga eee ( da ea ga baa ga

aga). Pea ag dgaa daa baaa be ebh

gg daada a ebh ede daada ea

da . Seag ha a eeba

da bebaga d daa aaga da e geaa ag eaf

ehgga daga daa eadga.

3.

adaah aah a daa eaa ba bae ag

ebha ea dega bebaga aa eaa. Baaa

d dega ea ag e eaa a aa

a () eba daa . P ha bea agef da

a, a ebaa ba dega cah da ga ecea .

Daa ecea , baaa ah daa eeba

da a ga ga aga (eee) a da baga daa g

dega bebaga aa eaa. Sea ebha aa ag

a da eceaa ag gg, bea d ga d baeaa , eaa aa daa eadaa beaha.

4.

deb ga dega aea baaa d

dega ea ag be gg da a. Saah a ga aa

adaah eaga ba ag ea da g

( ) ba daa eadaa beaha a eeag.


26/125

10

Dbadga dega , aa baa begea d

dea g eeba da aa dea aa eaa aa

eba eaggaa ( ) aa da. Daa beaha,

aa eghaag aa ag edag eaga ehgga

daa ecea dega eaa

5. C

C aa ea egah daa eaa bae adaah ea

dega bh ebea aa egg d ag egab d

aea ga ebaa beba ( ). Saah a eaa

aa ag ha d eag ea egah adaah eafaaa

ggga eghaag aa da eaga ba a ag

da a e g ( ). Keebha da eag ea egah

ag be gg adaah ea aa daa ecea

da dea g. Pea egah aa baa eaa ebaa da

daeah dea g da ha baaa aa eghaa baaeaggaa da aa ag cba eghaag. Oeh aea ea

egah eg edaa eeaa eaa eaa beba.

2.2 ()

Pada ah 1970, eag ah aeaa egebaga ebah

ede beaa A (AHP). Mede eaa

eaga daa egab ea dega efef da eaaaha ag

e, e, ee a da e dega caa

eedehaaa da eecea e egaba ea dega

eecaha eaaaha e daa bagabagaa, eaa aabe e

daa a ha hea, ebea a e ada ebagabef eag ega ea aabe da ee bebaga

ebaga eeaa aabe aa ag e a

egg da daa eegah ha ada a eeb [Saada, 2011].

Mede eecah eaaaha ag e da daa

a ag da e ead bagabaga e. AHP

eggabga aaa ebaga dega eaa bad dega caa

ag g da degah aa, egaaa da egeaha

e ebah ha da a aaah ag bedaaa ga, da

ga egaaa ebea ebaga. AHP eaa a

e egdefa, ege da ebea eaa ea eecaa eeha [S, 2005].

Pa eaa a be aba ag bea ada ea

aa. Peea a daa eggaa e aa hea.

Keebha AHP dbadga dega ede a adaah [S, 2009]:

1. S ag behea ebaga ee da ea ag dh

aa ada bb ea ag ag daa.


27/125

11

2. Meehga ada aa baa ea ea ebaga

ea da aeaf ag dh eh aa egab ea.

3. Meehga daa aha aa eahaa aa efa

egaba ea.Mede AHP ea eaa daa eecaha aaah ag

de ecaa be da ea ag ddaaa ada ebadga

efee da a eee daa hea. Sehgga daa da baha

de eaa de ag befa eehef aa daa aa

ebaa ea eea ha aa aaga ebadga ag

edehaa, ebag ea a a aeaf. AHP

eggaa daa ag befa aaf bedaaa ada ee,

egaaa, ehgga daa daa a eegaa daa e

da eag edea ecaa aaf [SUL09].

2.2.1 ATedaa bebeaa agah ag e dehaa daa eggaa

ede AHP, a [Aa, 2010] :

1. Medefa aaah da eea ag dga.

2. Meba hea ag daa dega a daa

dega bb a, ea da ega aeafaeaf

ada gaa ea ag ag baah.

3. Meba a ebadga beaaga ag eggabaa

b eaf ea eee ehada agag a aa

ea ag ega daaa. Pebadga daa bedaaa

ea da eba dega ea ga eega a

eee dbadga eee aa.

4. Meaa ebadga a ebaa [ (1)/2 ] bah dega

adaah baaa eee ag dbadga.

5. Meghg a ege da eg ea a da e

aa egaba daa dag.

6. Megag agah 3, 4 da 5 eh ga hea.

7. Meghg e ege da ea a ebadga beaaga.

Na e ege eaa bb ea eee. Lagah

ee ea daa eea a eeeeee ada

ga hea eedah aa egg.

8. Meea e hea. Ja a ebh da 10% (ee) aa 0,1

aa eaa daa ha deba.Lagahagah daa eggaa ede AHP ag daa daa

adaah ebaga be [Aa, 2010]:

1. Meea ee ea ca ea bae.

2. Me eaea eeb daa be a beaaga.

3. Meaha a .


28/125

12

4. Meghg a eee ea dega agag

eee dbag dega ah a .

5. Meghg a a ea dega eaha a

ba ha agah 4 da haa agah 5 dbag dega ah ea.

6. Meea aeafaeaf ag aa ead ha.7. Me aeafaeaf ag eah dea daa be

a beaaga agag ea. Sehgga aa ada

baa bah a beaaga aa aeaf.

8. Magag a beaaga aa aeaf ebaa bah

a, agag aa daha e.

9. Meghg a a aeaf agag a beaaga

aa aeaf dega ee agah 4 da 5.

10. Meg e ea a beaaga aa aeaf dega

agag eee a beaaga ada agah 2 daa

dega a a ea. Haa ag ag ba daha,

eda haa dbag dega agag a a eaebaa λ1, λ2, λ3, , λ

11. Meghg a ada a dega λa = ..(2.1)

12. Meghg a Ide Ke dega CI = ........(2.2)

13. Meghg Ra Ke dega CR = ..(2.3)

daa: RI adaah a de ad ag beaa da abe ad

ee abe 2.1

2.1 Ide Rad

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 0,00 0,00 0,58 0,90 1,12 1,24 1,32 1,41 1,45 1,49 1,51

: [Aa, 2010]

Ja C < 0,1, aa a ebadga beaaga ada a ea ag

dbea e. Ja C ≥ 0,1, aa a ebadga beaaga ada

a ea ag dbea da e. Sehgga a da e,

aa ega aa ada a beaaga ada ea a

aeaf ha dag.

