diskusi islam liberal

22
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

Upload: aim-pungpang-masohi

Post on 12-Apr-2016

225 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

diskusi islam liberal

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B����B��B���B���B�B�B����B����������,G[ �<< �������'HF���

&RS\ULJKW�������������<DKRR� ,QF��$OO�ULJKWV�UHVHUYHG��7HUPV�RI�6HUYLFH ��&RS\ULJKW�3ROLF\ ��*XLGHOLQHV ��$G�)HHGEDFN127,&(��:H�FROOHFW�SHUVRQDO�LQIRUPDWLRQ�RQ�WKLV�VLWH�7R�OHDUQ�PRUH�DERXW�KRZ�ZH�XVH�\RXU�LQIRUPDWLRQ��VHH�RXU�3ULYDF\�3ROLF\

<DKRR� 0\�<DKRR� 0DLO 6HDUFK:HOFRPH��\XVXIDQVKDU>6LJQ�2XW��0\�$FFRXQW@ 0DLO�+RPH ��0DLO�7XWRULDOV ��+HOS

)UHH�&RORU)OLS�3KRQHV�>$GG ��(GLW@,QER['UDIW6HQW

>(PSW\@7UDVK:KDWV�\RXU�&UHGLW6FRUH��FKHFN�LW�)5((����N�ORDQ�IRU�����PR��*R�0DVWHU&DUG�IRU&UHGLW�5HKDE

3ULQWDEOH�9LHZ ��)XOO�+HDGHUV

7KLV�PHVVDJH�LV�QRW�IODJJHG��>�)ODJ�0HVVDJH ��0DUN�DV�8QUHDG @

6DODP�VHMDKWHUD�XQWXN�$QGD�GDQ�UHNDQ��VHPXD��6D\D�LQJLQ�PHQJHWDKXL�OHELK�PHQGDODP�WHQWDQJ�SHPLNLUDQ�,VODP�/LEHUDO��6HMXMXUQ\D��VD\D�DGDODK�RUDQJ�\DQJ�DZDP��\DQJ�WLGDN�SHUQDK�PHQJHFDP�SHQGLGLNDQ�IRUPDO�\DQJ�WLQJJL��EDLN�GDODP�LOPX�DJDPD�PDXSXQ�XPXP��6D\D�KDQ\D�OXOXV�60$��SHUQDK�VHPSDW�NXOLDK�GL�37�GDQ�'��WDSL�VHPXDQ\D�SXWXV�GL�WHQJDK�MDODQ��6D\D�OHELK�VHQDQJ�EHODMDU�PDQGLUL��DXWRGLGDN��WHUXWDPD�OHZDW�PHPEDFD�EXNX�EXNX��EDLN�EXNX�XPXP��WHUXWDPD�EXNX�DJDPD��,VODP���2OHK�NDUHQD�VD\D�RUDQJ�DZDP��VD\D�PHQJKDUDS�XUDLDQ�$QGD�WLGDN�GHQJDQ�EDKDVD�\DQJ�VXNDU��QMOLPHW���6HVXDL�GHQJDQ�SHVDQ�5DVXOXOODK�VDZ���%HUELFDUDODK�NHSDGD�PDQXVLD�VHVXDL�GHQJDQ�NDGDU�DNDO�PHUHND���6D\D�UDVD�$QGD�PHQHULPD�+DGLWV�GL�DWDV��NDUHQD�+DGLWV�WVE�DJDNQ\D�WLGDN�EHUWHQWDQJDQ�GHQJDQ�LOPX�SVLNRORJL�NRPXQLNDVL�PRGHUQ��'DQ�VHWDKX�VD\D�-,/�PHQHULPD�KDO�\J�GHPLNLDQ��0XGDK�DQ�$QGD�EHUVHGLD�PHPEDJL�SHQJHWDKXDQ�GHQJDQ�VD\D�\J�DZDP�LQL�GDQ�WHULPDNDVLK�VHEHOXPQ\D�:DVVDODP�<XVXI'R�\RX�<DKRR�"<DKRR��0DLO ��+HOSV�SURWHFW�\RX�IURP�QDVW\�YLUXVHV��

6DYH�0HVVDJH�7H[W

3UHYLRXV _�1H[W�_�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV

'DWH� 6XQ�����'HF����������������������367�)URP� �\XVXI�DQVKDU���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!�� $GG�WR�$GGUHVV�%RRN6XEMHFW� LQJLQ�WDKX7R� XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP

3UHYLRXV _�1H[W�_�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV

0DLO $GGUHVVHV &DOHQGDU 1RWHSDG 0DLO�8SJUDGHV ��0DLO�2SWLRQV&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

)ROGHUV'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 0RYH���

'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 0RYH���

&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

Page 2: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B����B���B����B���B�B�B����B���������,G[ �<< ������'HF���

<DKRR� 0\�<DKRR� 0DLO 6HDUFK:HOFRPH��\XVXIDQVKDU>6LJQ�2XW��0\�$FFRXQW@ 0DLO�+RPH ��0DLO�7XWRULDOV ��+HOS

�����&HOO�3KRQH1R�&UHGLW�&KHFN�>$GG ��(GLW@,QER['UDIW6HQW

>(PSW\@7UDVK7LV�WKH�VHDVRQ�IRU�D)5((�&UHGLW�6FRUH����N�ORDQ�IRU�����PR��*R�)UHH�VKLSSLQJ�RUGHUV�����%DG�&UHGLW��*UHDW�&DUG

3ULQWDEOH�9LHZ ��)XOO�+HDGHUV

7KLV�PHVVDJH�LV�QRW�IODJJHG��>�)ODJ�0HVVDJH ��0DUN�DV�8QUHDG @

6DODP�6LODKNDQ�PHQJXQMXQJL�VLWXV�-,/�ZZZ�LVODPOLE�FRP��6HPXDEDKDQ�EDKDQ�\DQJ�DQGD�EXWXKNDQ�WHQWDQJ�-,/�DGD�GLVDQD�6HODPDW�PHPEDFD�8OLO

����\XVXI�DQVKDU��\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!�ZURWH�!�6DODP�VHMDKWHUD�XQWXN�$QGD�GDQ�UHNDQ��VHPXD��6D\D!�LQJLQ�PHQJHWDKXL�OHELK�PHQGDODP�WHQWDQJ�SHPLNLUDQ!�,VODP�/LEHUDO��6HMXMXUQ\D��VD\D�DGDODK�RUDQJ�\DQJ!�DZDP��\DQJ�WLGDN�SHUQDK�PHQJHFDP�SHQGLGLNDQ�IRUPDO!�\DQJ�WLQJJL��EDLN�GDODP�LOPX�DJDPD�PDXSXQ�XPXP��6D\D!�KDQ\D�OXOXV�60$��SHUQDK�VHPSDW�NXOLDK�GL�37�GDQ�'�!�WDSL�VHPXDQ\D�SXWXV�GL�WHQJDK�MDODQ��6D\D�OHELK!�VHQDQJ�EHODMDU�PDQGLUL��DXWRGLGDN��WHUXWDPD�OHZDW!�PHPEDFD�EXNX�EXNX��EDLN�EXNX�XPXP��WHUXWDPD�EXNX!�DJDPD��,VODP���2OHK�NDUHQD�VD\D�RUDQJ�DZDP��VD\D!�PHQJKDUDS�XUDLDQ�$QGD�WLGDN�GHQJDQ�EDKDVD�\DQJ�VXNDU!��QMOLPHW���6HVXDL�GHQJDQ�SHVDQ�5DVXOXOODK�VDZ�!��%HUELFDUDODK�NHSDGD�PDQXVLD�VHVXDL�GHQJDQ�NDGDU!�DNDO�PHUHND���6D\D�UDVD�$QGD�PHQHULPD�+DGLWV�GL!�DWDV��NDUHQD�+DGLWV�WVE�DJDNQ\D�WLGDN�EHUWHQWDQJDQ!�GHQJDQ�LOPX�SVLNRORJL�NRPXQLNDVL�PRGHUQ��'DQ�VHWDKX!�VD\D�-,/�PHQHULPD�KDO�\J�GHPLNLDQ��0XGDK�DQ�$QGD!�EHUVHGLD�PHPEDJL�SHQJHWDKXDQ�GHQJDQ�VD\D�\J�DZDP�LQL!�GDQ�WHULPDNDVLK�VHEHOXPQ\D�!��!�:DVVDODP�!�<XVXI!�!�!����������������������������������!�'R�\RX�<DKRR�"!��<DKRR��0DLO���+HOSV�SURWHFW�\RX�IURP�QDVW\�YLUXVHV�

3UHYLRXV _�1H[W _�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV

'DWH� 0RQ�����'HF����������������������367�)URP� �8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD���XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP!�� 9LHZ�&RQWDFW�'HWDLOV�6XEMHFW� 5H��LQJLQ�WDKX7R� �\XVXI�DQVKDU���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!

0DLO $GGUHVVHV &DOHQGDU 1RWHSDG 0DLO�8SJUDGHV ��0DLO�2SWLRQV&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

)ROGHUV'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 6SDP 0RYH���

Page 3: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B����B���B���B����B�B�B����B����������,G[ �<< �����'HF���

<DKRR� 0\�<DKRR� 0DLO 6HDUFK:HOFRPH��\XVXIDQVKDU>6LJQ�2XW��0\�$FFRXQW@ 0DLO�+RPH ��0DLO�7XWRULDOV ��+HOS

�����&HOO�3KRQH1R�&UHGLW�&KHFN�>$GG ��(GLW@,QER['UDIW6HQW

>(PSW\@7UDVK:KDWV�\RXU�&UHGLW6FRUH��FKHFN�LW�)5((����N�ORDQ�IRU�����PR��*R�*HW�<RXU�+RW/RZ�5DWHV�1RZ$SSO\�1RZ�IRU�D3ODWLQXP�&DUG�

3ULQWDEOH�9LHZ ��)XOO�+HDGHUV

7KLV�PHVVDJH�LV�QRW�IODJJHG��>�)ODJ�0HVVDJH ��0DUN�DV�8QUHDG @

6HWHODK�VD\D�PHPEXND�EXND�GDQ�PHQHODDK�EHEHUDSD�OLQN�GDODP�VLWXV�LVODPOLE��XWDPDQ\D�OLQN��7HQWDQJ�.DPL����VD\D�DNKLUQ\D�PHQJDPELO�NHVLPSXODQ�PHQJHQDL�,VODP�/LEHUDO�VEE��,VODP�/LEHUDO�DGDODK�VXDWX�EHQWXN�SHQDIVLUDQ�WHUKDGDS�,VODP�VHFDUD�EHEDV�GHQJDQ�PHQJDEDLNDQ�DTLGDK�GDQ�TDLGDK�\DQJ�DGD�GDODP�,VODP�LWX�VHQGLUL��6LVWLP�SHPLNLUDQ�VHSHUWL�LQL�MHODV�EDWKLO�GDQ�VHVDW��.HQDSD�GHPLNLDQ"�%HJLQL�ORJLNDQ\D�D��6HPXD�XSD\D�SHQDIVLUDQ��SHPLNLUDQ��VHEHEDV�DSDSXQ�GLD��WHQWX�PHQJJXQDNDQ�PHWRGH��NDLGDK�DWDX�SURVHV�EHUSLNLU�WHUWHQWX��NDODX�WLGDN�GHPLNLDQ��LWX�EXNDQ�WDIVLU�VHEDJDL�EXDK�SLNLU�PHODLQNDQ�OHELK�SDQWDV�GLVHEXW�QJDZXU��QJODQWXU�DWDX�QJOLQGXU��.HVLPSXODQQ\D��WLGDN�DGD�SHPLNLUDQ�\DQJ�EHEDV�QLODL��GLD�KDUXV�PHQJJXQDNDQ�NDLGDK�EHUSLNLU�WHUWHQWX�DJDU�GLDNXL�VHEDJDL�EXDK�GDUL�VXDWX�SURVHV�EHUSLNLU��E��,VODP�PHPLOLNL�VHMXPODK�QLODL�QLODL��DTLGDK�GDQ�TDLGDK��LWX�SDVWL��GDQ�LWX�GLDNXL�ROHK�-,/�VHQGLUL���WHUOHSDV�GDUL�DGDQ\D�VHMXPODK�SHUEHGDDQ�SHQGDSDW�WHUKDGDS�EHEHUDSD�PDWHUL�GDODP�DTLGDK�TDLGDK�WHUVHEXW��1LODL�QLODL�LWXODK�\DQJ�KDUXV�GLJXQDNDQ�DJDU�EXDK�SHPLNLUDQ��SHQDIVLUDQ��NLWD�WHUKDGDS�,VODP�PHQGDSDW�SHQJDNXDQ�VHEDJDL�EDJLDQ�GDUL�,VODP��6HEDJDLPDQD�KDOQ\D�VHEXDK�NDU\D�LOPLDK�GDODP�ELGDQJ�LOPX�WHUWHQWX��WLGDN�DNDQ�PHQGDSDW�SHQJDNXDQ�DSD�DSD�ELOD�WLGDN�PHQJJXQDNDQ�PHWRGH�LOPLDK�\DQJ�VHVXDL�GHQJDQ�ELGDQJ�SHPEDKDVDQ�NDU\D�WHUVHEXW��DSDNDK�LWX�ILVLND��VRVLRORJL�GDQ�ODLQQ\D��F��1DK��NDUHQD�-,/�WLGDN�PHQJJXQDNDQ�DTLGDK�GDQ�TDLGDK�,VODP�VHFDUD�GLVLSOLQ�GDQ�NRQVLVWHQ��NHFXDOL�\DQJ�VHVXDL�GHQJDQ�VHOHUD�EHUSLNLUQ\D��GDODP�PHODNXNDQ�SHQDIVLUDQ�EDJDLPDQD�PXQJNLQ�OD\DN�XQWXN�GLWHULPD�VHEDJDL�EDJLDQ�GDUL�,VODP��%DKNDQ�VXGDK�VHSDQWDVQ\D�NDODX�PHQXUXW�,VODP���VHNDOL�ODJL�PHQXUXW�,VODP���-,/�DGDODK�VHVDW�GDQ�NHOXDU�GDUL�,VODP��PHVNLSXQ�PHQXUXW�SHPLNLUDQ�OLEHUDO�VDK�VDK�VDMD��-DGL��EHUWDXEDWODK��'DQ�WLQJJDONDQ�ODK�RUDQJ�RUDQJ�\DQJ�PHQMDGLNDQ�DJDPD�PHUHND�VHEDJDL�SHUPDLQDQ�GDQ�VHQGD�JXUDX��GDQ�NHKLGXSDQ�GXQLD�WHODK�PHQLSX�PHUHND��'DQ�SHULQJDWNDQODK��PHUHND��GHQJDQ�$O�4XUDQ�LWX�DJDU�PDVLQJ�PDVLQJ�GLUL�WLGDN�GLMHUXPXVNDQ�NH�GDODP�QHUDND��NDUHQD�SHUEXDWDQQ\D�VHQGLUL�«���46�������2UDQJ�RUDQJ�\DQJ�PHQMDGLNDQ�DJDPD�PHUHND�VHEDJDL�SHUPDLQDQ�GDQ�VHQGD�JXUDX��GDQ�NHKLGXSDQ�GXQLD�WHODK�PHQLSX�PHUHND�PDND�SDGD�KDUL��NLDPDW��LQL��.DPL�PHOXSDNDQ�PHUHND�VHEDJDLPDQD�PHUHND�PHOXSDNDQ�SHUWHPXDQ�PHUHND�

3UHYLRXV _�1H[W _�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV

'DWH� 7XH�����'HF����������������������367�)URP� �\XVXI�DQVKDU���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!�� $GG�WR�$GGUHVV�%RRN6XEMHFW� WHQWDQJ�NDOLDQ7R� �8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD���XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP!

