team teaching - universitas brawijaya · the variety of teaching approaches used by the team can...

50
TEAM TEACHING Disiapkan dari berbagai sumber oleh : Prof. Dr. Pratiwi Trisunuwati PEKERTI, LP3M UB, 14 AGUSTUS 2019 8/14/2019 TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019 1

Upload: others

Post on 02-Jun-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

TEAM TEACHING

Disiapkan dari berbagai sumber oleh :

Prof. Dr. Pratiwi Trisunuwati

PEKERTI, LP3M UB, 14 AGUSTUS 2019

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

1

Page 2: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

1. ENCOURAGES STUDENT-LECTURE CONTACT

2.ENCOURAGES COOPERATION AMONG STUDENTS

3.ENCOURAGES ACTIVE LEARNING

4.GIVES PROMPT FEEDBACK

5.EMPHASISE TIME OF TASK

6.COMMUNICATED HIGH EXPECTATIONS

7.RESPECT DIVERSE TALENTS AND WAYS OF LEARNING

8/14/2019

2

TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

Page 3: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

3OUTPUT OF LEARNING

KOGNITIF AFEKTIF PSIKOMOTORIK

Pengetahuan Penerimaan Persepsi

Pemahaman Partisipasi Kesiapan

Penerapan Penilaian Gerakan terbimbing

Analisa Penentuan sikap Gerakan terbiasa

Sintesa Organisasi Penyesuaian pola

gerakan

evaluasi Pembentukan pola Kreativitas

8/14/2019

Page 4: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

4

Learning Pyramid* RETENTION RATE

8/14/2019

TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

4

* National Training Laboratories for Applied Behavioral Sciences, Alexandria, VA.

Page 5: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Why team teaching ???

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

5

Team teaching can open a student's eyes to accepting

more than one opinion and to acting more cooperatively

with others Team teaching may even provide educational benefits

such as increasing the student's level of understanding

and retention,

the student to obtain higher achievement.

Page 6: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Exposure to the views of more than one

teacher permits students :

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

6

To gain a mature level of understanding knowledge; rather than

considering only one view on each issue or new topic brought up in the

classroom,

Two or more varying views help students blur the black-and-white way

of thinking common in our society, and see many shades of gray.

In addition, diverse perspectives encourage students to consider the

validity of numerous views.

The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a

greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997).

Page 7: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Collaborative Relationships

Think about the successful collaborative relationships you have had in your life -- both personal and professional.

What has made these relationships successful?

Key words

Give one, get one

Working to gether with a single group of student

What makes collaborative partnerships work?

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

7

Page 8: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Objectives

Shared delivery of instruction

Mutual responsibility and ownership of class

Style of Co-teaching is dynamic, adapting as necessary

based on content delivered and student needs

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

8

Page 9: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Objectives

We will identify and discuss different collaborative

practices and co-teaching models.

We will plan ways to integrate collaborative practices

and co-teaching into our instructional repertoire in

order to improve student access and outcomes.

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

9

Page 10: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Advantages TT

THE STUDENTS

May increase students’ level of understanding

May lead to greater depth of understanding

May allow students to see other viewpoints

Variety of teaching styles may reach a greater variety of learning styles

THE TEACHERS

Allows team to play to its strengths

Creates a supportive environment

Allows development of new

teaching approaches

May help create sounder solutions

to discipline

Fosters intellectual growth

High Emotional intelligence

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

10

Page 11: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Disadvantages for the students

Potential for ambiguity and diversity (if there is no good coordination between lectures)

Some students may be confused by more than one way of looking at an issue (personal understanding)

Some students may feel lost or anonymous in a larger group

Compatibility of groups

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

11

Page 12: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Characteristics of Team Teaching

Development of Staff:

How do we deploy the teachers in brain teaching? The

deployment of teachers is done according to areas and methods

in which they feel most at home.

Experience Centered Work:

it means realistic field work of all kinds is undertaken on some

afternoons and two or more members of the staff are involved in

one project.

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

12

Page 13: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Stages of Collaboration

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

13

• Consider how a classroom partnership could be like a marriage.

• Where do you stand with likely partners in your situation?

• How can you effectively move a co-teaching relationship to the

• Collaborating stage?

Page 14: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

What makes collaborative partnerships work?

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

14

Page 15: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Co-Teaching

Is defined as two teachers (cooperating teacher and teacher

candidate) working together with groups of students-sharing the

planning, organization, delivery and assessment of instruction, as well

as the physical space.