2.2.2 D A

Daa eeeaa eaaaha dega eggaa ede AHPada ag ha daa, a [Saada, 2011]

1. Me hea da eaaaha ag dhada

Pea hea a dega eea a ag eaa

aaa e ecaa eeha daa ee eaa. Lee bea ed

da eaea ea aa eebaga aeafaeaf

ag ada da eea aeafaeaf eeb. Sea ea daa


29/125

13

e bea dbaaha da ea ea daa e ea

agag. Keda gabaa e daa be hea da eaaaha

ag dhada ee gaba 2.6 be :

2.1

: [Saada, 2011]

2. Meea a eee

Lagah eaa daa eea a eee adaah dega

eba ebadga beaaga, a ebadga eee ecaa

beaaga ea ea ag dbea. U ebadga beaaga

dgaa be a. Ma befa edehaa, beedda a ag

eaaa eaga eea e, eeeh fa

abaha dega eba ea ebadga ag g daegaa eeaa a ecaa eeha ebah

ebaga. U ea e ebadga beaaga, da da

ee ag aa hea eh ea, aa C, eda da ee

dbaaha dab eeeeee ag aa dbadga, aa A1, A2,

A3 aa a eeeeee ag dbadga eeb aa ee ada

abe 2.1 be

2.2 C

C A1 A2 A3

A1 1

A2 1

A3 1

: [Saada, 2011]


30/125

14

Seeah daa ega a beaaga a daa

dega eggaa baga eeeeaa eega eaf

da a eee dega eee aa ag dad dega aa 1 aa

dega 9. Saa edefaa da eeaa a 1 aa dega 9

ebaga daa ebadga beaaga eee ada ea eehea ehada a ea d ee ag ebh gg. Aaba a eee

aa daa a dbadga dega da ed, aa dbe a 1.

Ja a dbadga a a aa aa aa edaaa a

ee, aa dbadga aa a ebaaa. Pada abe 2.2

ebea def da eeaa aa aaf 1 aa dega 9

ea ga eega a eee dega eee aa.

2.3 B

Iea

Keega

Def Peeaa

1 Keda eee aa ega Da eee eegah ag aa bea

ehada a

3 Eee ag a ed ebh

eg daada eee aa

Pegaaa da eaa

ed eg a

eee dbadga

dega eee aa

5 Eee ag a ebh eg

daada eee aa

Pegaaa da eaa

aga a eg

a eee dega

eee aa

7 Sa eee ea ebh aeg daada eee aa

Sa eee ag adg da da

eha daa ae

9 Sa eee a eg

daada eee aa

B ag edg

eee ag a

ehada eee a

e ga

eegaa egg a

g egaa

2,4,6,8 Naa aaa da a

ebagaebaga

ag bedeaa

Na dbea ba ada

daaa da

haKebaa Ja afa edaa 1 aga dbadg afa , aa

ea a ebaaa debadg dega

: [Saada, 2011]


31/125

15

3. Peea Pa

U ea ea da aeaf, e daa ebadga

beaaga. Naa ebadga eaf da eh aeaf ea ba

deaa dega eea ag eah dea eghaa bb

da a. Bb aa a dhg dega aa a aa

ea eeeaa eaaa aeaa.

4. Ke Lg

Ke e da aa, eaa adaah bebe ag ea

ba dea ea dega eeagaa da eea. Keda,

eag ga hbga aa be ag ddaaa ada ea

ee.

2.3 ()

() adaah a da bebeaa ede eaga aa eea

a (a) daa aa ea. Mede dea ebaga ede

ag efe da , a ea dah deaa dbadga dega

ede a eaa aaah ea. Mede a

egad ea eha ag befa aaf da aaf

[Pab, 11].

adaah a ede eea a (a) daa

D (CD). Peaaaha aa d daa ede adaah eedehaaa, eeaa, da eaba. Dgaa da ba

ea ag dgaa daa adaah eggaa a daa

hbga [Naed, 2009].

P ag dgaa daa Pehee adaah eeaa a

aeaf ag eah deaa bedaaa ebaga

( ), dega adah daa [Aa, 2013]:

Ma f1(), f2(),f3(),f(),, f() ɛ

Daa adaah a aeaf, da f ( =1,2,3,,) eaa

a/a eaf aeaf agag aeaf.

Pehee ea daa eaga ede ag debaga

eh B. R da e da fae a :

1. Mebag hbga da .

2. Ea da hbga ebea aaba a ea

daa aadga eaaah ea


32/125

16

Daa fae eaa, a hbga bedaaa

ebaga da agag ea. Ide efee dea da

a ecaa gaf daa bedaaa efee da eba

ea. Daa daa eaa daa ehee daa ebaga

be:

2.4 D D A

Aeaf f 1(.) f 2(.) ... f (.) ... f (.)

a1 f 1(a1) f 2(a1) ... f (a1) ... f (a1)

a2 f 1(a2) f 2(a2) ... f (a2) ... f (a2)

... ... ... ... ... ... ...

a f 1(a) f 2(a) ... f (a) ... f (a)

... ... ... ... ... ... ...

a f 1(a) f 2(a) ... f (a) ... f (a)

: Saf, 2013]

S ea d aa ea egea baha ea aeaf a

da b ag eaa eee ha A, aaba a aeaf a

ea ag deaa aeaf a ebh da aeaf b, aa aeaf

a ebh dh ( ) dbadga aeaf b, edaga a a da

aeaf aa dega a da aeaf b, aa daa da baha

aeaf a da ea ebedaa () dega fg b, ehgga

eea aeaf aa ag ebh daa daa dega

eehaa a aeaf aa.

2.3.1

2.2 D

Sbe: [Paaa, 2014]

Lagahagah ag dgaa ede adaah ebaga be

[Paaa, 2014]:

1. Megdefa aeaf.

2. Peeaa da ea, aeaf (a) deaa ada bebeaa ea

(), ag ha daaa aa daa.

Megdefa Penjelasan darikriteria

Rekomendasi

fun si kriteria

Promethee ranking Menentukan indeks

referensi

Evaluasi matriks


33/125

17

3. Reeda fg efee eea aa. Daa

Pehee daa ea fg ea. Ha e aa da

a, ea be c ba bebeaa a.

4. Eaa a. Saa ea da aeaf dah eh, agaheaa adaah eba a aff. Tabe a

ea aaga eaea, a aaf da aaf da

efe ag dhaa eh aeaf behbga dega ea

eeb. Sa a daa ed da daa a ada aa

aa da.

5. Meea de efee ea. Pefee daaaa

dega aga aaa 0 da 1, da da dega ed ee

6. Pehee ag. Aah daa gaf a agg dea

bedaaa eag f da eeg f. Leag f adaah

ah a ga egg ag e aah eah da de a

da ha eaa aae ega agg. Peeaa

da hbga ag dbag aa ebaga a

ada gaf a ag, bea a aa (Pehee) da

a ega (Pehee) ada eah a ag g, ag

daa da ada eba ea eeaa

eeeaa aaah aae daa.

2.3.2 D

Na f eaa a aa da a ea [Aa, 2013]:

..........................................................................................................(2.4)

U ea aeaf aeaf eaa eaa daaeaf eeb a ea. Pada aa da aeaf dbadga,

, ha daa dea ebadga efeea.