0DLO $GGUHVVHV &DOHQGDU 1RWHSDG 0DLO�8SJUDGHV ��0DLO�2SWLRQV&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

)ROGHUV'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 0RYH���

Page 4: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B����B���B���B����B�B�B����B����������,G[ �<< � ���'HF���

&RS\ULJKW�������������<DKRR� ,QF��$OO�ULJKWV�UHVHUYHG��7HUPV�RI�6HUYLFH ��&RS\ULJKW�3ROLF\ ��*XLGHOLQHV ��$G�)HHGEDFN127,&(��:H�FROOHFW�SHUVRQDO�LQIRUPDWLRQ�RQ�WKLV�VLWH�7R�OHDUQ�PRUH�DERXW�KRZ�ZH�XVH�\RXU�LQIRUPDWLRQ��VHH�RXU�3ULYDF\�3ROLF\

GHQJDQ�KDUL�LQL��GDQ��VHEDJDLPDQD��PHUHND�VHODOX�PHQGHEDW�D\DW�D\DW�.DPL����46������:DVVDODP�<XVXI8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD��XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP! ZURWH�

'R�\RX�<DKRR�"<DKRR��0DLO���QRZ�ZLWK����0%�IUHH�VWRUDJH��/HDUQ�PRUH�6DYH�0HVVDJH�7H[W

6DODP�6LODKNDQ�PHQJXQMXQJL�VLWXV�-,/�ZZZ�LVODPOLE�FRP��6HPXDEDKDQ�EDKDQ�\DQJ�DQGD�EXWXKNDQ�WHQWDQJ�-,/�DGD�GLVDQD�6HODPDW�PHPEDFD�8OLO

3UHYLRXV _�1H[W _�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 0RYH���

&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

Page 5: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B�����B���B����B����B�B�B����B����������,G[ �<< ���'HF���

<DKRR� 0\�<DKRR� 0DLO 6HDUFK:HOFRPH��\XVXIDQVKDU>6LJQ�2XW��0\�$FFRXQW@ 0DLO�+RPH ��0DLO�7XWRULDOV ��+HOS

&HOO�3KRQH�ZLWK1R�&UHGLW�&KHFN>$GG ��(GLW@,QER['UDIW6HQW

>(PSW\@7UDVK:KDWV�\RXU�&UHGLW6FRUH��FKHFN�LW�)5((����.�ORDQ�IRU�RQO\������PRQWK��*HW�<RXU�+RW/RZ�5DWHV�1RZ$�&UHGLW�&DUGIRU�<RX�

3ULQWDEOH�9LHZ ��)XOO�+HDGHUV

7KLV�PHVVDJH�LV�QRW�IODJJHG��>�)ODJ�0HVVDJH ��0DUN�DV�8QUHDG @

6DODP�6HEDLNQ\D�DQGD�EHODMDU�GDQ�PHPEDFD�OHELK�EDQ\DN�DJDUWLGDN�PXGDK�PHQJDQJJDS�EDWKLO�VXDWX�LGH�,VODP�WLGDN�PHPEXWXKNDQ�RUDQJ�RUDQJ�\DQJ�SLFLN�SLNLUDQGDQ�VXND�PHQ\HVDWNDQ�VHVDPD�0XVOLP�%DFD�ODJL�GDQ�EDFD�OHELK�EDQ\DN�ODJL�8OLO����\XVXI�DQVKDU��\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!�ZURWH�!�6HWHODK�VD\D�PHPEXND�EXND�GDQ�PHQHODDK�EHEHUDSD�OLQN!�GDODP�VLWXV�LVODPOLE��XWDPDQ\D�OLQN��7HQWDQJ�.DPL���!�VD\D�DNKLUQ\D�PHQJDPELO�NHVLPSXODQ�PHQJHQDL�,VODP!�/LEHUDO�VEE��!��!�,VODP�/LEHUDO�DGDODK�VXDWX�EHQWXN�SHQDIVLUDQ!�WHUKDGDS�,VODP�VHFDUD�EHEDV�GHQJDQ�PHQJDEDLNDQ!�DTLGDK�GDQ�TDLGDK�\DQJ�DGD�GDODP�,VODP�LWX�VHQGLUL�!�6LVWLP�SHPLNLUDQ�VHSHUWL�LQL�MHODV�EDWKLO�GDQ�VHVDW�!�.HQDSD�GHPLNLDQ"�%HJLQL�ORJLNDQ\D�!��!�D��6HPXD�XSD\D�SHQDIVLUDQ��SHPLNLUDQ��VHEHEDV�DSDSXQ!�GLD��WHQWX�PHQJJXQDNDQ�PHWRGH��NDLGDK�DWDX�SURVHV!�EHUSLNLU�WHUWHQWX��NDODX�WLGDN�GHPLNLDQ��LWX�EXNDQ!�WDIVLU�VHEDJDL�EXDK�SLNLU�PHODLQNDQ�OHELK�SDQWDV!�GLVHEXW�QJDZXU��QJODQWXU�DWDX�QJOLQGXU�!�.HVLPSXODQQ\D��WLGDN�DGD�SHPLNLUDQ�\DQJ�EHEDV�QLODL�!�GLD�KDUXV�PHQJJXQDNDQ�NDLGDK�EHUSLNLU�WHUWHQWX�DJDU!�GLDNXL�VHEDJDL�EXDK�GDUL�VXDWX�SURVHV�EHUSLNLU��!��!�E��,VODP�PHPLOLNL�VHMXPODK�QLODL�QLODL��DTLGDK�GDQ!�TDLGDK��LWX�SDVWL��GDQ�LWX�GLDNXL�ROHK�-,/�VHQGLUL��!�WHUOHSDV�GDUL�DGDQ\D�VHMXPODK�SHUEHGDDQ�SHQGDSDW!�WHUKDGDS�EHEHUDSD�PDWHUL�GDODP�DTLGDK�TDLGDK!�WHUVHEXW��1LODL�QLODL�LWXODK�\DQJ�KDUXV�GLJXQDNDQ!�DJDU�EXDK�SHPLNLUDQ��SHQDIVLUDQ��NLWD�WHUKDGDS�,VODP!�PHQGDSDW�SHQJDNXDQ�VHEDJDL�EDJLDQ�GDUL�,VODP�!�6HEDJDLPDQD�KDOQ\D�VHEXDK�NDU\D�LOPLDK�GDODP�ELGDQJ!�LOPX�WHUWHQWX��WLGDN�DNDQ�PHQGDSDW�SHQJDNXDQ�DSD�DSD

3UHYLRXV _�1H[W _�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV

'DWH� 6XQ�����'HF����������������������367�)URP� �8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD���XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP!�� 9LHZ�&RQWDFW�'HWDLOV�6XEMHFW� 5H��WHQWDQJ�NDOLDQ7R� �\XVXI�DQVKDU���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!

0DLO $GGUHVVHV &DOHQGDU 1RWHSDG 0DLO�8SJUDGHV ��0DLO�2SWLRQV&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

)ROGHUV'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 6SDP 0RYH���

Page 6: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B�����B����B���B���B�B�B����B����������,G[ �<< ����'HF���&RS\ULJKW�������������<DKRR� ,QF��$OO�ULJKWV�UHVHUYHG��7HUPV�RI�6HUYLFH ��&RS\ULJKW�3ROLF\ ��*XLGHOLQHV ��$G�)HHGEDFN

<DKRR� 0\�<DKRR� 0DLO 6HDUFK:HOFRPH��\XVXIDQVKDU>6LJQ�2XW��0\�$FFRXQW@ 0DLO�+RPH ��0DLO�7XWRULDOV ��+HOS

�����&HOO�3KRQH1R�&UHGLW�&KHFN�>$GG ��(GLW@,QER['UDIW6HQW

>(PSW\@7UDVK:KDWV�\RXU�&UHGLW�6FRUH��FKHFN�LW�)5((����.�ORDQ�IRU�RQO\������PRQWK��*HW�<RXU�+RW/RZ�5DWHV�1RZ%HVW�FDUGIRU�EDG�FUHGLW

3ULQWDEOH�9LHZ ��)XOO�+HDGHUV

7KLV�PHVVDJH�LV�QRW�IODJJHG��>�)ODJ�0HVVDJH ��0DUN�DV�8QUHDG @

6D\D�VDQJDW�VHWXMX�GHQJDQ�DQMXUDQ�DQGD�XWN�EDQ\DN�PHPEDFD��LWX�KREL�VD\D��7DSL�WRORQJ�MDZDE�SHUWDQ\DDQ�VD\D��$SDNDK�PHQHULPD�VHPXD�SHQGDSDW�DWDX�WLGDN�PHQRODN�VDWXSXQ�SHQGDSDW�DGDODK�V\DUDW�XWN�WHUKLQGDU�GDUL�SLFLN�SLNLUDQ"�$SDNDK�WLGDN�LQJLQ�GLNDWDNDQ�VHVDW�EXNDQ�VDODK�VDWX�EHQWXN�SLFLN�SLNLUDQ"�/HELK�MDXK�ODJL��VD\D�LQJLQ�WDKX�DTLGDK�NDXP�OLEHUDO���DSDNDK�PHQXUXW�DQGD�WLGDN�DGD�GLNKRWRPL�DQWDUD�KDT�GDQ�EDWKLO��EHQDU�GDQ�VDODK��OXUXV�GDQ�VHVDW":DVVDODP�<XVXI8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD��XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP! ZURWH�

'R�\RX�<DKRR�"<DKRR��0DLO���)LQG�ZKDW�\RX�QHHG�ZLWK�QHZ�HQKDQFHG�VHDUFK��/HDUQ�PRUH�6DYH�0HVVDJH�7H[W

3UHYLRXV _�1H[W _�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV

'DWH� 0RQ�����'HF����������������������367�)URP� �\XVXI�DQVKDU���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!�� $GG�WR�$GGUHVV�%RRN6XEMHFW� SLFLN7R� �8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD���XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP!

6DODP�6HEDLNQ\D�DQGD�EHODMDU�GDQ�PHPEDFD�OHELK�EDQ\DN�DJDUWLGDN�PXGDK�PHQJDQJJDS�EDWKLO�VXDWX�LGH�,VODP�WLGDN�PHPEXWXKNDQ�RUDQJ�RUDQJ�\DQJ�SLFLN�SLNLUDQGDQ�VXND�PHQ\HVDWNDQ�VHVDPD�0XVOLP�%DFD�ODJL�GDQ�EDFD�OHELK�EDQ\DN�ODJL�8OLO

3UHYLRXV _�1H[W _�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV

0DLO $GGUHVVHV &DOHQGDU 1RWHSDG 0DLO�8SJUDGHV ��0DLO�2SWLRQV&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

)ROGHUV'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 0RYH���

'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 0RYH���

&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

Page 7: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B�����B���B����B����B�B�B����B����������,G[ �<< ���'HF���

<DKRR� 0\�<DKRR� 0DLO 6HDUFK:HOFRPH��\XVXIDQVKDU>6LJQ�2XW��0\�$FFRXQW@ 0DLO�+RPH ��0DLO�7XWRULDOV ��+HOS

)UHH�3KRQH$W�&LQJXODU�>$GG ��(GLW@,QER['UDIW6HQW

>(PSW\@7UDVK:KDWV�\RXU�&UHGLW�6FRUH��FKHFN�LW�)5((����N�ORDQ�IRU�����PR��*R�*HW�<RXU�+RW/RZ�5DWHV�1RZ1R�&UHGLW"�*HWD�0DVWHU&DUG

3ULQWDEOH�9LHZ ��)XOO�+HDGHUV

7KLV�PHVVDJH�LV�QRW�IODJJHG��>�)ODJ�0HVVDJH ��0DUN�DV�8QUHDG @

6DODP�$QGD�EROHK�PHQHULPD�DWDX�PHQRODN�SLNLUDQ�DWDX�LGH�7HWDSL�WLGDN�EHUKDN�PHQ\HVDWNDQ�VXDWX�LGH��,WX�EXNDQFDUD�\DQJ�EDLN�XQWXN�EHUGLVNXVL��$SDODJL�DQGD�KDQ\DPHPEDFD�VHNHOXPLW�SLNLUDQ��GDQ�GHQJDQ�JDPSDQJ�PHQXGXKVXDWX�SLNLUDQ�\DQJ�VHNHOXPLW�LWX�VHEDJDL�VHVDW��,QLDGDODK�PRGHO�,VODP�D�OD�+DUWRQR�$KPDG�-DL]��DQGDNHQDO��SHQJDUDQJ�EXNX��3DKDP�6HVDW�GDODP�,VODP��LWX"��3DKDP�+DUWRQRLVPH�LQL�\DQJ�PHPEXDW�VLWXDVL�GLVNXVLGDODP�,VODP�PHQMDGL�WLGDN�NRQGXVLI��NDUHQD�GHQJDQPXGDK�VHVRUDQJ�GLVHVDWNDQ��GLNDILUNDQ��GLV\LULNNDQ�GVW��$NLGDK�NDXP�0XVOLP�OLEHUDO�DGDODK�EDKZD�VHWLDSSHPDKDPDQ�NLWD�DWDV�,VODP�DGDODK�UHODWLI��NDUHQD�WLGDNDGD�\DQJ�WDKX�NHEHQDUDQ�PXWODN�VHODLQ�$OODK�GDQUDVXO�1\D��.LWD�DGDODK�PDQXVLD�UHODWLI�\DQJ�PHQFREDXQWXN�PHPDKDPL�NHEHQDUDQ��:DK\X�WHODK�EHUKHQWL��6HWLDSRUDQJ�ELVD�PHQJXWLS�D\DW�DWDX�KDGLV��WHWDSL�SDGDDNKLUQ\D�DSD�\DQJ�LD�NDWDNDQ�DGDODK�SHQGDSDWQ\DVHQGLUL��EHOXP�WHQWX�VHVXDL�GHQJDQ�DSD�\DQJGLNHKHQGDNL�7XKDQ��2OHK�NDUHQD�LWX��VHVDW�PHQ\HVDWNDQVHSHUWL�\DQJ�DQGD�ODNXNDQ�DGDODK�EHUWHQWDQJDQ�GHQJDQVHPDQJDW�GDVDU�,VODP�VHEDJDLPDQD�GLSDKDPL�ROHK�NDXPOLEHUDO��.DPX�PHQJLNXWL�VHPDQJDW�\DQJ�GLNHPEDQJNDQROHK�SDUD�PXMWDKLG�GDKXOX���5D\XQD�VKDZDEXQ\DKWDPLOXO�NKDWKD��ZD�UD\X�NKDVKPLQD�NKWKDXQ\DKWDPLOXVK�VKDZDE���$QGD�EROHK�PHQJNULWLN�SDKDP�,VOLE��.DPL�MXJDPHQJNULWLN�SHPDKDPDQ�NHORPSRN�NHORPSRN�,VODP�ODLQ�7HWDSL�NDPL�WLGDN�VHWXMX�GHQJDQ�VHVDW�PHQ\HVDWNDQ�NDILU�PHQJNDILUNDQ��6HEDE��NDPL�PHQJDQJJDS�EDKZD�MDODQNHEHQDUDQ�PHQXMX�NHEHQDUDQ�DGDODK�EDQ\DN��%XNDQ�KDQ\DVDWX��,VODP�VDWX��\HV��7HWDSL�GLSDKDPL�VHFDUDEHGD�EHGD��7XKDQ�VDWX��\HV��7HWDSL�FDUD�PDQXVLDPHQGHNDWL�GDQ�PHPDKDPL�7XKDQ�EHUEHGD�EHGD��4XUDQVDWX��\HV��7HWDSL�WDIVLUQ\D�EHGD�EHGD��6D\D�PHQRODNDQJJDSDQ�EDKZD�VDWX�MHQLV�WDIVLU�DWDX�SHPDKDPDQ�DGDODKSDOLQJ�EHQDU��GDQ�\DQJ�ODLQ�GLDQJJDS�VHVDW��,VODP�OLEHUDO�WLGDN�SHUQDK�PHQGDNX��VHEDJDLPDQD�NDXP,VODP�IXQGDPHQWDOLV��EDKZD�GLULQ\D�SDOLQJ�EHQDU�.LWD�VHPXD�DGDODK��VDOLN���GDODP�LVWLODK�WDVDZZXI�

3UHYLRXV _�1H[W _�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV

'DWH� 0RQ�����'HF����������������������367�)URP� �8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD���XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP!�� 9LHZ�&RQWDFW�'HWDLOV�6XEMHFW� 5H��SLFLN7R� �\XVXI�DQVKDU���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!