Both teachers are actively involved and engaged in all aspects of

instruction

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

16

Page 16: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Co-Teaching Strategies

One Teach, One Observe

One Teach, One Assist

Station Teaching

Parallel Teaching

Supplemental Teaching

Alternative (Differentiated) Teaching

Team Teaching

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

17

Page 17: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

At principles of Co-Teaching

Building better relationships

Communication/Collaboration

Co-Teaching/Co-Planning

Active vs. Passive

Use expertise of cooperating teacher

Attitude

Best way to meet students

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

18

Page 18: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Should be important decisions about:

(1) what will be presented (e.g., the units, lesson objectives) and in

what order,

(2) how the material is to be presented (e.g., to a large or small

group presentation),

(3) who is to present the information,

(4) how the students will be assessed,

(5) how small groups will be organized and which team teacher will

be assigned to each small group.

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

19

Page 19: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Key Elements

Co-teaching Workshop

One teacher candidate per classroom

Co-teaching integrated into teacher preparation curriculum

Clearly defined expectations, including solo teaching time

Support for CT’s and Teacher Candidates

Designated planning time for co-teaching each week

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

20

Page 20: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Improving their team

Questions such as:

(1) How can the class activities be improved?

(2) What problems have arisen?

(3) How can these problems be solved?

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

21

Page 21: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Co-Teaching is not simply dividing the tasks and responsibilities between two people.

Co-Teaching is an attitude of sharing the classroom and students

Co-Teachers must always be thinking…

We’re Both Teaching!

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

22

Page 22: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

One Teach, One Observe

One lecture has primary instructional responsibility while the other gathers specific observational information on students or the

(instructing) teacher.

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

23

Page 23: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

One Teach, One Assist

One lecture has primary instructional responsibility while the other assists students’ with their work, monitors behaviors, or

corrects assignments.

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

24

Page 24: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Parallel Teaching

In this approach, each lecture instructs half the students.

The two teachers are addressing the same instructional material using the same teaching strategies.

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

25

Page 25: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Station Teaching

The co-teaching pair divide the instructional content into parts.

Each lecture instructs one of the groups; groups then rotate or spend a designated amount of time at each station.

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

26

Page 26: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Supplemental Teaching

This strategy allows one lecture to work with students at their expected grade level, while the other lecture works with those

students who need the information and/or materials extended or remediated.

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

27

Page 27: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Alternative or Differentiated Teaching

Alternative teaching strategies provide two different approaches to teaching the same information.

The learning outcome is the same for all students; however, the avenue for getting there is different.

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

28

Page 28: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Hierarchy

Team Teaching

Alternative or Differentiated Teaching

Supplemental/Extended Teaching

Parallel Teaching

Station Teaching

One Teach, One Assist

One Teach, One Observe

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

29

Co-teaching strategies do not follow a specific

hierarchy

Page 29: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

TIM TEACHING tasks

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

30

Page 30: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Sharing Planning

The Teacher Candidate and Cooperating Teacher will share:

What content to teach

What co-teaching strategies to use

Who will lead different parts of the lesson

How to assess student learning

Materials and resources

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

31

Page 31: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Sharing Instruction

While Co-Teaching, the Teacher Candidate and Cooperating Teacher will:

Share leadership in the classroom

Work with all students

Use a variety of co-teaching approaches

Be seen as equal partners

Manage the classroom together

Make changes as needed during a lesson

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

32

Page 32: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Sharing Assessment

While Co-Assessing, the Teacher Candidate and Cooperating Teacher will:

Both participate in the assessment of the students

Share the workload of daily grading

Provide formative and summative assessment of students

Jointly determine grades

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

33

Page 33: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Sharing the Lead

Contribute ideas from the very beginning of the experience

Engage with students assisting with their learning from the very first day

Be expected to take on full leadership in all 3 areas (planning, instruction & assessment)

Demonstrate competencies as a teacher

Have opportunities to teach alone

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

34

Page 34: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Teacher Candidate

Come ready to learn; be enthusiastic and show initiative

Introduce yourself to team members

Ask questions and discuss professional issues

Share ideas and work cooperatively; be flexible

Help with all classroom responsibilities…record keeping, grading

Know your content and be a continuous learner

Plan engaging, standards based lessons

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

35

Page 35: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Teacher Candidate

Know and implement co-teaching strategies

Accept feedback and use suggestions for improvement

Be proactive in initiating communication with your triad members

Demonstrate respectful behaviors

Be reflective about your practice

Be patient with yourself and your cooperating teacher

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

36

Page 36: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Team Teaching Techniques

Pre-class Coordination and Preparation

Coordinate and discuss delivery styles

Choose a co-teaching model

Agree on course expectations

Agree on Responsibilities

Agree on Scheduling

Use the Administrator Guide

Setup a regular meeting time

Agree to be flexible

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

37

Page 37: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Team Teaching Techniques (Cont’d)

During Class

Present a team teaching approach

Control of the session

Should not interrupt the session

Include other instructor(s) when appropriate

Smooth transitions are essential

Assist and support

Communicate and coordinate the next session/activity

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

38

Page 38: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Team Teaching Techniques (Cont’d)