Peaaa ea (P) da efee a ehada aeaf b edea

a ehgga :

1. P (a,b) = 0, ea da ada ebedaa aaa aeaf a da

aeaf b bedaaa ea ea.

2. P (a,b) 0, ea efee ag eah aeaf a >


3. P (a,b) 1, ea efee ag a aeaf a >aeaf b bedaaa ea ea.

4. P (a,b) = 1, bea a efee da a ebh ba da b.

Daa ede , fg efee eg a eghaa a fg ag

bebeda aaa da eaa, ehgga :

P(A,B) = P(f(A)f(B))....................................................................(2.5)


34/125

18

daa [Paaa, 2014]:

A = Aeaf A

B = Aeaf B

P(A,B) = Pefee de aeaf A ehada aeaf B

f(A) = a fg Aeaf A

f(B) = a fg Aeaf B

2.3.3

Ta aa da edeaa adaah

eedah e egaba ea dega caa egea

e ea ead ea fg ea ag c daa ea ea

e ea eeeaa aa da eaa afa deaaefee dega eggaa a da aaee ag e

aae e ag gfa. Ea efee eeb aaa a

[Tc, 2011]:

1. Kea Baa ( C)

.......................................................................(2.6)

daa:

d = eh a ead=f(a)f(b).

Pada a , da ada ebedaa (aa eg) aaa a da b a

da haa a f(a)=f(b). Aaba ea ada agag aeaf

e a bebeda, aa eba ea eba efee

a aeaf e a ag ebh ba [Naed, 2009]

Be efee ea baa daa ada Gaba 2.3

2.3 B B

: [Ha, 2009]


35/125

19

2. Kea Qa ( C)

..............................................................................(2.7)

daa:

d = eh a ea d = f(a) f(b)

= a ag eeaa egah ag gfa da a ea

Pada a , da aeaf e efee ag aa eg aa

eaa eh H(d) da agag aeaf ea ee

da eebh a , da aaba eh a eaa ag

ag aeaf eebh a aa ead be efee a.

Ja eba ea eggaa ea a, aa ha

eea a daa a daa eeaa egah ag

gfa da a ea [Naed, 2009]. Be efee

ea e daa dha ada gaba 2.4 be :

2.4 B

: [Ha, 2009]

3. Kea dega Pefee Le

......................................................................(2.8)

daa:

H(d) = fg eh ea aa aeaf


= a ecedega aa efee

Kea efee e daa eeaa baha eaa a eh

e a ag ebh edah da , efee da eba

ea ega ecaa e dega a d. Ja a d ebh bea

dbadga dega a , aa ead efee a. Pada aa

eba ea egdefa bebeaa ea e ,

ha dea a da ecedega aa (a ) [Naed,


36/125

20

2009]. Be efee ea ee daa dha ada gaba 2.5

be :

2.5

: [Ha, 2009]

4. Kea Lee ( C)

...................................................................(2.9)

daa:



= a ecedega aa efee

= a ag eeaa egah ag gfa da a

ea

Pada a , ecedega da bebeda da ecedega

efe adaah dea ecaa a. Ja d beada daaa a da , ha bea a efee ag eah (H(d) = 0,5)

[Naed, 2009]. Be efee ea ee daa dha ada

gaba 2.6 be :

2.6 B

: [Ha, 2009]


37/125

21

5. Kea dega Pefee Le da Aea ag Tda Bebeda

..............................................................(2.10)

daa:



= a ecedega aa efee

= a ag eeaa egah ag gfa da a

ea

Pada a , egab ea eebaga egaa

efee ecaa e da da bebeda hgga efee a daaaea aaa da ecedega da [Naed, 2009]. Be

efee ea e da aea ag da bebeda daa dha ada

gaba 2.7:

2

.7 B A B: [Ha, 2009]

6. Kea Gaa ( C)

....................................................(2.11)

daa:



Fg beaa aaba eah dea a daa daa dba

bedaaa db a daa a [Naed, 2009]. Be

efee ea Gaa daa dha ada gaba 2.13 be :


38/125

22

2.8 B

: [Ha, 2009]

2.3.4

Tedaa ea e da eaaaaa ea ba debaga

daa ede , a e ba ebh dah dea a

aaeea aea haa a aa da aaee ag e dea.

Haa e aa ag da e a aaee. Tee

adaah ebaga be [Paaa, 2014] :

1. ag baa dabaga daa aae aa .

Ja a ebedaa () d baah aa aa dega a ≤

aa dagga da e a ebedaa aa = 0

2. ag baa dabaga daa aae aa .

Ja a ebedaa () d aa aa aa dega a ≥

aa ebedaa eeb e a a = 1.

3. ag baa dabaga daa aae σ ea

deah dega ba ebaga aaee ag ecaa agg

behbga dega a ada dea ada db a.

Pehga a daa eggaa e eea

a da , be e ag daa dgaa [Paaa, 2014]

K1 = a a a

K2 = a e2 a

() = K1 K2

() = / ∑ aeaf

() =

2.3.5

Ide efee ea dea bedaaa aaaa bb

da fg efee P.

...........................................................(2.12)

Daa: P (a,b) = efee de aeaf a ehada aeaf b

= baaa aeaf ; = bb ea ea


39/125

23

eaa ea efee eba ea ag eaaa

baha aeaf a ebh ba da aeaf b dega ebaga ecaa

a da eeha ea. Ha daa daa dega a aaa 0

da 1, dega eea ebaga be [Aa, 2013]:

1. ea efee ag eah aeaf a >


2. ea efee ag a aeaf a >


Ide efee dea bedaaa a hbga ada

eah ea da agag aeaf. Hbga daa daa

ebaga gaf a , dedea eaa aeaf bedaaa

eaa ea ee [Aa, 2013].

2.3.6

Pehga aah efee debaga bedaaa a de

[Paaa, 2014]:

1.

Jah da ag e aah eah da α. da ha

eaa ega . U ea α daa gaf

a dea bedaaa , dega eaaa:

..................................................................(2.13)

Daa:

ea efee baha aeaf a ebh ba daaeaf .

= baaa aeaf

= a aeaf da abe de efee daha ecaa

ha

2.

adaah ah da ag e aah edea da de

a da ha eaa aae ega agg.

d bedaaa aae aed da a...................................................................(2.14)

Daa:

ea efee baha aeaf ebh ba da

aeaf a.

= baaa aeaf


40/125

24

= a aeaf da abe de efee daha ecaa

eca.

3.

d dega eghg eh da .

....................................................................(2.15)

Keeaga:

1. = ea ea efee baha aeaf a

ebh ba da aeaf .

2. = ea efee baha aeaf ebh ba da

aeaf a.

3. = , dgaa eea a a

ada e Pehee I dega eaaa (2.13) ageggaa a aa.

4. = , dgaa eea a a

ada e Pehee I dega eaaa (2.13) ag eggaa

a aa.