0DLO $GGUHVVHV &DOHQGDU 1RWHSDG 0DLO�8SJUDGHV ��0DLO�2SWLRQV&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

)ROGHUV'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 6SDP 0RYH���

Page 8: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B�����B���B����B����B�B�B����B����������,G[ �<<���'HF���

SHMDODQ�NDNL�\DQJ�VHGDQJ�PHQFDUL�NHEHQDUDQ��6HPHQWDUDMDODQ�PHQXMX�NHSDGD�NHEHQDUDQ�LWX�EDQ\DN�UDJDPQ\D�7HUDNKLU��DSDNDK�DGD�GLNRWRPL�DQWDUD��KDT��GDQ�EDWKLO�"�-HODV�DGD��7HWDSL�EDJDLPDQD�NLWDPHQGHIHQLVLNDQ�WHQWDQJ�GXD�LVWLODK�WHUVHEXW��LWXODKPDVDODK�GDVDUQ\D��2UDQJ�RUDQJ�GHQJDQ�VHPDQJDW+DUWRQRLVPH�DNDQ�GHQJDQ�PXGDK�PHQXGXK�EDKZDSHQGDSDW�SHQGDSDW�\DQJ�EHUODZDQDQ�GHQJDQ�GLULQ\DDGDODK�EDWKLO��,QLODK�\DQJ�WHUMDGL�GDODP�,VODP�VHODPDLQL��VHPXD�NHORPSRN�PHQJDQJJDS�GLULQ\D�\DQJ�SDOLQJKDT��\DQJ�ODLQ�EDWKLO��2UDQJ�6XQQL�PHQJDQJJDS�RUDQJ6\LDK�EDWKLO��EHJLWX�MXJD�VHEDOLNQ\D��'L�GDODP�6XQQLVHQGLUL��PDVLQJ�PDVLQJ�NHORPSRN�PHPEDWKLONDQ�NHORPSRN\DQJ�ODLQ��%DJL�VD\D��,VODP�PHQMDGL�EXUXN�FLWUDQ\DNDUHQD�KDO�KDO�VHPDFDP�LQL�,VODP�OLEHUDO�PHQJKHQGDNL�EHQWXN�SHPDKDPDQ�,VODP�\DQJODLQ��\DNQL�SHPDKDPDQ�\DQJ�PHQHPSDWNDQ�VHPXD�SHUEHGDDQILUTDK��PD]KDE��LVPH��SDQGDQJDQ��LGHRORJL��DOLUDQ�GDQODLQ�ODLQQ\D�VHEDJDL�VHEXDK�NHND\DDQ�,VODP��GDQ�WLGDNEROHK�GLVHVDWNDQ�DWDX�GLNDILUNDQ��+DQ\D�GHQJDQ�EHJLWX,VODP�PHQMDGL�VXDWX�SHUDGDEDQ�\DQJ�ND\D��,VODP�DNDQPHQ\HPSLW�PHQMDGL�DJDPD�\DQJ�NHUGLO�MLND�RUDQJ�RUDQJ\DQJ�EHUSDQGDQJDQ�SLFLN�EDKZD�SHPDKDPDQQ\D�VHQGLULDGDODK�SDOLQJ�EHQDU��VHSHUWL�DQGD"��PDUDN�GLPDQD�PDQD��MLND�+DUWRQRLVPH�EHUNHFDPEDK�GDQEHUWDPEDK�WDPEDK�6HPRJD�SHQMHODVDQ�LQL�PHQFXNXSL�8OLO����\XVXI�DQVKDU��\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!�ZURWH�!�6D\D�VDQJDW�VHWXMX�GHQJDQ�DQMXUDQ�DQGD�XWN�EDQ\DN!�PHPEDFD��LWX�KREL�VD\D��!�7DSL�WRORQJ�MDZDE�SHUWDQ\DDQ�VD\D��!�!�$SDNDK�PHQHULPD�VHPXD�SHQGDSDW�DWDX�WLGDN�PHQRODN!�VDWXSXQ�SHQGDSDW�DGDODK�V\DUDW�XWN�WHUKLQGDU�GDUL!�SLFLN�SLNLUDQ"�!�!�$SDNDK�WLGDN�LQJLQ�GLNDWDNDQ�VHVDW�EXNDQ�VDODK�VDWX!�EHQWXN�SLFLN�SLNLUDQ"�!�!�/HELK�MDXK�ODJL��VD\D�LQJLQ�WDKX�DTLGDK�NDXP!�OLEHUDO���DSDNDK�PHQXUXW�DQGD�WLGDN�DGD�GLNKRWRPL!�DQWDUD�KDT�GDQ�EDWKLO��EHQDU�GDQ�VDODK��OXUXV�GDQ!�VHVDW"!��!�:DVVDODP�!�<XVXI!�!�8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD��XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP!�ZURWH�!�6DODP�!�6HEDLNQ\D�DQGD�EHODMDU�GDQ�PHPEDFD�OHELK�EDQ\DN�DJDU!�WLGDN�PXGDK�PHQJDQJJDS�EDWKLO�VXDWX�LGH�!�!�,VODP�WLGDN�PHPEXWXKNDQ�RUDQJ�RUDQJ�\DQJ!�SLFLN�SLNLUDQ!�GDQ�VXND�PHQ\HVDWNDQ�VHVDPD�0XVOLP�!�!�%DFD�ODJL�GDQ�EDFD�OHELK�EDQ\DN�ODJL�!�!�8OLO!�!�!�!�!����������������������������������!�'R�\RX�<DKRR�"!��<DKRR��0DLO���)LQG�ZKDW�\RX�QHHG�ZLWK�QHZ�HQKDQFHG!�VHDUFK��/HDUQ�PRUH�

Page 9: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B�����B����B���B����B�B��B�����B����������,G[ �<���'HF���

<DKRR� 0\�<DKRR� 0DLO 6HDUFK:HOFRPH��\XVXIDQVKDU>6LJQ�2XW��0\�$FFRXQW@ 0DLO�+RPH ��0DLO�7XWRULDOV ��+HOS

�����&HOO�3KRQH1R�&UHGLW�&KHFN�>$GG ��(GLW@,QER['UDIW6HQW

>(PSW\@7UDVK7LV�WKH�VHDVRQ�IRU�D)5((�&UHGLW�6FRUH&RQVROLGDWH+ROLGD\�GHEW�QRZ�)UHH�VKLSSLQJ�RUGHUV�����0DVWHU&DUG�WR%XLOG�&UHGLW

3ULQWDEOH�9LHZ ��)XOO�+HDGHUV

7KLV�PHVVDJH�LV�QRW�IODJJHG��>�)ODJ�0HVVDJH ��0DUN�DV�8QUHDG @

7HULPD�NDVLK��NDUHQD�SHPDKDPDQ�VD\D�WWJ�SHPDKDPDQ�NDXP�OLEHUDO�VHPDNLQ�EHUWDPEDK��1DPXQ�SHQMHODVDQ�DQGD�EXNDQQ\D�PHQFXNXSL�MXVWUX�EDUX�PHUXSDNDQ�DZDO�GDUL�GLVNXVL�NLWD�\J�PXQJNLQ�DNDQ�PHPDQMDQJ�GDQ�PHOHEDU��6D\D�KDUDS�DQGD�WHWDS�EHUVDEDU�PHODGHQL�8QJNDSDQ��\J�DQGD�NHPXNDNDQ�PHPDQJ�VHSLQWDV�FXNXS�LQGDK�GDQ�PHQ\HMXNNDQ��QDPXQ�VHVXQJJXKQ\D�VDQJDW�OHPDK�GDQ�PHQJJHOLNDQ��6DWX�FRQWRK�VDMD��LPEDXDQ�DQGD�DJDU�WLGDN�DGD�\J�GLVHVDWNDQ�DWDX�GLNDILUNDQ�NDUHQD�7XKDQ�VDWX�WDSL�FDUD�PHQGHNDWL�GDQ�PHPDKDPL�7XKDQ�EHUEHGD�EHGD��NLWD�DGDODK�SHQFDUL�NHEHQDUDQ�GDQ�MDODQ�XWN�PHQXMX�NHEHQDUDQ�LWX�EDQ\DN�UDJDPQ\D��2.�7DUXKODK��MDODQ�PHQXMX�7XKDQ�GDQ�.HEHQDUDQ�LWX�EHUDJDP�GDQ�EHUEHGD�EHGD��WDSL�DSDNDK�GLDQWDUD�VHNLDQ�EDQ\DN�MDODQ�LWX�WLGDN�DGD�\DQJ�VHVDW"�$SDNDK�DOLUDQ��VHNV�EHEDV��GDQ��EXQXK�GLUL�PDVVDO��GHQJDQ�DODVDQ�ULWXDO�SHQ\HPEDKDQ�NSG�7XKDQ��WLGDN�ELVD�GLNDWDNDQ�VHVDW"�%LVD�VDMD�DQGD�GHQJDQ�NHPDPSXDQ�EHURODK�NDWD�VHGHPLNLDQ�UXSD�GDSDW�PHQJHODN�SHQJJXQDDQ�FDS��VHVDW��WHUKDGDS�DOLUDQ�VHSHUWL�LWX��GHQJDQ�PHQJDWDNDQ�LWX�DGDODK�EHQWXN��SHQFDULDQ�7XKDQ�\J�EHOXP�VHOHVDL��DWDX��NHEHEDVDQ�EHUHNVSUHVL�GL�KDGDSDQ�7XKDQ�\J�NHEDEODVDQ��DWDX��SXQFDN�NHJLODDQ�PDQXVLD�GDODP�EHU�7XKDQ��GDQ�VHDEUHN�MXQJNLU�EDOLN�GDQVD�EDKDVD�\J�ODLQQ\D��QDPXQ�VD\D�NLUD�NLWD�GDQ�XPPDW�PDQXVLD�VHGXQLD�WHWDS�VDMD�OHELK�PXGDK�PHQHULPD�SHQJJXQDDQ�NDWD��VHVDW��WKG�PHUHND��1DK��NDODX�NLWD��DWDX�NHEDQ\DNDQ�NLWD��ELVD�PHQHULPD�FDS��VHVDW��WKG�JRORQJDQ���NHEDEODVDQ��VHPDFDP�LWX��PHQJDSD�NLWD�KDUXV�PHQRODN�SHQJJXQDDQ�NDWD��VHVDW��WKG�VHMXPODK�JRORQJDQ��WHUWHQWX�PHVNL�GJ�NDGDU�GDQ�WLQJNDW�NHVHVDWDQ�\J�EHUEHGD�EHGD"�6SW�XQJNDSDQ�7XKDQ�GOP�DO�4XUDQ�WWJ��NHFRQGRQJDQ�\J�VHGLNLW��GHQJDQ�NDOLPDW������ODTDG�NLGWD�WDUNDQX�LODLKLP�V\DLDQ�TDOLODQ��>46������@�GDQ��NHVHVDWDQ�\J�MDXK��GHQJDQ�NDOLPDW������IDTDG�GKDOOD�GKDODODQ�EDLGDQ��>46������@�,WX�KDQ\D�VDWX�FRQWRK�NRPHQWDU�VD\D�WKG�XUDLDQ�DQGD��.RPHQWDU��\J�ODLQQ\D�VD\D�VLPSDQ�GXOX�DJDU�GLVNXVL�NLWD�WLGDN�WHUODOX�PHPDQMDQJ�GDQ�PHOHEDU���'L�DWDV�VD\D�NDWDNDQ�LQL�EDUX�DZDO�GDUL�GLVNXVL�NLWD�NDUHQD�VD\D�PHOLKDW�WLWLN�SDQJNDO�SHPELFDUDDQ�\J�PXGDK�DQ�ELVD�PHQJXUDL�EHQDQJ�DWDX�MDULQJ�NXVXW�

3UHYLRXV _�1H[W _�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV

'DWH� 7XH�����'HF����������������������367�)URP� �\XVXI�DQVKDU���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!�� $GG�WR�$GGUHVV�%RRN6XEMHFW� EDUX�DZDO7R� �8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD���XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP!