Post class

Gather evaluations

Help repack materials

Discuss and evaluate the course

Review the delivery and presentation methods

Congratulate each other

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

39

Page 39: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Getting Started

• Review the elements of collaboration

• Identify personality strengths and weaknesses, areas of expertise,

learning styles, teaching styles and what you can bring to the

relationship

• Identify your values and beliefs on classroom management,

motivating students, what is fair, assessment, grading, instructional

strategies (‘more is more’)

• Decide on the best times for meeting and planning for everyone

involved

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

40

Page 40: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Frame work team teaching

• dasar

• Manfaat

• Model

Deskripsitim

• Sesuai tujuaninstitusional

• Menentukananggautatim

• MenyusunRPP

MerancangTim

• Evaluasipembelajarandan LO

• Konsolidasi TT

• PengembanganPBL

Implementasidan evaluasitim teaching

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

41

Page 41: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

IMPLEMENTASI TEAM TEACHING

Merancangkegiatan pbl

Membagi peran dantanggung jawab

Mengatur pengelolaankelas

Mengadakan pertemuan2 kolaborasi bersama

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

42

Learning Outcomes

Page 42: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Stages of Co-Teacher Development

Beginning Stage

Compromising Stage

Collaborative Stage

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

43

Gately, S., Gately, F., Understanding Co-teaching Components, Journal of Teaching Exceptional Children, 2 (3) 41-47

•Teachers often present separate lessons•One teacher is “boss”; one is “helper”

•Special educators offers mini-lessons or clarifies strategies that students may use.•Both teachers direct some of the activities in the classroom.

•Both teachers participate in the presentation of the lesson, provide instruction and structure the learning activities•Students address questions and discuss concerns with both teachers

Page 43: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

The Components of Co-Teaching

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

44

CO-TEACHINGCOMPONENTS

INTERPERSONALCOMMUNICATION

PHYSICAL ENVIRON

MENT

FAMILIARITY WITHTHE

CURRICULUM

INSTRUCTIONAL PLANNING

INSTRUCTION

ASSESSMENT

TEACHING PHILOSOPHY

BELIEFS

CURRICULUM GOALS

Gately, S., Gately, F., Understanding Co-teaching Components, Journal of Teaching Exceptional Children, 2 (3) 41-47

Page 44: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Implementasi Tim Teaching

2 or more teachers join to teach one group

2 or more teachers join to teach a large group

divided on different class both in same time or not

May be for the whole lesson

May be for part of the lesson

May be in one location or by videoconferencing

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

45

Page 45: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

Sharing Responsibility

Cooperating Teacher & Teacher Candidate

Plan

Assess

Lead

Teach

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

46

Page 46: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

7-12 Survey Drawbacks of Co-Teaching

Cumulative Data 2004-2008 (N= 1686)

7.1

8.3

8.8

11.6

13

13.5

18.8

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

Less Material Covered

Candidate too dependent

Teachers interrupt each other

Contradicting information

Grading Issues

Confusing who to go to

Confusing with 2 explanations

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

47

Page 47: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

48 Anticipate problems and minimise there impact

Page 48: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

To be necessary for a successful

team teaching program

(1) Compatibility of team members,

(2) Shared commitment to team teaching and ongoing communication,

(3) Same interest in connecting the content or curriculum to real life,

(4) A strong desire to ignite students' thirst for knowledge.

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

49

Page 49: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

References

Dove, M., & Honigsfeld, A. (2010). ESL coteaching and collaboration: Opportunities to

develop teacher leadership and enhance student learning. TESOL Journal, 1(1), 3-22.

http://dx.doi.org/ 10.5054/tj.2010.214879

Hendrickson, D. (2011). ESL and mainstream co-teaching practices in one elementary

school (Unpublished master's thesis). Hamline University, St. Paul, MN. Retrieved from:

http://www.hamline.edu/WorkArea/DownloadAsset.aspx?id=2147516348

Honigsfeld, A., & Dove, M. (2008). Co-teaching in the ESL classroom. Delta Kappa Gamma

Bulletin,74(2), 8-14. Retrieved from http://publication.dkg.org/dsweb/Get/Rendition-

891/2008%20Winter.pdf#page=8

Martinsen Holt, N. (2004). Pull-out to collaboration: Becoming an effective ESL co-teacher

(Unpublished master's thesis). Hamline University, Saint Paul, MN. Retreived from:

http://www.hamline.edu/WorkArea/DownloadAsset.aspx?id=2147490909

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

50

Page 50: TEAM TEACHING - Universitas Brawijaya · The variety of teaching approaches used by the team can also reach a greater variety of learning styles (Brandenburg, 1997). Collaborative

8/14/2019TEAM TEACHING PROF PTS AGUSTUS 2019

51