5. = , dgaa eghaa ea ah

eea a daa eeeaa aaah ehgga

eghaa a ega.

2.3.7 A

Pega aa daa daa dega eggaa eaaabe [Paaa, 2014]:

.........(216)

Pega aa daa dhg da ah daa ag ea dbag

dega ah da daa . Aa eaa ebeaa dea a aga

ha ega ehadaa aga ebeaa.


41/125

25

BAB 3 D

Daa bab aa ebaha edg ag dgaa daaeea , ag e: d eae, d aaga, aaa

ebha, eacaga e, eea e, ega e, ea

ea. Be daga a ag dgaa daa edg .

START

STUDI LITERATUR

ANALISA KEBUTUHAN SISTEM

STUDI LAPANGAN

PERANCANGAN SISTEM

IMPLEMENTASI SISTEM

PENGUJIAN SISTEM

KESIMPULAN DAN SARAN

STOP

KEBUTUHANTERPENUHI

F

T

3.1 D A

3.1

Sd eae bea eeaa ea eaha e

e e aga ada aa daa eacaga da egaa baaedaa. Pada aha d ea eeaa eag ee ag

dgaa daa egeaa . Tee ag dgaa

edg ea deeh da b, a, , da eea

ebea ag e ebahaa ag aa aa behbga

dega . Ha aa ag dbaha daa egeaa adaah

eea ea ba bae, ea ede ag dgaa daa

eea ea ba bae a A ( AHP )


42/125

26

da

(Pehee).

3.2

Sd aaga ag daa adaah egeah d e

da ba bae U Aa Ba Bae Uea Baaa (UABBUB)

Maag. Ha daa daa dega eg egaa aha ag

daa eh ba bae UABBUB. Kegaa ga bea

egaa eaa ag d eh agag ea UABBUB.

Sea ga egeah aaah ada e eea a ag eah

dgaa eh eah UABBUB aa .

Te ega daa ag daa adaah ebaga

be:

3.2.1 /Obea aa egaaa daa aga daa egeah ecaa

agg d ag daa da ga ea aa da bagaaa

ed ag edag beaa aa . Sea ga egeah

eaaahaeaaaha ag eg c beaa dega egaba

ea eh eah ba bae. Haha ag daa aaa a

egea a egaba ea ag edag beaa da be daa

ea ag dah ada.

3.2.2 /

Mede daa dega eaa aacaa eada ha eah

da aage ba bae UABBUB egea aaahaaah ag egdaa eh . Ha daa dega a eeeh fa

eegaegaa ebaga aca daa egeaa . Daa

aacaaa ada bebeaa eaaa ag daa a da e

eha ea ag daa aa da ag dhaaaa. Da

aacaa ag eah daa ddaaa bebeaa fa da eah da

ga ha e UABBUB, a ada bebeaa ea ag ha deh eh

ea. Kea eeb dbag ead ga baga a eda, a, da

ga eaa e. Kea eaa adaah eda ag behbga

dega ehada daa eg aha da ga eeaa a. Kea

eaa adaah a. Kea e dehaa aea ead a

ebea ebah aa ea aa. Sa ag ba eadaeah a ea aa bedaa ba a ada eaaa beg

ga ebaa. Da ea ag eah adaah eaa e ag ed

da , , , , , da . Sea , da

aacaa ddaaa a a bb e ea ag aa dea

daa eghga e eea ea ba bae


43/125

27

3.2.3 A

Taha aaa ebha e daa eea aa aa

ag daa daa eh e. ada aha aa deaa egea

baaa da e da a ag daa dcaa eh aa egga.

3.2.4

Kebha fga ag aa aa dedaa eh aa

adaah ebaga be:

a. Aa a eaa, eabah, ebah da egha

dafa ca ea ba bae.

b. Aa a eaa, eabah, ebah, da egha

ag ba e daa e.

c. Aa a eaa haaa daa ea.

d. Aa a eaa haaa ehga

a ebadga eggaa ede AHP.

e. Aa a eaa haaa

ehga aeaf ea eggaa ede .

f. Aa a eaa haaa ha eaga ea d

ea eggaa ede AHP da .

g. Aa a eaa ha eeda ea

dega ha eaga eggaa ede AHP da .

3.3

Pada aha eacaga e, e a eacag a e

ag a eeh ea ebha fga aa daa .

Tee da aa da daa da ae dgabga dega ag

ddaa eda deeaa eacag da egebaga

a e eea ea ba bae.

3.3.1 D

Se ag aa dba edg ea eea ea

ba bae adaah dega eeaa ede AHP da .

AHP dgaa eaa ebba ea da aa dce

ea aaah CR


44/125

28

AHP. Bb da ea ag dhaa aa de ada ede .

Kea ag dgaa adaah: eda, a, da eaa e.

Sbea ag dgaa adaah: ehada, ea a, a eada eah,

, , , , , , da . Da

ea da bea eeb aa dea ea aa aa ag aaead ea daa ba bae da aa eea aa

ea fa ag dga. Daga a a da e aa

daa dha ada gaba 3.2

3.2 B D

3.4

Ieea aa ag eeaa ede AHP da

daa bedaaa eacaga aa. Ieea eaga a

daa dega eggaa bahaa egaa beea be aeggaa eea ba daa MSQL dega aa XAMPP da

bahaa egaa eb (PHP, HTML, JaaSc). Ieea aa

e:

a. Pebaa aa a.

b. Meaa ehga eea bb ea eggaa AHP

Peah I Pe O

I daa

ea

ea

Pe Peea Hasil perankingan dari

setiap posisi.

Pe eea

ea ba

bae dega

ede AHP da


45/125

29

c. Meaa ehga eaga eggaa ede .

d. Meghaa bebeaa bea a eaga ea

bedaaa . Da a eeb aa ea ea ag

dh bedaaa a ea ag dah da ebea.

3.5

Pega e daa daa ea baha aa

daa dbag ea dega ag dhaaa. Pega e ag daa

e:

a. Pega daa dega caa ebadga ha da aa ag

dbag dega daa ea ag aa a daa ag

ddaa da bea.

b. Pega daa dega eaa e bea daa aa

e ah. Daa bea ddaa da eah da af e UABBUB.Saa ebadga aa ea da bea ddaa da ha

aacaa dega eah da ha e UABBUB. Seeah a

bb ddaa dega eggaa ede AHP, e eaa

ehga ag daa dega ede . Pehga

dega ede aa eghaa ag ea ea

dega da egg aa eedah. Aaba ha da e

ea dega ea eah da ha e, aa e daa

daaa ea dega a.

3.6

Pegaba ea daa eeah ea ahaa eacaga,eea, da ega e aa eah eea daa da

ddaaa ada eeaa aaa e da a. Kea dab

eaab a aaah ag dah dabaa ebea. Taha eah

adaah aa ag dada eeba eaahaeaaha ag

ead daa ebaa e Peea Pea I T Ba Bae

Meggaa Mede A (AHP) da

(Pehee) da

eeaa ea ea ebea ebaga aa

egebaga aa eaa.