0DLO $GGUHVVHV &DOHQGDU 1RWHSDG 0DLO�8SJUDGHV ��0DLO�2SWLRQV&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

)ROGHUV'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 0RYH���

Page 10: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B�����B����B���B����B�B��B�����B����������,G[ � ���'HF���

GDUL�SHPLNLUDQ��-DULQJDQ�8PPDW�/LEHUDO���XVXO�VD\D�-,/�EHUJDQWL�QDPD�GXOX�PHQMDGL�-8/���7LWLN�DZDO�GLVNXVL�NLWD�DGDODK�XFDSDQ�DQGD��������DSDNDK�DGD�GLNRWRPL�DQWDUD�KDT�GDQ�EDWKLO"�-HODV�DGD��7HWDSL�EDJDLPDQD�NLWD�PHQGHIHQLVLNDQ�WHQWDQJ�GXD�LVWLODK�WHUVHEXW��LWXODK�PDVDODK�GDVDUQ\D���<DK��LWXODK�PDVDODK�GDVDUQ\D��.DODX�EHJLWX��DSD�GHIHQLVL�NDXP�OLEHUDO�VHQGLUL�WWJ�DO�KDT�GDQ�DO�EDWKLO":DVVDODP�<XVXI8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD��XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP! ZURWH�6DODP�$QGD�EROHK�PHQHULPD�DWDX�PHQRODN�SLNLUDQ�DWDX�LGH�7HWDSL�WLGDN�EHUKDN�PHQ\HVDWNDQ�VXDWX�LGH��,WX�EXNDQFDUD�\DQJ�EDLN�XQWXN�EHUGLVNXVL��$SDODJL�DQGD�KDQ\DPHPEDFD�VHNHOXPLW�SLNLUDQ��GDQ�GHQJDQ�JDPSDQJ�PHQXGXKVXDWX�SLNLUDQ�\DQJ�VHNHOXPLW�LWX�VHEDJDL�VHVDW��,QLDGDODK�PRGHO�,VODP�D�OD�+DUWRQR�$KPDG�-DL]��DQGDNHQDO��SHQJDUDQJ�EXNX��3DKDP�6HVDW�GDODP�,VODP��LWX"��3DKDP�+DUWRQRLVPH�LQL�\DQJ�PHPEXDW�VLWXDVL�GLVNXVLGDODP�,VODP�PHQMDGL�WLGDN�NRQGXVLI��NDUHQD�GHQJDQPXGDK�VHVRUDQJ�GLVHVDWNDQ��GLNDILUNDQ��GLV\LULNNDQ�GVW��$NLGDK�NDXP�0XVOLP�OLEHUDO�DGDODK�EDKZD�VHWLDSSHPDKDPDQ�NLWD�DWDV�,VODP�DGDODK�UHODWLI��NDUHQD�WLGDNDGD�\DQJ�WDKX�NHEHQDUDQ�PXWODN�VHODLQ�$OODK�GDQUDVXO�1\D��.LWD�DGDODK�PDQXVLD�UHODWLI�\DQJ�PHQFREDXQWXN�PHPDKDPL�NHEHQDUDQ��:DK\X�WHODK�EHUKHQWL��6HWLDSRUDQJ�ELVD�PHQJXWLS�D\DW�DWDX�KDGLV��WHWDSL�SDGDDNKLUQ\D�DSD�\DQJ�LD�NDWDNDQ�DGDODK�SHQGDSDWQ\DVHQGLUL��EHOXP�WHQWX�VHVXDL�GHQJDQ�DSD�\DQJGLNHKHQGDNL�7XKDQ��2OHK�NDUHQD�LWX��VHVDW�PHQ\HVDWNDQVHSHUWL�\DQJ�DQGD�ODNXNDQ�DGDODK�EHUWHQWDQJDQ�GHQJDQVHPDQJDW�GDVDU�,VODP�VHEDJDLPDQD�GLSDKDPL�ROHK�NDXPOLEHUDO��.DPX�PHQJLNXWL�VHPDQJDW�\DQJ�GLNHPEDQJNDQROHK�SDUD�PXMWDKLG�GDKXOX���5D\XQD�VKDZDEXQ\DKWDPLOXO�NKDWKD��ZD�UD\X�NKDVKPLQD�NKWKDXQ\DKWDPLOXVK�VKDZDE���$QGD�EROHK�PHQJNULWLN�SDKDP�,VOLE��.DPL�MXJDPHQJNULWLN�SHPDKDPDQ�NHORPSRN�NHORPSRN�,VODP�ODLQ�7HWDSL�NDPL�WLGDN�VHWXMX�GHQJDQ�VHVDW�PHQ\HVDWNDQ�NDILU�PHQJNDILUNDQ��6HEDE��NDPL�PHQJDQJJDS�EDKZD�MDODQNHEHQDUDQ�PHQXMX�NHEHQDUDQ�DGDODK�EDQ\DN��%XNDQ�KDQ\DVDWX��,VODP�VDWX��\HV��7HWDSL�GLSDKDPL�VHFDUDEHGD�EHGD��7XKDQ�VDWX��\HV��7HWDSL�FDUD�PDQXVLDPHQGHNDWL�GDQ�PHPDKDPL�7XKDQ�EHUEHGD�EHGD��4XUDQVDWX��\HV��7HWDSL�WDIVLUQ\D�EHGD�EHGD��6D\D�PHQRODNDQJJDSDQ�EDKZD�VDWX�MHQLV�WDIVLU�DWDX�SHPDKDPDQ�DGDODKSDOLQJ�EHQDU��GDQ�\DQJ�ODLQ�GLDQJJDS�VHVDW��,VODP�OLEHUDO�WLGDN�SHUQDK�PHQGDNX��VHEDJDLPDQD�NDXP,VODP�IXQGDPHQWDOLV��EDKZD�GLULQ\D�SDOLQJ�EHQDU�.LWD�VHPXD�DGDODK��VDOLN���GDODP�LVWLODK�WDVDZZXI�SHMDODQ�NDNL�\DQJ�VHGDQJ�PHQFDUL�NHEHQDUDQ��6HPHQWDUDMDODQ�PHQXMX�NHSDGD�NHEHQDUDQ�LWX�EDQ\DN�UDJDPQ\D�7HUDNKLU��DSDNDK�DGD�GLNRWRPL�DQWDUD��KDT��GDQ�EDWKLO�"�-HODV�DGD��7HWDSL�EDJDLPDQD�NLWDPHQGHIHQLVLNDQ�WHQWDQJ�GXD�LVWLODK�WHUVHEXW��LWXODKPDVDODK�GDVDUQ\D��2UDQJ�RUDQJ�GHQJDQ�VHPDQJDW+DUWRQRLVPH�DNDQ�GHQJDQ�PXGDK�PHQXGXK�EDKZDSHQGDSDW�SHQGDSDW�\DQJ�EHUODZDQDQ�GHQJDQ�GLULQ\DDGDODK�EDWKLO��,QLODK�\DQJ�WHUMDGL�GDODP�,VODP�VHODPDLQL��VHPXD�NHORPSRN�PHQJDQJJDS�GLULQ\D�\DQJ�SDOLQJ

Page 11: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ���B�����B����B����B����B�B��B�����B���������,G[ �<<���'HF���

<DKRR� 0\�<DKRR� 0DLO 6HDUFK:HOFRPH��\XVXIDQVKDU>6LJQ�2XW��0\�$FFRXQW@ 0DLO�+RPH ��0DLO�7XWRULDOV ��+HOS

)UHH�3KRQH$W�&LQJXODU�>$GG ��(GLW@,QER['UDIW6HQW

>(PSW\@7UDVK7LV�WKH�VHDVRQ�IRU�D)5((�&UHGLW�6FRUH����.�ORDQ�IRU�RQO\������PRQWK��)UHH�VKLSSLQJ�RUGHUV�����1HHG�FUHGLW"*HW�RXU�FDUG�

3ULQWDEOH�9LHZ ��)XOO�+HDGHUV

7KLV�PHVVDJH�LV�QRW�IODJJHG��>�)ODJ�0HVVDJH ��0DUN�DV�8QUHDG @

6DODP�6HWDKX�VD\D��\DQJ�VXND�EHUPDLQ�VLODW�OLGDK��GDQEHUPDLQ�GHQJDQ�UHWRULND�EDKDVD�\DQJ�VHRODK�RODKPH\DNLQNDQ�DGDODK�NDXP�IXQGDPHQWDOLV��$\DW�GDQ�KDGLVNHUDS�GLKDPEXU�KDPEXUNDQ��6DWX�GXD�NDOLPDW�ODQJVXQJSHQXK�VHVDN�GHQJDQ�NXWLSDQ�NXWLSDQ�GDUL�.LWDE�6XFL�6HRODK�RODK�VXDWX�SHPELFDUDDQ�\DQJ�SHQXK�GHQJDQ�D\DWVXFL�DNDQ�EHQDU�GHQJDQ�VHQGLULQ\D��6D\D�EHODMDU�GL�SHVDQWUHQ��3HQJDODPDQ�\DQJ�VD\DSHURODK�GDUL�SHVDQWUHQ�DGDODK��NLDL�NLDL�VD\D�MDUDQJPHQJXWLS�D\DW�GDQ�KDGLV��NDUHQD�PHUHND�NKDZDWLU�NHOLUXPHQDIVLUNDQ��3DOLQJ�MDXK�PHUHND�PHQJXWLS�SHQGDSDWXODPD�DWDX�NLDL�\DQJ�ODLQ��.DODX�SXQ�NHOLUX��WDNDSD�DSD��WRK�PHUHND�PDQXVLD��,WXODK�SHQJDODPDQ�\DQJPHPEHNDV�SDGD�GLUL�VD\D�KLQJJD�VHNDUDQJ��'DQ�LWXODK\DQJ�PHPEXDW�VD\D�DJDN��PXDN��PHOLKDW�NDXPIXQGDPHQWDOLV�GL�NDPSXV�NDPSXV�\DQJ�VHWLDS�ELFDUDVHODOX�PHPHUFLNNDQ�D\DW�GDQ�KDGLV�GL�PDQD�PDQD��$\DW�GDQ�KDGLV�ELVD�PHQJDODPL�LQIODVL�MLND�GLREUDOGHQJDQ�FDUD�GHPLNLDQ��.HPEDOL�NH�SRNRN�VRDO�\DQJ�DQGD��VD\D�WDN�PDX�SDNDLNDWD��DQWXP��D�OD�NDXP�IXQGDPHQWDOLV�GL�-DNDUWD�SHUVRDONDQ��6RDO�NHEHEDVDQ�PHQDIVLU��.HEHEDVDQ�PHQDIVLU�VXGDK�PHQMDGL�NHQ\DWDDQ�GDQ�IDNWDGDODP�VHMDUDK�SHPLNLUDQ�,VODP��,WX�WHUMDGL�GDUL�VHMDN]DPDQ�VDKDEDW�GDQ�PDNLQ�EHUNHPEDQJ�SDGDJHQHUDVL�JHQHUDVL�XODPD�\DQJ�GDWDQJ�EHODNDQJDQ��5LEXDQWDIVLU�GDUL�SHOEDJDL�VXGXW�SHQGHNDWDQ�GLWXOLV�ROHKXODPD��$GD�WDIVLU�\DQJ�OLEHUDO�DWDX�\DQJ�OLWHUDO��$GDWDIVLU�GHQJDQ�SHQGHNDWDQ�VXIL�\DQJ�VDQJDW��EHEDV��GDQDGD�WDIVLU��ELO�PDWVXU��D�OD��DO�'XUU�DO�0DQWVXU�\DQJ�VDQJDW�WDDW�GHQJDQ�SHPDKDPDQ�KDUILDK��5LEXDQ�WDIVLU�LWX�WDN�PXQJNLQ�GLWXOLV�MLND�WDN�DGDNHEHEDVDQ�EHUSHQGDSDW�GDQ�EHUSLNLU�GDODP�,VODP�<DQJ�VD\D�NDJHW��XPDW�,VODP�VHNDUDQJ��\DQJ�XPXPQ\D�WDNEHODMDU�WUDGLVL�SHPLNLUDQ�,VODP�\DQJ�ND\D��WLED�WLEDPHPEHQFL�NHEHEDVDQ�EHUSLNLU��$GD�DGD�VDMD�DODVDQQ\D�6DODK�VDWX�DODVDQQ\D��NHEHEDVDQ�EHUSLNLU�LWXODK�\DQJPHQ\HEDENDQ�,EOLV�WHUMDWXK�GDQ�VHVDW��6HEDE�,EOLVPHPDNDL�SLNLUDQQ\D�VHQGLUL�GDQ�PHQRODN�SHULQWDK�7XKDQ�.HWDXKLODK�VDXGDUDNX��DUJXPHQ�LQL�VXGDK�SHUQDK�GLSDNDLROHK�SDUD�XODPD�GDKXOX�\DQJ�PHQHQWDQJ�SHQJJXQDDQ�TL\DV

3UHYLRXV�_�1H[W _�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV

'DWH� 7XH�����'HF����������������������367�)URP� �8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD���XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP!�� 9LHZ�&RQWDFW�'HWDLOV�6XEMHFW� 5H��EDUX�DZDO7R� �\XVXI�DQVKDU���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!

0DLO $GGUHVVHV &DOHQGDU 1RWHSDG 0DLO�8SJUDGHV ��0DLO�2SWLRQV&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

)ROGHUV'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 6SDP 0RYH���

Page 12: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ���B�����B����B����B����B�B��B�����B���������,G[ �< ���'HF���

DWDX�VLORJLVPH��WHWDSL�WRK�XODPD�ODLQ�WDN�WHUSHQJDUXKGHQJDQ�SHQGDSDW�LQL��GDQ�WHWDS�PHQJDQJJDS�TL\DVVHEDJDL�VDODK�VDWX�DVDV�SHQWLQJ�GDODP�LVWLQEDWK�KXNXP�$ODVDQ�ODLQ�\DQJ�SDOLQJ�SRSXOHU��GDQ�WDPSDNQ\D�GLVLQLODK�DQGD��VHNDOL�ODJL�EXNDQ��DQWXP���WHUMDWXK�DGDODK�EDKZD�MLND�NHEHEDVDQ�EHUSLNLU�GLELDUNDQ��PDNDRUDQJ�DNDQ�FHQGHUXQJ�NHEDEODVDQ��$SDNDK�GHPL�NHEHEDVDQEHUSLNLU��VHNV�EHEDV��GLKDODONDQ"�$SDNDK�GHPLNHEHEDVDQ��FDUD�FDUD�LEDGDK�GHQJDQ�EXQXK�GLUL�PDVVDOGLSHUEROHKNDQ"�.DODX�VHPXD�SHQGHNDWDQ�NHSDD�7XKDQDGDODK�VDK��DSDNDK�FDUD��JLOD��\DQJ�GLWHPSXK�ROHKVHNWH�VHSHUWL��5DQWLQJ�'DXG��LWX�DEVDK"'DQ�VHWHUXVQ\D��6D\D�VXQJJXK�KHUDQ�GHQJDQ�WDQJJDSDQ�VHPDFDP�LQL�2UDQJ�RUDQJ�\DQJ�EHUMXDQJ�XQWXN�WDJDNQ\D�NHEHEDVDQSLNLUDQ��EDLN�GL�%DUDW�DWDX�GL�7LPXU��WLGDN�SHUQDKEHUSLNLU�EDKZD�KDO�LWX�XQWXN�PHQJKDODONDQ��VHNVEHEDV���<DQJ�SDWXW�GLFXULJDL�DGDODK��NHQDSD�VRDO�VHNVEHJLWX�PHQJJDQJJX�SLNLUDQ�XPDW�,VODP��$SDNDK�PHUHNDEHJLWX��QJHUHV��SLNLUDQQ\D��VHKLQJJD�GLSHQXKL�GHQJDQVHNV�PHOXOX".HQDSD�KDO�\DQJ�SHUWDPD�WHUOLQWDV�GL�SLNLUDQ�DQGDEHJLWX�PHQGHQJDU�VRDO��NHEHEDVDQ�EHUSLNLU��DGDODK�VRDOVHNV"�$SDNDK�DQGD�PHPSXQ\DL�PDVDODK�GDODP�KDO�LQL�PDDI�"6HPXD�DJDPD��EXNDQ�KDQ\D�,VODP�PHQJKDUDPNDQ�]LQD�6HPXD�DJDPD�PHQJKDUDPNDQ�SHPEXQXKDQ��SHQFXULDQ�EHUERKRQJ��PHQLSX��EHUVLNDS�WDN�KRUPDW�SDGD�RUDQJ�WXD�GVW��$SD�\DQJ�GDODP�WUDGLVL�<DKXGL�GLVHEXW�VHEDJDL�6HSXOXK�3HUMDQMLDQ���7HQ�&RPPDQGHPHQW��DGDODKPHUXSDNDQ�DMDUDQ�DMDUDQ�\DQJ�XQLYHUVDO��EXNDQ�VDMDGDODP�DJDPD�<DKXGL�WHWDSL�MXJD�,VODP�GDQ�DJDPD�DJDPDODLQ��3UDNWHN�SUDNWHN�SHQ\HPEDKDQ�DJDPD�\DQJ�PHODQJJDUSULQVLS�LWX��DNDQ�GHQJDQ�VHQGLULQ\D�GLWRODN�ROHKDJDPD�DJDPD�EHVDU��'L�QHJHUL�QHJHUL�\DQJ�PHQMXQMXQJ�WLQJJL�SHPLNLUDQ�\DQJEHEDV��SHQFXULDQ�GDQ�SHPEXQXKDQ�WLGDN�GHQJDQVHQGLULQ\D�KDODO�GHPL�NHEHEDVDQ�EHUSLNLU��'L�VLQLODK�VD\D�SHUFD\D��EDKZD�DNDO�PDQXVLD�GDQ�ZDK\X7XKDQ�VHEHWXOQ\D�EHUWHPX�GDODP�VDWX�WLWLN��,QLODK�\DQJGLNDWDNDQ�ROHK�,EQ�7D\PL\DK�VHEDJDL��0XZDIDTDW6KDULKLO�0DTXO�OL�6KDKLKLO�0DQTXO���%DJDLPDQD�MLND�ZDK\X�GDQ�DNDO�EHUWHQWDQJDQ"6D\D�PHQJLNXWL�SHQGDSDW�,EQ�5XVKG��VHRUDQJ�ILORVRI�GDQDKOL�ILNLK�GDUL�DEDG����0��GDODP��)DVKO�DO�0DTDO�)L�0D%DLQD�DO�+LNPDWL�ZDV�6\DULDWL�PLQ�DO�,WWLVKDO��0HQXUXW�GLD��MLND�DGD�SHUWHQWDQJDQ�DQWDUD�NHGXDQ\D�PDND�ZDK\X�KDUXV�GLWDNZLO��7HWDSL��KDO�LQL�KDUXVGLOLKDW�GHQJDQ�FHUPDW��7LGDN�VHPXD�SHQGDSDW�DNDOPDQXVLD�GHQJDQ�VHQGLULQ\D�VDK��+DQ\D�SHQGDSDW�\DQJGDODP�LVWLODK�,EQ�7D\PL\DK�GLVHEXW��VKDULK���SHQGDSDW\DQJ�GLODQGDVL�GHQJDQ�DUJXPHQ�\DQJ�NRNRK��GDQ�EXNDQVHNHGDU�PHPSHUWXUXWNDQ�KDZD�QDIVX�EHODND��\DQJ�GDSDWGLSHUWLPEDQJNDQ�$SD�SHQGDSDW�\DQJ��VKDULK��LWX"�,EQ�5XVKG�VHQGLULWLGDN�PHQHWDSNDQ�VXDWX�DQFDU�DQFDU��%DJL�VD\D�DQFDU�DQFDU�LWX�WLGDN�NHWDW��NDNX��VHEDE�SDGD�DNKLUQ\D\DQJ�PHQHQWXNDQ�VHEXDK�SHQGDSDW�PDVXN�DNDO�GDQ�WLGDNDGDODK�NDODQJDQ�FHUGLN�SDQGDL�VHQGLUL��,EQ�5XVKGVHQGLUL�VXGDK�PHQJDWDNDQ�GDODP��%LGD\DW�DO�0XMWDKLG�EDKZD��DO�QXVKXVK�PXWDQDKL\DK�ZD�DO�ZDTDL�JKDLUXPXWDQDKL\DK���WHNV�WHNV�DJDPD�GDQ�ZDK\X�WHUEDWDVMXPODKQ\D��VHPHQWDUD�VLWXDVL�VRVLDO�WHUXV�EHUXEDK�%DJDLPDQD�PXQJNLQ��NDWD�,EQ�5XVGK��VHVXDWX�\DQJWHUEDWDV�DNDQ�PHQJDWDVL�\DQJ�WDN�WHUEDWDV��'L�VLWXODKDNDO�PDQXVLD�GDQ�NHEHEDVDQ�EHUSLNLU�GLSHUOXNDQ��

Page 13: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ���B�����B����B����B����B�B��B�����B���������,G[ �< ���'HF���

7HQWDQJ�PDVDODK��KDT��GDQ��EDWKLO���MHODV�KDO�LWX�DGD�<DQJ�PHQMDGL�VRDO�DGDODK�RUDQJ�RUDQJ�\DQJ�VHMHQLVGHQJDQ�DQGD�\DQJ�PXGDK��PHPEDWKLONDQ��SDQGDQJDQRUDQJ�RUDQJ�\DQJ�EHUEHGD��$QGD�PHQ\HEXW�-,/�EDWKLO"$WDV�GDVDU�DSD"�$WDV�GDVDU�NXWLSDQ�D\DW�GDQ�KDGLV�\DQJEHUKDPEXUDQ�GHQJDQ�VHHQDNQ\D�LWX"�$SDNDK�NDODX�VXGDKPHQJXWLS�D\DW�ODOX�VHOHVDL"�%XNDQNDK�D\DW�ELVDGLWDIVLUNDQ�PDFDP�PDFDP�$PELO�FRQWRK�D\DW�EHULNXW�LQL��$GD�D\DW�\DQJ�EHUEXQ\L��/D�WXGULNXKXO�DEVKDU�ZD�KXZD�\XGULNXO�DEVKDU�ZD�KXZDOODWKLIXO�NKDELU���$\DW�LWX��NLUD�NLUD��LVLQ\D�DGDODKEDKZD�7XKDQ�LWX�EHJLWX�OHPEXW�VHKLQJJD�WDN�ELVDGLOLKDW�ROHK�PDWD��2OHK�NDUHQD�LWX��PDQXVLD�WDN�DNDQELVD�PHOLKDW�7XKDQ��PHVNLSXQ�GL�VRUJD��$WDV�GDVDU�D\DWLQLODK�NDXP�0XWD]LODK�PHQRODN�NHPXQJNLQDQ�PDQXVLDPHOLKDW�7XKDQ�GL�VRUJD��7HWDSL�DGD�D\DW�ODLQ���:XMXKXQ�\DXPD�LG]LQ�QDGKLUDK�LOD�UDEELKD�QDGOLUDK���$\DW�LWX�NLUD�NLUD�LVLQ\DDGDODK�EDKZD�RUDQJ�RUDQJ�\DQJ�EHULPDQ��GL�VRUJD�QDQWL�DNDQ�PHOLKDW�7XKDQ��$WDV�GDVDU�LQLODK�NDXP�$V\DUL\\DKEHUSHQGDSDW�EDKZD�PDQXVLD�PXQJNLQ�PHOLKDW�7XKDQ�GLVRUJD��%DJDLPDQD�DQGD�PHQGDPDLNDQ�DQWDUD�NHGXD�D\DW�LWX��.DXP0XWD]LODK�SDNDL�D\DW��.DXP�$V\DUL\DK�SDNDL�D\DW��0DQD\DQJ�EHQDU�,QWLQ\D��EHOXP�WHQWX�NDODX�DQGD�PHPDNDL�D\DW�GDQ�KDGLVGHQJDQ�VHQGLULQ\D�DQGD�VXGDK�ELVD�PHQ\XGDKL�GLVNXVLGDQ�PHQXGXK�\DQJ�ODLQ�VDODK��VHVDW��EDWKLO��PXUWDG�NDILU��GVW�6D\D�PHQJDNXL�DGDQ\D�\DQJ��KDT��GDQ�\DQJ��EDWKLO��7HWDSL�VD\D��VHEDJDL�PDQXVLD��PHPSXQ\DL�SHQJHWDKXDQ\DQJ�WHUEDWDV��GDQ�VD\D�WDN�OD\DN�GHQJDQ�EHJLWX�PXGDKPHQ\DODKNDQ�GDQ�PHPEDWKLONDQ�SHQGDSDW�ODLQ��<DQJ�VD\DODNXNDQ�KDQ\DODK�PHQJNULWLN��WHWDSL�VD\D�WLGDN�DNDQSHUQDK�VDPSDL�SDGD�NHVLPSXODQ�EDKZD�SHQGDSDW�ODZDQVD\D�EDWKLO��NHFXDOL�MLND�SHQGDSDW�LWX�MHODV�MHODVPHODZDQ�DNDO�VHKDW��.DODX�DGD�RUDQJ�EHUSHQGDSDW�EDKZDPHPEXQXK�DGDODK�KDODO��MHODV�LWX�EDWDO��GDUL�VXGXWSDQGDQJ�DSDSXQ��7HWDSL�VD\D�WLGDN�DNDQ�PHQJDWDNDQEDKZD�FDUD�EHULEDGDK�RUDQJ�.ULVWHQ�GDQ�+LQGX�DGDODKEDWDO��'DODP�PHQJKXNXPL�VHVXWDX��EDWKDO��DWDX��KDT���NLWDKDUXV�PHPDNDL�GXD�LQVWUXPHQ��ZDK\X�GDQ�DNDO��7LGDNELVD�KDQ\D�GHQJDQ�ZDK\X��2OHK�NDUHQD�LWX��VD\DNHEHUDWDQ�VHNDOL�GHQJDQ�WLQGDNDQ�FHURERK�SDUD�NDXPIXQGDPHQWDOLV�\DQJ�PHQJREUDO�D\DW�GDQ�KDGLV��WHWDSLPHQJDEDLNDQ�SHQDODUDQ�DNDO�VHKDW�$OD�NXOOL�KDO��DSD�\DQJ�VD\D�WXOLV�LQL�EHOXP�WHQWXEHQDU��6HEDE�KDQ\D�$OODK�ODK�\DQJ�WDKX�PDQD�\DQJ�EHQDUPDQD�\DQJ�VDODK��.LWD�KDQ\D�EHUXVDKD�XQWXN�EHQDU�8OLO����\XVXI�DQVKDU��\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!�ZURWH�!�7HULPD�NDVLK��NDUHQD�SHPDKDPDQ�VD\D�WWJ�SHPDKDPDQ!�NDXP�OLEHUDO�VHPDNLQ�EHUWDPEDK��!��!�1DPXQ�SHQMHODVDQ�DQGD�EXNDQQ\D�PHQFXNXSL�MXVWUX�EDUX!�PHUXSDNDQ�DZDO�GDUL�GLVNXVL�NLWD�\J�PXQJNLQ�DNDQ!�PHPDQMDQJ�GDQ�PHOHEDU��6D\D�KDUDS�DQGD�WHWDS!�EHUVDEDU�PHODGHQL�!��!�8QJNDSDQ��\J�DQGD�NHPXNDNDQ�PHPDQJ�VHSLQWDV�FXNXS!�LQGDK�GDQ�PHQ\HMXNNDQ��QDPXQ�VHVXQJJXKQ\D�VDQJDW!�OHPDK�GDQ�PHQJJHOLNDQ��6DWX�FRQWRK�VDMD��LPEDXDQ!�DQGD�DJDU�WLGDN�DGD�\J�GLVHVDWNDQ�DWDX�GLNDILUNDQ!�NDUHQD�7XKDQ�VDWX�WDSL�FDUD�PHQGHNDWL�GDQ�PHPDKDPL!�7XKDQ�EHUEHGD�EHGD��NLWD�DGDODK�SHQFDUL�NHEHQDUDQ

Page 14: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B�����B����B���B����B�B��B�����B���������,G[ �<<���'HF���

<DKRR� 0\�<DKRR� 0DLO 6HDUFK:HOFRPH��\XVXIDQVKDU>6LJQ�2XW��0\�$FFRXQW@ 0DLO�+RPH ��0DLO�7XWRULDOV ��+HOS

)UHH�&RORU)OLS�3KRQHV�>$GG ��(GLW@,QER['UDIW6HQW

>(PSW\@7UDVK7LV�WKH�VHDVRQ�IRU�D)5((�&UHGLW�6FRUH����.�ORDQ�IRU�RQO\������PRQWK��*HW�<RXU�+RW/RZ�5DWHV�1RZ5H�HVWDEOLVK&UHGLW�1RZ�

3ULQWDEOH�9LHZ ��)XOO�+HDGHUV

7KLV�PHVVDJH�LV�QRW�IODJJHG��>�)ODJ�0HVVDJH ��0DUN�DV�8QUHDG @

0HPEDFD�HPDLO�DQGD�\J�ODOX��NHVDQ�\J�VD\D�WDQJNDS�DGDODK�XUDLDQ�DQGD�OHELK�EDQ\DN�PHUXSDNDQ�FXUDKDQ�SHUDVDDQ�GDQ�HPRVL�\J�FDPSXU�DGXN��NHVDO�PXDN�VLQLV�NDJHW�ELQJXQJ�MDGL�VDWX���6D\D�PHQJHUWL�SHUDVDDQ�DQGD�GDQ�VD\D�WXUXW�SULKDWLQ�GJ�NHNHVDODQ�GDQ�NHELQJXQJDQ�DQGD��1DPXQ�XSD\D�VD\D�XWN�VHGLNLW�PHQMHUQLKNDQ�GDQ�PHQHQDQJNDQ�DUXV�SHPLNLUDQ�NLWD�DJDN�WHUKDPEDW�GJ�FXUDKDQ�SHPLNLUDQ��GDQ�HPRVL��DQGD�\J�FXNXS�GHUDV��%DUDQJNDOL�PHPDQJ�EHJLWX�FDUD�EHUSLNLU�GDQ�PRGHO�GLVNXVL�DQGD�GDQ�NRPXQLWDV�DQGD�GL�XWDQ�ND\X��+DQ\D�VDMD�VD\D�WDN�LQJLQ�EHU�VXX�]KDQQ�GHQJDQ�PHQJDWDNDQ�EDKZD�LWX�VDODK�VDWX�FDUD�DQGD�PHQJDFDXNDQ�NRQVHQWUDVL�RUDQJ�\J�LQJLQ�EHUSLNLU�OXUXV�OXUXV�VDMD�7DSL�WDN�DSDODK��PDUL�NLWD�NHPEDOL�PHQJXUDL�EHQDQJ�NXVXW�NHWLPEDQJ�EHUODUXW�ODUXW�GOP�HPRVL�GDQ�UDWDSDQ�WKG�XPPDW�,VODP�\J�PHPDQJ��VDDW�LQL��VHGDQJ�FHQWDQJ�SUHQDQJ��%HQDQJ�PHUDK�XUDLDQ�NLWD�PDVLK�VHSXWDU��NHEHEDVDQ�EHUSLNLU��GOP�NDLWDQQ\D�GJ�KDT��EDWKLO��EHQDU��VDODK��OXUXV��VHVDW��$GD�VHGLNLW�NHPDMXDQ��NDUHQD�VHSHUWLQ\D�DQGD�VXGDK�PHQJDNXL�DGDQ\D�MDODQ�EHUDJDPD�\J�VHVDW�GDQ�EDWKLO�GJ�SHUQ\DWDDQ�DQGD��������SUDNWHN�SUDNWHN�SHQ\HPEDKDQ�DJDPD�\DQJ�PHODQJJDU�SULQVLS�LWX��DNDQ�GHQJDQ�VHQGLULQ\D�GLWRODN�ROHK�DJDPD�DJDPD�EHVDU���0HVNLSXQ�DQGD�EHOXP�EHUDQL��DWDX�PDVLK�PDOX��PHQJJXQDNDQ�NDWD��VHVDW��GL�VLWX��WDSL�PDNVXGQ\D�NXUDQJ�OHELK�VDPD��NDUHQD�MLND�VHPXD�DJDPD�DJDPD�EHVDU�DGDODK��MDODQ�\J�EHQDU���PHQXUXW�DQGD��EHUDUWL�DSD�\J��GLWRODN��ROHK�PHUHND�DGDODK��MDODQ�\J�VDODK���6DODK�MDODQ� �VHVDW��$ODLVD�NDG]DOLN"1DK��VDWX�MDOLQDQ�EHQDQJ�NXVXW�WHODK�EHUKDVLO�NLWD�WDULN�VLPSXOQ\D�\DLWX�PHPDQJ�DGD�MDODQ�\J�EHQDU�GDQ�DGD�MDODQ�\DQJ�VHVDW�DWDX��VDODK�MDODQ���ELOD�DQGD�WLGDN�WHJD�PHQJJXQDNDQ�NDWD��VHVDW����6D\DQJQ\D��NULWHULD�EHQDU�GDQ�VHVDWQ\D�VXDWX�MDODQ�EHUDJDPD�DQGD�VHUDKNDQ�EHJLWX�VDMD��WDQSD�MHODV�GDOLO�GDQ�DUJXPHQQ\D��SDGD�GXD�KDO�\DLWX��DNDO�VHKDW��GDQ��QLODL�QLODL�XQLYHUVDO��\DLWX�QLODL�QLODL�\J�WHUGDSDW�GOP�VHPXD�DJDPD��'L�VLQL�SHPLNLUDQ�NLWD�VDOLQJ�NXVXW�ODJL��0DUL�NLWD�FRED�XUDLNDQ�MDOLQDQ�EHQDQJ�NXVXW�LQL�GHQJDQ�PHQDULN�VXDWX�WLWLN�WHPX�\J�NLWD�VHSDNDWL�EHUVDPD��'DODP�EHEHUDSD�EDJLDQ�WXOLVDQ�DQGD�GDODP�HPDLO�HPDLO�\J�WHUGDKXOX�DQGD�WHODK�PHPEHULNDQ�VXDWX�NHVLPSXODQ�\J�VDQJDW�EHUKDUJD�WWJ��DTLGDK��NDXP�OLEHUDO�\DLWX�EDKZD��SURGXN�DNDO�DGDODK�UHODWLI�VHGDQJ�NHEHQDUDQ�PXWODN�EHUVXPEHU�GDUL�7XKDQ���.DODX�PHPDQJ�GHPLNLDQ�SHQJDNXDQ�GDQ�NH\DNLQDQ�DQGD��EDJDLPDQD�NDODX�NLWD�NDWDNDQ�VDMD��NDUHQD�GL�WLWLN�LQL�SLNLUDQ�NLWD�VHSDNDW��EDKZD��

3UHYLRXV�_�1H[W _�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV

'DWH� :HG�����'HF����������������������367�)URP� �\XVXI�DQVKDU���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!�� $GG�WR�$GGUHVV�%RRN6XEMHFW� DNDO�VHKDW7R� �8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD���XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP!