46/125

30


47/125

31

BAB 4 ACAA

Peacaga aa ada ed da ea aha aeacaga be aaee beba egeaha, eacaga

be aaee de, eacaga be aaee daa, da

be aaa egga. Gaba 4.1 eaa h eacaga

ag deaa ada eea .

4.1

Taha e eea ea bae adaah ad

eaa daa ca ea. Keda eea a ebadga

eea bb a da ea ea eggaa ede AHP

da eeah daa dega eaa ehga efee ea

aeaf dega ebadga ea ea dega ea ag a. Ha

ehga efee eeb eda dgaa egg a

Perancangan

Analisa

Kebutuhan

Perancangan

Subsistem

Manajemen Basis

Pengetahuan

Perancangan

Subsistem

Manajemen Data

Perancangan

Subsistem

Manajemen Model

Perancanagn

Subsistem

Antarmuka

Pengguna

Perhitungan Manual

dengan Metode AHP

dan Promethee

Desain User

Interface


48/125

32

eaga dega eggaa ede . Da ha da

eaga eeb dgaa eea aa a

ea ag aa daa daa eadga.

4.1 A

Pe aa ebha egac ada eg fga da

fga ag eba egga daa eeh ebha egea

fa daa ca ea ba bae UABBUB. Taha aa da

dega eea aa ag ea dega e. Seeah a

deaa, eda dea ebha ag ha dbea e eada

aa eeb.

4.1.1 ( )

Taha eea aa egga adaah aha daa

deaa ag behbga aa ea dega e eeb. abe4.1 eehaa eag ee da ga eeaga ha ae ag

d ehada e.

4.1

D

Peah Peah eaa ag haa e ha ae

eha ha ea da e edg ea

eea ea aa ba bae.

Ad Ad eaa ag e ha ae ag gg

ehada e. Ad e ha ae

eaa, egbah da egha daa aeafea. ea ad ga beha egea

eaa aeaf, egea daa ea, egea

ehga bb AHP da eha ha ea

eea ea aa ba bae.

4.1.2 D

Dafa ebha eaa baga ag eeaga eag fg

fg ag d eh aa ea a ag ea dega fg eeb.

Dag ga eeaa eag fafa edg ag daaeba aa beaa ea dega eea. Tabe 4.2 eaa

ebha fga ag d eh aa beea a ag

behbga.


49/125

33

4.2D

A

1 Aa a eaa, eabah, ebah

da egha dafa aeaf ea babae.

Ad

2 Aa a eaa haaa a

ebadga ha efee AHP.

Ad

3 Aa a egbah e efee ada

ea ea.

Ad

4 Aa a eaa ha de

e ag deeh da a

beaaga ha da efee AHP.

Ad

5 Aa a eaa haaa ha daehga a , , da

.

Ad

6 Aa a eaa haaa ha

aga da ede AHP da Pehee.

Ad, Peah

7 Aa a eaa haaa ha

aa ea dega fa ag dga.

Ad, Peah

Kebha fga adaah ebha aa fa edg ag

daa eada aa aa e ag dba daa beaa ea dega

ag dga. Tabe 4.3 ea ebha fga e ag

ha deh aga aa daa beaa dega ba.

4.3 D

1 Aa debaga dega eggaa bahaa egaa

PHP dega eggaa e aaee ba daa MSQL.

2 Aa eggaa aa Deaeae da e ee

eaa ea daa.

3 Aa eggaa ee MSQL.

4.2 B

Sbe aaee ba egeaha beafaa eea

aaa ehgga aa eba daa egaba ea. Sebe

eaa ehga eea ea aa ba bae dega


50/125

34

eggaa ede AHP da , daa ehga bb

efee ehada agag ea dega eggaa ede AHP.

Mede AHP eea aa bea daa ea ag ha de

ead a eega. Peea ea ddaa da ha aacaa

dega eah da ha e UABBUB.

Da ha aacaa eada eah da e UABBUB, edaa ga

ea ag dgaa ebaga ada daa ea ea aa ba

bae. Tga ea eeb adaah eda, a, da eaa e.

Kega ea eeb a :

1. Keda

Meaa daa da ea ag bea a eda. Daa

dbag ead bea ebaga be:

a. Kehada daa aha

Daa da ea ag bea a ehada daa ea aha

.b. Tea a

Daa da ea ag bea a eeaa a daa

eg aha.

4.4

Sbea Na Sada Na

Kehada

daa aha

12 a aha

34 a aha

56 a aha

78 a aha

910 a aha

1

2

3

4

5

Tea a Tea a

Laba 5 e

Laba 10 e

Laba 15 e

Laba > 15 e

5

4

3

2

1

2. Sa

Daa da ea ag bea a a ea ehada gga

d eaa d daa b. Daa dbag ead bea ebaga

be:

a. Sa eada eah

Daa bea eaa a eag ea ehada eah.

b. Tea


51/125

35

Daa bea eaa a eag ea ehada ea

a ag eegah eaaa .

4

.5 Sbea Na Sada Na

Sa eada

eah

Tda ba

Kag ba

C ba

Ba

Saga ba

1

2

3

4

5

Tea Tda ba

Kag ba

C ba

Ba

Saga ba

1

2

3

4

5

3. Keaa e

Daa bea a da eaa e eag ea. Daa

eaa ba bae eaa e dbag ead ea

bea. Ea ea eeb adaah ebaga be:

a.

Daa ag bea a da eag ea daa eaa

ea aa .

b. D Daa ag bea a eag ea daa ebaa ba

eea aa.

c.

Daa ag bea a eag ea bea eahaa f da

ga ea aa eag ea.

d.

Daa ag bea a eag ea daa eaa ebaa

e eaag aa edaaa .

e. A

Daa ag bea a eag ea daa bea eagaa

egah ba.

f.

Daa ag bea a eag e daa ecaha eggg

ba aa eea aa.


52/125

36

4.6

Sbea Sada a

120

D 120 120

120

A 120

120

4.3

Aa ag aa dba eea ea ba bae

dega eeaa ede AHP da PROMETHEE. Mede AHP dgaa

e ebba. Da ede PROMETHEE dgaa

eea eaaa ea ag aa a edaa ba bae. Caa

eea eaaa ea adaah dega eaa eaaehada agag ea ea dega ea ag dah dea.

Keda aa dea bb da agag ea da bea

ag eaa ha da ea eah. Kea ag dgaa adaah

eda, a, da eaa e. Sbea ag dgaa adaah

ehada, ea a, a eada eah, a eada ea, ,

, , , , . Na da agag

ea dgaa ehga ag eggaa ede

PROMETHEE. Mede AHP da PROMETHEE dh aea ede daa

eeeaaa eaaaha ea da ga e bebeaa e

efee eghg a ebadga da agag ea. Pada

e dhaa ag ea ag aa dgaa daaeea e ea dega ea da fa ag dga.