0DLO $GGUHVVHV &DOHQGDU 1RWHSDG 0DLO�8SJUDGHV ��0DLO�2SWLRQV&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

)ROGHUV'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 0RYH���

Page 15: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B�����B����B���B����B�B��B�����B���������,G[ �< ���'HF���

�7LGDN�DGD�XNXUDQ�GDQ�NULWHULD�\J�WHUEDLN�GDQ�WHUVHKDW��EDJL�DNDO�VHKDW��XWN�PHQHQWXNDQ�EHQDU�WLGDNQ\D�VXDWX�MDODQ�EHUDJDPD�VHODLQ�XNXUDQ�GDQ�NULWHULD�\J�GLWHWDSNDQ�ROHK�7XKDQ��$QGD�VHWXMX�GHQJDQ�SHUQ\DWDDQ�GL�DWDV":DVVDODP�<XVXI8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD��XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP! ZURWH�6DODP�6HWDKX�VD\D��\DQJ�VXND�EHUPDLQ�VLODW�OLGDK��GDQEHUPDLQ�GHQJDQ�UHWRULND�EDKDVD�\DQJ�VHRODK�RODKPH\DNLQNDQ�DGDODK�NDXP�IXQGDPHQWDOLV��$\DW�GDQ�KDGLVNHUDS�GLKDPEXU�KDPEXUNDQ��6DWX�GXD�NDOLPDW�ODQJVXQJSHQXK�VHVDN�GHQJDQ�NXWLSDQ�NXWLSDQ�GDUL�.LWDE�6XFL�6HRODK�RODK�VXDWX�SHPELFDUDDQ�\DQJ�SHQXK�GHQJDQ�D\DWVXFL�DNDQ�EHQDU�GHQJDQ�VHQGLULQ\D��6D\D�EHODMDU�GL�SHVDQWUHQ��3HQJDODPDQ�\DQJ�VD\DSHURODK�GDUL�SHVDQWUHQ�DGDODK��NLDL�NLDL�VD\D�MDUDQJPHQJXWLS�D\DW�GDQ�KDGLV��NDUHQD�PHUHND�NKDZDWLU�NHOLUXPHQDIVLUNDQ��3DOLQJ�MDXK�PHUHND�PHQJXWLS�SHQGDSDWXODPD�DWDX�NLDL�\DQJ�ODLQ��.DODX�SXQ�NHOLUX��WDNDSD�DSD��WRK�PHUHND�PDQXVLD��,WXODK�SHQJDODPDQ�\DQJPHPEHNDV�SDGD�GLUL�VD\D�KLQJJD�VHNDUDQJ��'DQ�LWXODK\DQJ�PHPEXDW�VD\D�DJDN��PXDN��PHOLKDW�NDXPIXQGDPHQWDOLV�GL�NDPSXV�NDPSXV�\DQJ�VHWLDS�ELFDUDVHODOX�PHPHUFLNNDQ�D\DW�GDQ�KDGLV�GL�PDQD�PDQD��$\DW�GDQ�KDGLV�ELVD�PHQJDODPL�LQIODVL�MLND�GLREUDOGHQJDQ�FDUD�GHPLNLDQ��.HPEDOL�NH�SRNRN�VRDO�\DQJ�DQGD��VD\D�WDN�PDX�SDNDLNDWD��DQWXP��D�OD�NDXP�IXQGDPHQWDOLV�GL�-DNDUWD�SHUVRDONDQ��6RDO�NHEHEDVDQ�PHQDIVLU��.HEHEDVDQ�PHQDIVLU�VXGDK�PHQMDGL�NHQ\DWDDQ�GDQ�IDNWDGDODP�VHMDUDK�SHPLNLUDQ�,VODP��,WX�WHUMDGL�GDUL�VHMDN]DPDQ�VDKDEDW�GDQ�PDNLQ�EHUNHPEDQJ�SDGDJHQHUDVL�JHQHUDVL�XODPD�\DQJ�GDWDQJ�EHODNDQJDQ��5LEXDQWDIVLU�GDUL�SHOEDJDL�VXGXW�SHQGHNDWDQ�GLWXOLV�ROHKXODPD��$GD�WDIVLU�\DQJ�OLEHUDO�DWDX�\DQJ�OLWHUDO��$GDWDIVLU�GHQJDQ�SHQGHNDWDQ�VXIL�\DQJ�VDQJDW��EHEDV��GDQDGD�WDIVLU��ELO�PDWVXU��D�OD��DO�'XUU�DO�0DQWVXU�\DQJ�VDQJDW�WDDW�GHQJDQ�SHPDKDPDQ�KDUILDK��5LEXDQ�WDIVLU�LWX�WDN�PXQJNLQ�GLWXOLV�MLND�WDN�DGDNHEHEDVDQ�EHUSHQGDSDW�GDQ�EHUSLNLU�GDODP�,VODP�<DQJ�VD\D�NDJHW��XPDW�,VODP�VHNDUDQJ��\DQJ�XPXPQ\D�WDNEHODMDU�WUDGLVL�SHPLNLUDQ�,VODP�\DQJ�ND\D��WLED�WLEDPHPEHQFL�NHEHEDVDQ�EHUSLNLU��$GD�DGD�VDMD�DODVDQQ\D�6DODK�VDWX�DODVDQQ\D��NHEHEDVDQ�EHUSLNLU�LWXODK�\DQJPHQ\HEDENDQ�,EOLV�WHUMDWXK�GDQ�VHVDW��6HEDE�,EOLVPHPDNDL�SLNLUDQQ\D�VHQGLUL�GDQ�PHQRODN�SHULQWDK�7XKDQ�.HWDXKLODK�VDXGDUDNX��DUJXPHQ�LQL�VXGDK�SHUQDK�GLSDNDLROHK�SDUD�XODPD�GDKXOX�\DQJ�PHQHQWDQJ�SHQJJXQDDQ�TL\DVDWDX�VLORJLVPH��WHWDSL�WRK�XODPD�ODLQ�WDN�WHUSHQJDUXKGHQJDQ�SHQGDSDW�LQL��GDQ�WHWDS�PHQJDQJJDS�TL\DVVHEDJDL�VDODK�VDWX�DVDV�SHQWLQJ�GDODP�LVWLQEDWK�KXNXP�$ODVDQ�ODLQ�\DQJ�SDOLQJ�SRSXOHU��GDQ�WDPSDNQ\D�GLVLQLODK�DQGD��VHNDOL�ODJL�EXNDQ��DQWXP���WHUMDWXK�DGDODK�EDKZD�MLND�NHEHEDVDQ�EHUSLNLU�GLELDUNDQ��PDNDRUDQJ�DNDQ�FHQGHUXQJ�NHEDEODVDQ��$SDNDK�GHPL�NHEHEDVDQ

Page 16: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B�����B����B����B����B�B��B����B����������,G[ �<���'HF���

<DKRR� 0\�<DKRR� 0DLO 6HDUFK:HOFRPH��\XVXIDQVKDU>6LJQ�2XW��0\�$FFRXQW@ 0DLO�+RPH ��0DLO�7XWRULDOV ��+HOS

)UHH�&RORU)OLS�3KRQHV�>$GG ��(GLW@,QER['UDIW6HQW

>(PSW\@7UDVK:KDWV�\RXU�&UHGLW6FRUH��FKHFN�LW�)5(($SSO\�IRU�D3HUVRQDO�/RDQ*HW�<RXU�+RW/RZ�5DWHV�1RZ$�&UHGLW�&DUGIRU�<RX�

3ULQWDEOH�9LHZ ��)XOO�+HDGHUV

7KLV�PHVVDJH�LV�QRW�IODJJHG��>�)ODJ�0HVVDJH ��0DUN�DV�8QUHDG @

6DODP�'DUL�PDQD�DQGD�PHQ\LPSXONDQ�VHMDN�DZDO�EDKZD�GDODPSHUVSHNWLI�,VODP�OLEHUDO�WLGDN�DGD�\DQJ��VDODK��GDQ�EHQDU�"�7LGDN�DGD��KDT��GDQ��EDWLO�"�6XGDK�WHQWX�KDO�LWX�DGD��<DQJ�PHPEHGDNDQ�DQGD�GHQJDQNDXP�0XVOLP�OLEHUDO�VHSHUWL�VD\D�DGDODK�EDWDVDQPHQJHQDL�GXD�LVWLODK�LWX��$TLGDK�NDPL�DGDODK��,VODP�EXNDQ�VDWX�VDWXQ\D�DJDPD\DQJ�EHQDU��GDQ�EXNDQ�SXOD�SDOLQJ�EHQDU��0DNVXG�VD\D�,VODP��VHEDJDL�QDPD�DJDPD�\DQJ�GLEDZD�ROHK�1DEL0XKDPPDG��.DPL�PHPDQGDQJ�EDKZD�NHEHQDUDQ�WHUVHEDUGDODP�VHPXD�DJDPD��2OHK�NDUHQD�LWX��NDPL�WLGDN�DNDQPHPDQGDQJ�DJDPD�ODLQ�VHEDJDL�EDWKLO��$GD�VWDQGDU�XQLYHUVDO�WHQWDQJ�NHEDWKLODQ��+DO�LWXWDPSDN�GDODP�KDO�KDO�\DQJ�EDLN�VHFDUD�ZDK\X�DWDX�DNDOVHKDW�GLDQJJDS�EDWDO��VHSHUWL�WLQGDNDQ�NHMDKDWDQ�\DQJWHUNDQGXQJ�GDODP��6HSXOXK�3HUMDQMLDQ���7HQ&RPPDQGHPHQW���%HOXP�WHQWX�KDO�KDO�\DQJ�EHUODZDQDQ�GHQJDQ�NHWHQWXDQ\DQJ�VHFDUD�KDUDILDK�WHUWHUD�GDODP�4XUDQ�DGDODK�EDWLO�0LVDOQ\D��KXNXPDQ�SHQMDUD�EDJL�SHQFXULDQ�\DQJ�PHQXUXWILTK�VXGDK�PHPHQXKL�V\DUDW�XQWXN�GLNHQDL�KXNXP�SRWRQJWDQJDQ�.HQDSD�GHPLNLDQ"�6HEDE��GDODP�NHUDQJND�EHSLNLU�NDPL�WLGDN�VHPXD�KDO�\DQJ�VHFDUD�KDUDILDK�WHUFDQWXP�GDODP4XUDQ�PHVWL�NLWD�LNXWL�VHFDUD�KDUDILDK�SXOD��.HQDSDGHPLNLDQ��NLWD�GLVNXVL�GL�ODLQ�NHVHPSDWDQ��NDODX�VD\DDGD�ZDNWX��6HNDUDQJ�VD\D�DNDQ�PHQDQJJDSL�SHUQ\DWDDQ�DQGD�GL�EDZDKLQL���7LGDN�DGD�XNXUDQ�GDQ�NULWHULD�\J�WHUEDLN�GDQ!�WHUVHKDW��EDJL�DNDO�VHKDW��XWN�PHQHQWXNDQ!�EHQDU�WLGDNQ\D�VXDWX�MDODQ�EHUDJDPD�VHODLQ�XNXUDQ!�GDQ�NULWHULD�\J�GLWHWDSNDQ�ROHK�7XKDQ��$SD�\DQJ�DQGD�PDNVXGNDQ�GHQJDQ��MDODQ�DJDPD�"�$SDNDKMDODQ�LWX�PHQ\DQJNXW�LEDGDK��PXDPDODK��DNKODT��DGDE�DWDX�DSD"�6HEDE�DJDPD�PHPLOLNL�GLPHQVL�\DQJ�NRPSOHNV�

3UHYLRXV�_�1H[W _�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV

'DWH� 7KX�����'HF����������������������367�)URP� �8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD���XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP!�� 9LHZ�&RQWDFW�'HWDLOV�6XEMHFW� 5H��DNDO�VHKDW7R� �\XVXI�DQVKDU���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!

0DLO $GGUHVVHV &DOHQGDU 1RWHSDG 0DLO�8SJUDGHV ��0DLO�2SWLRQV&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

)ROGHUV'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 6SDP 0RYH���

Page 17: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B�����B����B����B����B�B��B����B����������,G[ � ���'HF���

'L�OHYHO�PDQD�DQGD�PDX�EHUELFDUD"$SD�\DQJ�DQGD�PDNVXGNDQ�GHQJDQ��NULWHULD�\DQJGLWHWDSNDQ�ROHK�7XKDQ�"�%LVDNDK�DQGD�PHQJJXQDNDQLVWLODK�\DQJ�MDXK�OHELK�VWDQGDU�GDODP�NHLOPXDQ�,VODP"6HEDE�LVWLODK��NULWHULD�7XKDQ��VDPD�VHNDOL�WLGDNMHODV��6D\D�WDN�DNDQ�PHQMDZDE�SHUWDQ\DDQ�DQGD�LQL�NDODX�DQGDWLGDN�PHQMHODVNDQ�PDVDODK�LWX�GXOX�8OLO

����\XVXI�DQVKDU��\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!�ZURWH�!�0HPEDFD�HPDLO�DQGD�\J�ODOX��NHVDQ�\J�VD\D�WDQJNDS!�DGDODK�XUDLDQ�DQGD�OHELK�EDQ\DN�PHUXSDNDQ�FXUDKDQ!�SHUDVDDQ�GDQ�HPRVL�\J�FDPSXU�DGXN!��NHVDO�PXDN�VLQLV�NDJHW�ELQJXQJ�MDGL�VDWX���6D\D!�PHQJHUWL�SHUDVDDQ�DQGD�GDQ�VD\D�WXUXW�SULKDWLQ�GJ!�NHNHVDODQ�GDQ�NHELQJXQJDQ�DQGD��1DPXQ�XSD\D�VD\D�XWN!�VHGLNLW�PHQMHUQLKNDQ�GDQ�PHQHQDQJNDQ�DUXV�SHPLNLUDQ!�NLWD�DJDN�WHUKDPEDW�GJ�FXUDKDQ�SHPLNLUDQ��GDQ�HPRVL�!�DQGD�\J�FXNXS�GHUDV��%DUDQJNDOL�PHPDQJ�EHJLWX�FDUD!�EHUSLNLU�GDQ�PRGHO�GLVNXVL�DQGD�GDQ�NRPXQLWDV�DQGD!�GL�XWDQ�ND\X��+DQ\D�VDMD�VD\D�WDN�LQJLQ�EHU�VXX!�]KDQQ�GHQJDQ�PHQJDWDNDQ�EDKZD�LWX�VDODK�VDWX�FDUD!�DQGD�PHQJDFDXNDQ�NRQVHQWUDVL�RUDQJ�\J�LQJLQ�EHUSLNLU!�OXUXV�OXUXV�VDMD�!��!�7DSL�WDN�DSDODK��PDUL�NLWD�NHPEDOL�PHQJXUDL�EHQDQJ!�NXVXW�NHWLPEDQJ�EHUODUXW�ODUXW�GOP�HPRVL�GDQ�UDWDSDQ!�WKG�XPPDW�,VODP�\J�PHPDQJ��VDDW�LQL��VHGDQJ!�FHQWDQJ�SUHQDQJ��%HQDQJ�PHUDK�XUDLDQ�NLWD�PDVLK!�VHSXWDU��NHEHEDVDQ�EHUSLNLU��GOP�NDLWDQQ\D�GJ�KDT�!�EDWKLO��EHQDU��VDODK��OXUXV��VHVDW��!��!�$GD�VHGLNLW�NHPDMXDQ��NDUHQD�VHSHUWLQ\D�DQGD�VXGDK!�PHQJDNXL�DGDQ\D�MDODQ�EHUDJDPD�\J�VHVDW�GDQ�EDWKLO!�GJ�SHUQ\DWDDQ�DQGD��������SUDNWHN�SUDNWHN!�SHQ\HPEDKDQ�DJDPD�\DQJ�PHODQJJDU�SULQVLS�LWX��DNDQ!�GHQJDQ�VHQGLULQ\D�GLWRODN�ROHK�DJDPD�DJDPD�EHVDU��!�0HVNLSXQ�DQGD�EHOXP�EHUDQL��DWDX�PDVLK�PDOX�!�PHQJJXQDNDQ�NDWD��VHVDW��GL�VLWX��WDSL�PDNVXGQ\D!�NXUDQJ�OHELK�VDPD��NDUHQD�MLND�VHPXD�DJDPD�DJDPD!�EHVDU�DGDODK��MDODQ�\J�EHQDU���PHQXUXW�DQGD��EHUDUWL!�DSD�\J��GLWRODN��ROHK�PHUHND�DGDODK��MDODQ�\J!�VDODK���6DODK�MDODQ� �VHVDW��$ODLVD�NDG]DOLN"!��!�1DK��VDWX�MDOLQDQ�EHQDQJ�NXVXW�WHODK�EHUKDVLO�NLWD!�WDULN�VLPSXOQ\D�\DLWX�PHPDQJ�DGD�MDODQ�\J�EHQDU�GDQ!�DGD�MDODQ�\DQJ�VHVDW�DWDX��VDODK�MDODQ���ELOD�DQGD!�WLGDN�WHJD�PHQJJXQDNDQ�NDWD��VHVDW����6D\DQJQ\D�!�NULWHULD�EHQDU�GDQ�VHVDWQ\D�VXDWX�MDODQ�EHUDJDPD!�DQGD�VHUDKNDQ�EHJLWX�VDMD��WDQSD�MHODV�GDOLO�GDQ!�DUJXPHQQ\D��SDGD�GXD�KDO�\DLWX��DNDO�VHKDW��GDQ!��QLODL�QLODL�XQLYHUVDO��\DLWX�QLODL�QLODL�\J!�WHUGDSDW�GOP�VHPXD�DJDPD��'L�VLQL�SHPLNLUDQ�NLWD!�VDOLQJ�NXVXW�ODJL��0DUL�NLWD�FRED�XUDLNDQ�MDOLQDQ!�EHQDQJ�NXVXW�LQL�GHQJDQ�PHQDULN�VXDWX�WLWLN�WHPX�\J!�NLWD�VHSDNDWL�EHUVDPD��!���!�'DODP�EHEHUDSD�EDJLDQ�WXOLVDQ�DQGD�GDODP�HPDLO�HPDLO!�\J�WHUGDKXOX�DQGD�WHODK�PHPEHULNDQ�VXDWX�NHVLPSXODQ!�\J�VDQJDW�EHUKDUJD�WWJ��DTLGDK��NDXP�OLEHUDO�\DLWX!�EDKZD��SURGXN�DNDO�DGDODK�UHODWLI�VHGDQJ�NHEHQDUDQ!�PXWODN�EHUVXPEHU�GDUL�7XKDQ���.DODX�PHPDQJ�GHPLNLDQ!�SHQJDNXDQ�GDQ�NH\DNLQDQ�DQGD��EDJDLPDQD�NDODX�NLWD!�NDWDNDQ�VDMD��NDUHQD�GL�WLWLN�LQL�SLNLUDQ�NLWD!�VHSDNDW��EDKZD��!��

Page 18: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B�����B����B���B����B�B��B����B����������,G[ �<<���'HF���

<DKRR� 0\�<DKRR� 0DLO 6HDUFK:HOFRPH��\XVXIDQVKDU>6LJQ�2XW��0\�$FFRXQW@ 0DLO�+RPH ��0DLO�7XWRULDOV ��+HOS

�����&HOO�3KRQH1R�&UHGLW�&KHFN�>$GG ��(GLW@,QER['UDIW6HQW

>(PSW\@7UDVK:KDWV�\RXU�&UHGLW6FRUH��FKHFN�LW�)5(($SSO\�IRU�D3HUVRQDO�/RDQ6HQG���IDVW�ZLWKZHVWHUQXQLRQ�FRP&UHGLW�&DUG�WR%XLOG�RU�UH�%XLOG

3ULQWDEOH�9LHZ ��)XOO�+HDGHUV

7KLV�PHVVDJH�LV�QRW�IODJJHG��>�)ODJ�0HVVDJH ��0DUN�DV�8QUHDG @

6D\D�FXNXS�VXUSULVH�PHQGHQJDU�SHUQ\DWDDQ�DQGD�EDKZD�DJDPD�PHPLOLNL�GLPHQVL�\DQJ�VDQJDW�NRPSOHNV��7DGLQ\D�VD\D�PHQJDQJJDS�NDXP�OLEHUDO�PHPSHUVHPSLW�PDNQD�DJDPD�SDGD�WDWDUDQ�PRUDO�VDMD��6\XNXUODK�NDODX�EHJLWX��%LOD�DQGD�PHPLQWD�VD\D�PHPSHUMHODV�GL�OHYHO�PDQD�NDWD��DJDPD��\DQJ�VD\D�PDNVXG�GDODP�NDOLPDW���7LGDN�DGD�XNXUDQ�GDQ�NULWHULD�\J�WHUEDLN�GDQ�WHUVHKDW��EDJL�DNDO�VHKDW��XWN�PHQHQWXNDQ�EHQDU�WLGDNQ\D�VXDWX�MDODQ�EHUDJDPD�VHODLQ�XNXUDQ�GDQ�NULWHULD�\J�GLWHWDSNDQ�ROHK�7XKDQ��0DND�VD\D�NDWDNDQ�EDKZD�VHEHQDUQ\D�\J�VD\D�PDNVXG�DGDODK��DJDPD��GOP�DUWL�\J�VHOXDV�OXDVQ\D��GL�VHPXD�OLQL�NHKLGXSDQ���7DSL�DJDU�GLVNXVL�NLWD�WLGDN�WHUODOX�PHOHEDU�VHKLQJJD�EHUWHOH�WHOH��DSDODJL�DQGD�VHGDQJ�VLEXN��PXQJNLQ�LNXW�VHPLQDU�QDWDO�GVE��PDND�GDODP�GLVNXVL�NDOL�LQL�VD\D�PHPEDWDVL�SDGD�OHYHO��DTLGDK��DWDX��NHSHUFD\DDQ��VDMD�GXOX��$GDSXQ�\J�VD\D�PDNVXG�GHQJDQ��NULWHULD�\DQJ�GLWHWDSNDQ�ROHK�7XKDQ��WLGDNODK�WHUODOX�PXOXN�PXOXN��DQGD�WLGDN�XVDK�ELQJXQJ��3HUVLV�VHSHUWL�SHQJHUWLDQ�NULWHULD�\J�WHUGDSDW�GDODP�NDPXV�NDPXV��NULWHULD� �VWDQGDU��XNXUDQ��SDWRNDQ��QRUPD���'DODP�NDLWDQQ\D�GHQJDQ�7XKDQ�GDQ�$JDPD�EHUDUWL�NHSHUFD\DDQ�GDQ�DPDODQ�DSD�VDMD�GDODP�EHUDJDPD�\J�KDUXV�GLPLOLNL�ROHK�VHVHRUDQJ�XQWXN�PHQGDSDWNDQ�ULGKD�7XKDQ��.DODX�DQGD�PHPLQWD�LVWLODK�\J�OHELK�LVODPL��HKP�����\D�5XNXQ�,PDQ�GDQ�5XNXQ�,VODP�LWX��7DSL�VD\D�NLUD�VHRUDQJ�OLEHUDOLV�VHMDWL�PDFDP�DQGD�OHELK�VHQDQJ�PHQJJXQDNDQ�LVWLODK�\J�XQLYHUVDO��1DK��NDODX�NHGXD�SHQJHUWLDQ�GL�DWDV�NLWD�JDEXQJ�PDND�SHUQ\DWDDQ�WDGL�ELVD�GLSHUMHODV�VHEDJDL�EHULNXW��7LGDN�DGD�VWDQGDU��XNXUDQ��SDWRNDQ�GDQ�QRUPD�\DQJ�WHUEDLN�GDQ�WHUVHKDW��EDJL�DNDO�VHKDW��XWN�PHQHQWXNDQ�EHQDU�WLGDNQ\D�VXDWX�NHSHUFD\DDQ��DTLGDK��GDODP�DJDPD�VHODLQ�VWDQGDU��XNXUDQ��SDWRNDQ�GDQ�QRUPD�\DQJ�GLWHWDSNDQ�ROHK�7XKDQ��6HNDOL�ODJL��DSDNDK�DQGD�VHWXMX�GHQJDQ�SHUQ\DWDDQ�GL�DWDV"�.DODX�DQGD�PHPDQJ�VHGDQJ�VXSHU�VLEXN��FXNXS�GLMDZDE�GHQJDQ�GXD�KXUXI��<$��DWDX��12��:DVVDODP�<XVXI

3UHYLRXV�_�1H[W _�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV

'DWH� 7KX�����'HF����������������������367�)URP� �\XVXI�DQVKDU���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!�� $GG�WR�$GGUHVV�%RRN6XEMHFW� NULWHULD�DJDPD7R� �8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD���XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP!

0DLO $GGUHVVHV &DOHQGDU 1RWHSDG 0DLO�8SJUDGHV ��0DLO�2SWLRQV&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

)ROGHUV'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 0RYH���

Page 19: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B�����B����B����B����B�B��B����B����������,G[ �<���'HF���

<DKRR� 0\�<DKRR� 0DLO 6HDUFK:HOFRPH��\XVXIDQVKDU>6LJQ�2XW��0\�$FFRXQW@ 0DLO�+RPH ��0DLO�7XWRULDOV ��+HOS

)UHH�3KRQHVDW�&LQJXODU��>$GG ��(GLW@,QER[����'UDIW6HQW

>(PSW\@7UDVK:KDWV�\RXU�&UHGLW6FRUH��FKHFN�LW�)5((*HW�XS�WR������%DQN�2QOLQH�1R�IHH�/RZ�5DWH/LQH�RI�&UHGLW$�&UHGLW�&DUGIRU�<RX�

3ULQWDEOH�9LHZ ��)XOO�+HDGHUV

7KLV�PHVVDJH�LV�QRW�IODJJHG��>�)ODJ�0HVVDJH ��0DUN�DV�8QUHDG @

6DODP�-HODVNDQ�GXOX��DSD�\DQJ�DQGD�PDNVXG�GHQJDQ�NULWHULD7XKDQ�GDODP�PDVDODK�DNLGDK�8UXVDQ�DNLGDK�GDODP�,VODP�WLGDN�VHVLPSHO�\DQJ�DQGDED\DQJNDQ��3HUWHQJNDUDQ�SHQGDSDW�OXDU�ELDVD�KHEDWQ\D�%DQ\DN�VHNWH�WLPEXO�GL�VDQD��0DVLQJ�PDVLQJ�PHQGDNXVHEDJDL�SDOLQJ�EHQDU��SDOLQJ�VHVXDL�GHQJDQ�NULWHULD7XKDQ�$SD�\DQJ�DQGD�PDNVXG�GHQJDQ�NULWHULD�7XKDQ�GDODPDNLGDK"�$SD�VDMD�LVLQ\D"8OLO����\XVXI�DQVKDU��\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!�ZURWH�!�6D\D�FXNXS�VXUSULVH�PHQGHQJDU�SHUQ\DWDDQ�DQGD�EDKZD!�DJDPD�PHPLOLNL�GLPHQVL�\DQJ�VDQJDW�NRPSOHNV��7DGLQ\D!�VD\D�PHQJDQJJDS�NDXP�OLEHUDO�PHPSHUVHPSLW�PDNQD!�DJDPD�SDGD�WDWDUDQ�PRUDO�VDMD��6\XNXUODK�NDODX!�EHJLWX��%LOD�DQGD�PHPLQWD�VD\D�PHPSHUMHODV�GL�OHYHO!�PDQD�NDWD��DJDPD��\DQJ�VD\D�PDNVXG�GDODP�NDOLPDW��!��!��7LGDN�DGD�XNXUDQ�GDQ�NULWHULD�\J�WHUEDLN�GDQ!�WHUVHKDW��EDJL�DNDO�VHKDW��XWN�PHQHQWXNDQ!�EHQDU�WLGDNQ\D�VXDWX�MDODQ�EHUDJDPD�VHODLQ�XNXUDQ!�GDQ�NULWHULD�\J�GLWHWDSNDQ�ROHK�7XKDQ��!��!�0DND�VD\D�NDWDNDQ�EDKZD�VHEHQDUQ\D�\J�VD\D�PDNVXG!�DGDODK��DJDPD��GOP�DUWL�\J�VHOXDV�OXDVQ\D��GL�VHPXD!�OLQL�NHKLGXSDQ���7DSL�DJDU�GLVNXVL�NLWD�WLGDN!�WHUODOX�PHOHEDU�VHKLQJJD�EHUWHOH�WHOH��DSDODJL�DQGD!�VHGDQJ�VLEXN��PXQJNLQ�LNXW�VHPLQDU�QDWDO�GVE��PDND!�GDODP�GLVNXVL�NDOL�LQL�VD\D�PHPEDWDVL�SDGD�OHYHO!��DTLGDK��DWDX��NHSHUFD\DDQ��VDMD�GXOX��!��!�$GDSXQ�\J�VD\D�PDNVXG�GHQJDQ��NULWHULD�\DQJ!�GLWHWDSNDQ�ROHK�7XKDQ��WLGDNODK�WHUODOX�PXOXN�PXOXN�!�DQGD�WLGDN�XVDK�ELQJXQJ��3HUVLV�VHSHUWL�SHQJHUWLDQ!�NULWHULD�\J�WHUGDSDW�GDODP�NDPXV�NDPXV��NULWHULD� !�VWDQGDU��XNXUDQ��SDWRNDQ��QRUPD���'DODP�NDLWDQQ\D!�GHQJDQ�7XKDQ�GDQ�$JDPD�EHUDUWL�NHSHUFD\DDQ�GDQ

3UHYLRXV�_�1H[W _�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV

'DWH� )UL�����'HF����������������������367�)URP� �8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD���XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP!�� 9LHZ�&RQWDFW�'HWDLOV�6XEMHFW� 5H��NULWHULD�DJDPD7R� �\XVXI�DQVKDU���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!