53/125


54/125

38

4.4 D

Daa eacaga aaee daa edaa ba daa ag

egadg daa edg daa ebaa aa ag daa dgaa

daa bebaga a da d ea daa da eh eaga a agdeb D (DBMS). Daa aa eggaa

DBMS MSQL. Ea daa ba daa ada aa adaah ebaga be:

1. Tabe e

Tabe dgaa ea ag behbga dega

aa. Ea e da ab a ebaga

da ad. Ab ada abe daa dha ada abe 4.7

dbaah .

4.7

N Naa Fed Te Keeaga

1. Id_e (PK) Iege Id e eaa

2. Vacha Ueae da ea e

ag g eaa g

e daa aa.

3. Pad Vacha Pad da e

eaa g edaa

aa.

4. Lee Iege Ab ea

ee ha ae e

2. Tabe a AHP

Tabe ea daa aa da a ebadga

beaaga. Daa ag ea de ehgga eghaa

bb a ag a aa da ada abe bb a.

Ab ada abe a ea daa dha ada abe 4.8 d baah

4.8 A

N Naa Fed Te Keeaga

1 Id_a (PK) Iege Id a ea

eaa 2 Id_ (FK) Iege Id ea ag

dgaa ga

eghbga dega abe

3 Naa Vacha Naa a AHP

4 Bb Vacha bb ag aa


55/125

39

dgaa ea

a a AHP

3. Tabe bb AHPTabe dgaa ea ha bb a ag

dhaa da ehga eggaa ede AHP. Bb a

eda aa dada aa daa eaa ehga

eggaa ede . Ab ada abe bb a

daa dha ada abe 4.9 d baah .

4.9

N Naa Fed Te Keeaga

1 Id_bb (PK) Iege Id bb a

eaa

2 Id_ (FK) Iege Id ea eaeghbga dega abe

3 Bb acha Ab ea

bb ea ea

4. Tabe aeaf

Tabe befg ea daa da aeaf ea. Ab

ada abe aeaf daa dha ada abe 4.10 dbaah .

4.10

N Naa Fed Te Keeaga

1. Id_aeaf (PK) Iege d da ea aeaf

ea eaa

2. Naa_ea Vacha Naa da ea ea.

3. Id_ (FK) Iege Id ag dgaa

eghbga e

abe

5. Tabe_Kea

Tabe befg ea daa ea. Ab ada abe

ea daa dha ada abe 4.11 dbaah .


56/125

40

4.11

N Naa Fed Te Keeaga

1. (PK) Iege Id da ea eaa

2. Naa_ea Vacha Naa ea

4. Te Iege Ab ea

e efee da

egbah e abe

e_efee

6. Tabe

Tabe befg ea daa da ea. Ab daabe daa dha ada abe 4.12 dbaah .

4.12

N Naa Fed Te Keeaga

1. (PK) Iege Id da eaa

.

2. Naa_ Vacha Naa da

7. Tabe e_efee

Tabe befg ea daa da e efee. Ab

da abe e_efee daa dha ada abe 4.13 dbaah .

4.13

N Naa Fed Te Keeaga

1. (PK) Iege Id da e efee

eaa .

2. Naa_efee Vacha Naa da e efee.

8. Tabe ag

Tabe befg ea daa ag ea. Ab da

abe ag_ea daa dha ada abe 4.14 dbaah .

4.14

N Naa Fed Te Keeaga

1. (PK) Iege Id da ea eaa


57/125

41

2. Id_ (FK) Iege Id da ag

dgaa

eghbga e abe

3. Id_aeaf (FK) Iege Id da aeaf ag

dga

eghbga e abe

aeaf

4. Bb Vacha Ab ag dgaa

ea a e f

9. Tabe Cee

Tabe befg ea daa ea ag be ebaga

cee. Ab da abe cee daa dha ada abe 4.15 dbaah .

4.15

N Naa Fed Te Keeaga

1. Id_aeaf (PK) Iege Id da aeaf ea

eaa

2. had Fa Na da ea had

3. Tea_a Fa Na da ea ea

a

4. Sa_eah Fa Na da ea a

eada eah

5. Tea Fa Na da ea ea

6. Pag Fa Na da ea ag7. Shg Fa Na da ea hg

8. Idace Fa Na da ea dace

9. Ag Fa Na da ea ag

10. F Fa Na da ea f

10. Tabe _gad


gad. Ab da abe gad daa dha ada abe 4.16

dbaah .

4.16

N Naa Fed Te Keeaga


eaa

2. had Fa Na da ea had



58/125

42

a


eada eah


6. Pag Fa Na da ea ag

7. Shg Fa Na da ea hg



10. F Fa Na da ea f

11. Tabe e_fad


e fad. Ab da abe e fad daa dha ada abe

4.17 dbaah .

4.17

N Naa Fed Te Keeaga


eaa

2. Had Fa Na da ea had


a


eada eah





10. F Fa Na da ea f

12. Tabe hg_gad


cee. Ab da abe hg gad daa dha ada abe 4.18

dbaah .

4.18

N Naa Fed Te Keeaga


eaa




59/125

43

a


eada eah


6. Pag Fa Na da ea ag

7. Shg Fa Na da ea hg



10. F Fa Na da ea f

13. Tabe a_fad


a fad. Ab da abe a fad daa dha ada abe

4.19 dbaah .

4.19

N Naa Fed Te Keeaga


eaa



a


eada eah





10. F Fa Na da ea f

4.5

Pada be aaee de e da ha, a

eacaga e bea daga a e da aaa. Daga a

dba dega a eba daa e eaha aaa a

e. Sedaga aaa adaah ch ehga ada eeggaa ede AHP da Pehee.

4.5.1 D A

Daga a eaa gabaa ecaa gaf ag ed da b

b ag dba edaha eahaa e ag ead da

eaha ha ah. Pe ag aa daa e eggaa ede

eea eaga ea ag aa a e daa


60/125

44

ba bae UABBUB dega eggaa bb a ag dhg

eggaa ede AHP. Ha eaga ddaaa da ebadga

ha ehga eggaa ga e efee ag ada ada ede

, a e , e , da e . Daga a eea

ea ba bae daa dha da daga 4.2.

Start

Normalisasi M atriks

Perbandingan

Berpasangan

Menghitung Bobot

Prioritas

Menghitung Lamda

Maks

Menghitung

Consistency Ratio

(CR)

Consistency Ratio (CR)


61/125

45

MenghitungParameter Nilai p

dan q

Menghitung Derajat

Preferensi dan

Indeks Preferensi

Menghitung Leaving

Flow, Entering Flow

dan Net Flow

Perangkingan dengan

menggunakan NetFlow

rangking[i] dan susunan[i]

Stop

A

4.3 D B B

Lagah eaa daa e ebba AHP adaah dega

eaha ea ada agag b ea. Seeah e

eaha eda eaa aa a. Pe aa

ebadga beaaga daa ehada ea a a

ebadga beaag. Sea a a ebadga beaaga daa

a aa dbag dega ha eaha a a ebadga

daa a . Daga a ehga aa a ebadga

beaaga daa dha ada daga 4.3.


62/125

46

return

normal [i][j]

j

normal [i][j] = data [i][j] /

jumlah [j]

j=0; j


63/125

47

Meghg

bb a Sa

Na

[][]

=0;


64/125

48

Meghg

Lada Ma Sa

T [],

ah [ ]

=0;


65/125

49

Start

Lamda maks

CI = (Lamda maks -

jumlah kriteria) /

(jumlah kriteria-1)

CR = CI / IR

CI, CR

return

Menghitung

Consistency Ratio

(CR)

4.7 D C C

Seeah eg e da ddaaa bb a ag ea

eda eaa ehga eggaa ede ebaga

ag aa aa dgaa eag ea ag aa a

e daa ba bae UABBUB. Pehga daa degaeggaa daa ag eah ddaa da aacaa dega ha eah.

Tedaa ea agah daa e ea ede ehee, a :

1. Ha eaa ag daa daa e ehga adaah

eea a aaee da . Na ddaa dega eggaa

e. Daga a ehga e da ada gaba 4.7 dbaah

.


66/125

50

Meghg

Paaee Na

da

Sa

Aeaf,

=0

Feach (aeaf a ha )

S[] = ha >

daaea

++

Ma = a()

1 = a [0]

2 = [1] – [0]

= 1 – 2

= / baa daa

=

,

Re

4.8 D

2. Lagah eda adaah eaa ehga a deaa efee

ag ag ea. Daa ehga a deaa efee ga

eebaga e efee ag dh daa ha ag dgaa

adaah e , da ee. Daga a ehga deaa efee

daa dha ada daga 4.8.


67/125

51

Mulai

Data calon pemain,

Tipe preferensi

i


68/125

52

Start

Array[i][j], nilai[i][j],

pemain[i][j]

Jml_preferensi = count(array1)

Jml_kriteria = 11

Jml_alternatif = count(pemain)

i=0; i


69/125

53

return

LF[i] , EF[i], NF [i]

i

j

total = total + indeks [i]

[j]

j=0; j


70/125

54

4.20 B

A B C D E F G H I J

A 1 3 1/3 3 4 4 4 4 4 4B 1/3 1 1/3 1/2 1/3 1/3 1/3 1/3 1/3 1/3

C 3 3 1 3 3 3 3 3 3 3

D 1/3 2 1/3 1 2 2 2 2 2 2

E 3 1/3 1/2 1 3 1 3 3 3

F 3 1/3 1/2 1/3 1 1/3 1 1 1

G 3 1/3 1/2 1 3 1 3 3 3

H 3 1/3 1/2 1/3 1 1/3 1 1 1

I 3 1/3 1/2 1/3 1 1/3 1 1 1

J 3 1/3 1/2 1/3 1 1/3 1 1 1

4.21 B

A B C D E F G H I J

A 1 3 1/3 3 4 4 4 4 4 4

B 1/3 1 1/3 1/2 1/3 1/3 1/3 1/3 1/3 1/3

C 3 3 1 3 3 3 3 3 3 3

D 1/3 2 1/3 1 2 2 2 2 2 2

E 3 1/3 1/2 1 1 1/3 1 1 1/3

F 3 1/3 1/2 1 1 1/3 1 1 1/3

G 3 1/3 1/2 1 3 1 3 3 3

H 3 1/3 1/2 1 1 1/3 1 1 1/3I 3 1/3 1/2 1 1 1/3 1 1 1/3

J 3 1/3 1/2 3 3 1 3 3 1

4.22 B

A B C D E F G H I J

A 1 3 1/3 3 4 4 4 4 4 4

B 1/3 1 1/3 1/2 1/3 1/3 1/3 1/3 1/3 1/3

C 3 3 1 3 3 3 3 3 3 3

D 1/3 2 1/3 1 2 2 2 2 2 2

E 3 1/3 1/2 1 1 1 1/3 1/3 1F 3 1/3 1/2 1 1 1 1/3 1/3 1

G 3 1/3 1/2 1 1 1 1/3 1/3 1

H 3 1/3 1/2 3 3 3 1 1 3

I 3 1/3 1/2 3 3 3 1 1 3

J 3 1/3 1/2 1 1 1 1/3 1/3 1


71/125

55

4.23 B

A B C D E F G H I J

A 1 3 1/3 3 4 4 4 4 4 4B 1/3 1 1/3 1/2 1/3 1/3 1/3 1/3 1/3 1/3

C 3 3 1 3 3 3 3 3 3 3

D 1/3 2 1/3 1 2 2 2 2 2 2

E 3 1/3 1/2 1 1/3 1 1/3 1 1

F 3 1/3 1/2 3 1 3 1 3 3

G 3 1/3 1/2 1 1/3 1 1/3 1 1

H 3 1/3 1/2 3 1 3 1 3 3

I 3 1/3 1/2 1 1/3 1 1/3 1 1

J 3 1/3 1/2 1 1/3 1 1/3 1 1

4.24 B C

A B C D E F G H I J

A 1 3 1/3 3 4 4 4 4 4 4

B 1/3 1 1/3 1/2 1/3 1/3 1/3 1/3 1/3 1/3

C 3 3 1 3 3 3 3 3 3 3

D 1/3 2 1/3 1 2 2 2 2 2 2

E 3 1/3 1/2 1 3 1 3 3 3

F 3 1/3 1/2 1/3 1 1 1/3 1 1

G 3 1/3 1/2 1/3 1 1 1/3 1 1

H 3 1/3 1/2 1 3 3 1 3 3

I 3 1/3 1/2 1/3 1 1 1/3 1 1J 3 1/3 1/2 1/3 1 1 1/3 1 1

Keeaga abe 4.20, 4.21, 4.22, 4.23, da 4.24 :

A : Kehada daa aha

B : Tea Wa

C : Sa eada Peah

D :

E :

F : D

G :

H :

I : A

J :

Pada abe 4.20 eha ebadga aa a ehgga ebe a.

Keda a eeb dedehaaa dega


72/125

56

Da eeb aa ddaaa a a ebadga beaaga

ag eah dedehaaa. Lagah eaa eda eaha ea

ag edaa ada abe 4.20. ha eaha da ea

edaa ada abe 4.25 be :

4.25 B

D D

A B C D E F G H I J

A 1.000 3.000 0.333 3.000 4.000 4.000 4.000 4.000 4.000 4.000

B 0.333 1.000 0.333 0.500 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.333

C 3.000 3.000 1.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000

D 0.333 2.000 0.333 1.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000

E 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 3.000 1.000 3.000 3.000 3.000

F 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 0.333 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000 1.000

G 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 3.000 1.000 3.000 3.000 3.000

H 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 0.333 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000 1.000

I 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 0.333 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000 1.000

J 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 0.333 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000 1.000

∑ 6.166 27.00 3.977 10.5 12.66 19.33 12.66 19.33 19.33 19.33

4.26 B

D D

A B C D E F G H I JA 1.000 3.000 0.333 3.000 4.000 4.000 4.000 4.000 4.000 4.000

B 0.333 1.000 0.333 0.500 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.333

C 3.000 3.000 1.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000

D 0.333 2.000 0.333 1.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000

E 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000 0.333

F 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000 0.333

G 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 3.000 3.000 1.000 3.000 3.000 1.000

H 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000 0.333

I 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000 0.333

J 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 3.000 3.000 1.000 3.000 3.000 1.000

∑ 6.166 27.00 3.977 10.5 19.33 19.33 12.66 19.33 19.3 12.66

4.27 B

D D

A B C D E F G H I J

A 1.000 3.000 0.333 3.000 4.000 4.000 4.000 4.000 4.000 4.000


73/125

57

B 0.333 1.000 0.333 0.500 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.333

C 3.000 3.000 1.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000

D 0.333 2.000 0.333 1.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000

E 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 1.000 1.000 0.333 0.333 1.000

F 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 1.000 1.000 0.333 0.333 1.000

G 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 1.000 1.000 0.333 0.333 1.000

H 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 3.000 3.000 3.000 1.000 1.000 3.000

I 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 3.000 3.000 3.000 1.000 1.000 3.000

J 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 1.000 1.000 0.333 0.333 1.000

∑ 6.166 27.00 3.977 10.5 19.33 19.33 19.33 12.66 12.66 19.3

4.28 B

D D

A B C D E F G HI J

A 1.000 3.000 0.333 3.000 4.000 4.000 4.000 4.000 4.000 4.000

B 0.333 1.000 0.333 0.500 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.333

C 3.000 3.000 1.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000

D 0.333 2.000 0.333 1.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000

E 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 0.333 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000

F 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 3.000 1.000 3.000 1.000 3.000 3.000

G 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 0.333 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000

H 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 3.000 1.000 3.000 1.000 3.000 3.000

I 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 0.333 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000

J 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 0.333 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000

∑ 6.166 27.00 3.977 10.5 19.33 12.66 19.33 12.66 19.3 19.3

4.29 B C

D D

A B C D E F G H I J

A 1.000 3.000 0.333 3.000 4.000 4.000 4.000 4.000 4.000 4.000

B 0.333 1.000 0.333 0.500 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.333

C 3.000 3.000 1.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000 3.000

D 0.333 2.000 0.333 1.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000

E 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 3.000 3.000 1.000 3.000 3.000

F 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 0.333 1.000 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000

G 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 0.333 1.000 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000

H 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 1.000 3.000 3.000 1.000 3.000 3.000

I 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 0.333 1.000 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000

J 0.250 3.000 0.333 0.500 0.333 1.000 1.000 0.333 1.000 1.000

∑ 6.166 27.00 3.977 10.5 12.66 19.33 19.33 12.66 19.3 19.3


74/125

58

Pe eaa adaah eaa aa a. Sea a

a ebadga beaaga daa a aa dbag dega ha

eaha a a ebadga daa a . Tabe 4.30

eaa a ag eah daa da eaha ea a

ag eah eaa.

4.30

A B C D E F G H I J ∑

A 0.162 0.111 0.083 0.286 0.316 0.207 0.316 0.207 0.207 0.207 2.102

B 0.054 0.037 0.083 0.048 0.026 0.017 0.026 0.017 0.017 0.017 0.343

C 0.487 0.111 0.250 0.286 0.237 0.155 0.237 0.155 0.155 0.155 2.228

D 0.054 0.074 0.083 0.095 0.158 0.103 0.158 0.103 0.103 0.103 1.036

E 0.041 0.111 0.083 0.048 0.079 0.155 0.079 0.155 0.155 0.155 1.061

F 0.041 0.111 0.083 0.048 0.026 0.052 0.026 0.052 0.052 0.052 0.542

G 0.041 0.111 0.083 0.048 0.079 0.155 0.079 0.155 0.155 0.155 1.061H 0.041 0.111 0.083 0.048 0.026 0.052 0.026 0.052 0.052 0.052 0.542

I 0.041 0.111 0.083 0.048 0.026 0.052 0.026 0.052 0.052 0.052 0.542

J 0.041 0.111 0.083 0.048 0.026 0.052 0.026 0.052 0.052 0.052 0.542

4.31 B


A 0.162 0.111 0.083 0.286 0.207 0.207 0.316 0.207 0.207 0.316 2.102

B 0.054 0.037 0.083 0.048 0.017 0.017 0.026 0.017 0.017 0.026 0.343

C 0.487 0.111 0.250 0.286 0.155 0.155 0.237 0.155 0.155 0.237 2.228D 0.054 0.074 0.083 0.095 0.103 0.103 0.158 0.103 0.103 0.158 1.036

E 0.041 0.111 0.083 0.048 0.052 0.052 0.026 0.052 0.052 0.026 0.542

F 0.041 0.111 0.083 0.048 0.052 0.052 0.026 0.052 0.052 0.026 0.542

G 0.041 0.111 0.083 0.048 0.155 0.155 0.079 0.155 0.155 0.079 1.061

H 0.041 0.111 0.083 0.048 0.052 0.052 0.026 0.052 0.052 0.026 0.542

I 0.041 0.111 0.083 0.048 0.052 0.052 0.026 0.052 0.052 0.026 0.542

J 0.041 0.111 0.083 0.048 0.155 0.155 0.079 0.155 0.155 0.079 1.061

4.32 B


A 0.162 0.111 0.083 0.286 0.207 0.207 0.207 0.316 0.316 0.207 2.102

B 0.054 0.037 0.083 0.048 0.017 0.017 0.017 0.026 0.026 0.017 0.343

C 0.487 0.111 0.250 0.286 0.155 0.155 0.155 0.237 0.237 0.155 2.228

D 0.054 0.074 0.083 0.095 0.103 0.103 0.103 0.158 0.158 0.103 1.036

E 0.041 0.111 0.083 0.048 0.052 0.052 0.052 0.026 0.026 0.052 0.542


75/125

59

F 0.041 0.111 0.083 0.048 0.052 0.052 0.052 0.026 0.026 0.052 0.542

G 0.041 0.111 0.083 0.048 0.052 0.0

penentuan pemain inti tim bola basket menggunakan metode ahp dan promethee

Documents