0DLO $GGUHVVHV &DOHQGDU 1RWHSDG 0DLO�8SJUDGHV ��0DLO�2SWLRQV&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

)ROGHUV'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 6SDP 0RYH���

Page 20: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B�����B����B���B����B�B��B�����B����������,G[ �<���'HV���

<DKRR� 0\�<DKRR� 0DLO 6HDUFK:HOFRPH��\XVXIDQVKDU>6LJQ�2XW��0\�$FFRXQW@ 0DLO�+RPH ��0DLO�7XWRULDOV ��+HOS

�����&HOO�3KRQH1R�&UHGLW�&KHFN�>$GG ��(GLW@,QER['UDIW6HQW

>(PSW\@7UDVK:KDWV�\RXU�&UHGLW6FRUH��FKHFN�LW�)5((����N�ORDQ�IRU�����PR��*R�1R�IHH�/RZ�5DWH/LQH�RI�&UHGLW$�*RRG�&DUG�IRU%DG�&UHGLW�

3ULQWDEOH�9LHZ ��)XOO�+HDGHUV

7KLV�PHVVDJH�LV�QRW�IODJJHG��>�)ODJ�0HVVDJH ��0DUN�DV�8QUHDG @

0HVNLSXQ�DQGD�WLGDN�PHQMDZDE�GHQJDQ��\D��DWDX��QR��WDSL�GDUL�WHPD�EDUX�\J�DQGD�DQJNDW�GDSDW�GLVLPSXONDQ�EDKZD�DQGD�VHWXMX�GDQ�PHPDQJ�WLGDN�ELVD�WLGDN��DQGD�PHVWL�VHWXMX�GJ�SHUQ\DWDDQ�WVE��.DUHQD�SHUQ\DWDDQ�WVE�DGDODK�NRQVHNXHQVL�ORJLV�GDUL�SULQVLS�NDXP�OLEHUDO�VHQGLUL�EDKZD���SURGXN�DNDO�DGDODK�UHODWLI�VHGDQJ�NHEHQDUDQ�PXWODN�EHUVXPEHU�GDUL�7XKDQ���6D\D�EHUWDQ\D��VHWXMX�DWDX�WLGDN��KDQ\DODK�XWN�PHQJLQJDWNDQ�GDQ�PHQHJDVNDQ�NHPEDOL�DTLGDK�GDQ�DNVLRPD�WVE��.DUHQD�VLDSDSXQ�\J�GLWDQ\D���DVDONDQ�GLD�WLGDN�DWKHLV���WHQWDQJ�VLDSD�\J�SDOLQJ�WDKX��VHJDOD�KDO��DSDODJL�WWJ�DJDPD��DSDNDK�7XKDQ�DWDX�PDQXVLD��SDVWL�DNDQ�PHQMDZDE��7XKDQ��WDQSD�SHUOX�EHUSLNLU�SDQMDQJ�ODJL��PHVNLSXQ�GLDQWDUD�PHUHND�VHQGLUL�PDVLK�VLEXN�EHUGHEDW�WWJ��7XKDQ���<DK��GL�VLWXODK�DQHKQ\D�PDQXVLD�GDQ�GL�VLWXODK�KHEDWQ\D�7XKDQ�\J�PHQFLSWDNDQ�PDQXVLD��'L�EDZDK�LQL�VD\D�XUXWNDQ�GXOX�NHPDMXDQ�GDQ�NHVLPSXODQ�\J�WHODK�NLWD�FDSDL�GDUL�GLVNXVL�LQL����$GDQ\D�MDODQ�\J�KDT��EHQDU��OXUXV�GDODP�EHUDJDPD�GDQ�DGDQ\D�MDODQ�\J�EDWKLO��VDODK��VHVDW�GDODP�EHUDJDPD�����7LGDN�DGD�\DQJ�SDOLQJ�WDKX�WWJ�MDODQ�\J�KDT��EHQDU��OXUXV�GDODP�EHUDJDPD�VHUWD�MDODQ�\J�EDWKLO��VDODK��VHVDW�GDODP�EHUDJDPD�VHODLQ�7XKDQ��%DJDLPDQD�FDUD�PDQXVLD�PHQGDSDW�LOPX�7XKDQ�LWX"�-DZDEDQQ\D�LDODK�OHZDW�:DK\X��2UDQJ�\DQJ�PHQGDSDW�ZDK\X�GDUL�$OODK�GLVHEXW�1DEL�DWDX�5DVXO��%HUKXEXQJ�NRPXQLWDV�DQGD�PDVLK�PHQJDNX�EHUDJDPD�,VODP��SDOLQJ�WLGDN�EHUODEHO�,VODP���PDND�:DK\X�\J�GLPDNVXG�GOP�SHPELFDUDDQ�NLWD�LQL�WLGDN�ODLQ�DGDODK�ZDK\X�WHUDNKLU��\DNQL�DO�4XUDQ��\J�GLWXUXQNDQ�NHSDGD�1DEL�GDQ�5DVXO�WHUDNKLU��\DNQL�0XKDPPDG�VDZ��.DODX�GHPLNLDQ��EHUDUWL�NHVLPSXODQ�GL�DWDV�NLWD�WDPEDK�GHQJDQ�NHVLPSXODQ�NHWLJD�VEE����8QWXN�PHQJHWDKXL�MDODQ�\J�KDT��EHQDU��OXUXV�GDODP�EHUDJDPD�VHUWD�MDODQ�\J�EDWKLO��VDODK��VHVDW�GDODP�EHUDJDPD�NLWD�KDUXV�PHUXMXN�SDGD�ILUPDQ�$OODK�GDODP�DO�4XUDQ�GDQ�VDEGD�5DVXO�GDODP�DO�+DGLWV��6HNDUDQJ�EDUXODK�NLWD�PHPDVXNL�PHGDQ�SHUWDUXQJDQ�VHVXQJJXKQ\D�DQWDUD�VHPXD�JRORQJDQ��VHNWH�GDQ�DOLUDQ�\J�PHQJDNX�GLUL�,VODP��WHUPDVXN�-,/���0HGDQ�SHUWDUXQJDQ�LWX�DGDODK���0DQD�MDODQ�EHUDJDPD�\J�KDT��EHQDU��OXUXV�GDQ�PDQD�MDODQ�EHUDJDPD�\J�EDWKLO��VDODK��VHVDW�PHQXUXW�$OODK�GDQ�5DVXO�1\D��PHQXUXW�DO�4XUDQ�GDQ�DV�6XQQDK�"�

3UHYLRXV�_�1H[W _�%DFN�WR�0HVVDJHV

'DWH� 6XQ�����'HF����������������������367�)URP� �\XVXI�DQVKDU���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP!�� $GG�WR�$GGUHVV�%RRN6XEMHFW� NHVLPSXODQ�GDQ�VDUDQ7R� �8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD���XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP!

0DLO $GGUHVVHV &DOHQGDU 1RWHSDG 0DLO�8SJUDGHV ��0DLO�2SWLRQV&KHFN�0DLO &RPSRVH 6HDUFK�0DLO 6HDUFK�WKH�:HE

)ROGHUV'HOHWH 5HSO\ )RUZDUG 0RYH���

Page 21: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B�����B����B���B����B�B��B�����B����������,G[ � ���'HV���

+DO�LQL�VHVXDL�GHQJDQ���GDQ�VXGDK�PHQFDNXS���SHUWDQ\DDQ�DQGD��EDJDLPDQD�NULWHULD�GDQ�PDWHUL�DTLGDK�GDODP�,VODP"�0HQXUXW�DQGD��DTLGDK�,VODP�WLGDN�VLPSHO��VHQJLW�GLSHUWHQJNDUNDQ�KLQJJD�PHQLPEXONDQ�EDQ\DN�VHNWH��%DJDLPDQD�LQL"�6HEHOXPQ\D��DGD�GXD�SULQVLS�GDQ�IDNWD�\J�KDUXV�NLWD�LQJDW����$TLGDK�,VODP��GHPLNLDQ�SXOD�DVSHN�DVSHN�ODLQ�GOP�,VODP��DGDODK�DSD�\J�GLNDWDNDQ�ROHK�DO�4XUDQ�GDQ�DV�6XQQDK��EXNDQ�DSD�\J�GLNDWDNDQ�ROHK�VHNWH�VHNWH�XPPDW�,VODP����6HNWH�VHNWH�WVE�EDUX�PXQFXO�MDXK�VHSHQLQJJDO�1DEL�VDZ�GDQ�WLGDN�NLWD�GDSDWL�GL�]DPDQ�5DVXOXOODK�VDZ�GDQ�SDUD�VDKDEDWQ\D�0HQJDSD�GL�]DPDQ�1DEL�EHOXP�PXQFXO�VHNWH�VHNWH"�3HQ\HEDEQ\D�DGD�GXD�����.HWLND�LWX�ZDK\X�PDVLK�WXUXQ�GDQ�SHQHULPD�ZDK\X��\J�SXQ\D�RWRULWDV�XWN�PHQMHODVNDQQ\D��\DLWX�1DEL�PDVLK�KLGXS��6HKLQJJD�VHPXD�SHUWDQ\DDQ�\J�WLPEXO�VHSXWDU�,VODP�DNDQ�GLMDZDE�ODQJVXQJ�ROHK��QDUD�VXPEHU�NHEHQDUDQ��\DNQL�$OODK�OHZDW�OLVDQ�1DEL�1\D�����6LNDS�SDUD�VDKDEDW�\J��VDPLQD�ZD�DWKDQD��GDQ�WLGDN�VXND�EHUWDQ\D�\J�WLGDN�SHUOX��+DO�KDO�\J�EHUNDLWDQ�GHQJDQ�DTLGDK�\J�GLVDPSDLNDQ�ROHK�DO�4XUDQ�GDQ�DO�+DGLWV�ODQJVXQJ�PHUHND�LPDQL�GDQ�\J�EHUNDLWDQ�GHQJDQ�DPDOL\DK�ODQJVXQJ�PHUHND�DPDONDQ��3HUVHOLVLKDQ�SHQGDSDW�\J�PHQMXUXV�NH�SHUSHFDKDQ�PXODL�WHUMDGL�VHWHODK�OHQ\DSQ\D�IDNWRU�SHUWDPD�GL�DWDV��1DEL�ZDIDW���.HPXGLDQ�GDUL�]DPDQ�NH�]DPDQ��SHUSHFDKDQ�VHPDNLQ�PHQMDGL�MDGL�KLQJJD�PHQLPEXONDQ�VHNWH�VHNWH��VHLULQJ�GHQJDQ�PDNLQ�OXQWXUQ\D��ZDWDN�VDKDEDW���IDNWRU�NHGXD��GL�NDODQJDQ�XPPDW�,VODP��/HPDKQ\D�LPDQ��UHQGDKQ\D�NHWDDWDQ�VHUWD�EDQ\DN�EHUWDQ\D�GDQ�EHUGHEDW�PHUXSDNDQ�SLQWX�JHUEDQJ�WHUEHVDU��GDUL�VLVL�LQWHUQDO��EDJL�WLPEXOQ\D�VHNWH�VHNWH�GOP�,VODP�$GDSXQ�GDUL�VLVL�HNVWHUQDO��PDVXNQ\D�ILOVDIDW�GOP�WXEXK�XPPDW�,VODP��GLVDPSLQJ�IDNWRU�SROLWLN��PHUXSDNDQ�VDODK�VDWX�SHQ\XPEDQJ�WHUEHVDU�EDJL�PDUDNQ\D�VHNWH�VHNWH�LWX��0HQJDSD�GHPLNLDQ"�3HNHUMDDQ�ILOVDIDW�KDQ\D�GXD��EHUWDQ\D�GDQ�EHUGHEDW��EHUGHEDW�GDQ�EHUWDQ\D��WDN�SXWXV�SXWXVQ\D�EDJDLNDQ��OLQJNDUDQ�VHWDQ���NDUHQD�ELOD�EHUKHQWL�EHUDUWL�WDPDWODK�ULZD\DW�ILOVDIDW���6HDQGDLQ\D�VHOXUXK�ILOVXI�\J�DGD�GL�GXQLD�GLEHEDQNDQ�XWN�PHQXQWDVNDQ�VDWX�SHUPDVDODKDQ�VDMD�VHEHOXP�EHUSLQGDK�NH�SHUPDVDODKDQ�VHODQMXWQ\D��QLVFD\D�KDELV�XPXU�PHUHND�GDQ�KDELV�XPXU�GXQLD��VHGDQJ�PHUHND�PDVLK�VLEXN�EHUSLNLU�WWJ��DSD�LWX�EHUSLNLU"����5HQH�'HVFDUWHV�\J�VHPSDW�GLGXJD�PDWL�EXQXK�GLUL��WHUNHQDO�GJ�XFDSDQ�KDPSDQ\D�FRJQLWR�HUJR�VXP� �DNX�EHUSLNLU�PDND�DNX�DGD��.DODX�EHQDU�LD�EXQXK�GLUL��PXQJNLQ�VDMD�LD�LQJLQ�PHPEXNWLNDQ�NHVLPSXODQQ\D�GDQ�WLGDN�LQJLQ�NHVLPSXODQQ\D�LWX�GLSHUWDQ\DNDQ�ODJL���$SDODJL�XWN�PHPLNLUNDQ�WWJ��DNDO���DOLK�DOLK�XWN�PHPLNLUNDQ�WWJ�6DQJ�3HQFLSWD�DNDO�GDQ�DSD�\J�GLPDXL�7XKDQ��0DQDNDOD�FDUD�ILOVDIDW�GLSDNDL�GOP�EHUDJDPD�QLVFD\D�NLWD�WLGDN�DNDQ�PHQGDSDWNDQ�KDVLO�DSD�DSD�VHODLQ�NHNXIXUDQ��.HQDSD"�.DUHQD�DJDPD�GLWXUXQNDQ�EXNDQ�XWN�LWX��GLSHUWDQ\DNDQ�GDQ�GLSHUGHEDWNDQ���$JDPD�GLWXUXQNDQ�XWN�GLLPDQL�GDQ�GLDPDONDQ���1%��ILOVDIDW�GDQ�WXUXQDQQ\D�VHEHWXOQ\D�EHUJXQD�XQWXN�PHPEDKDV�VDLQV��EXNDQ�DJDPD��%HUFHUPLQ�GDUL�NHGXD�IDNWD�GDQ�IDNWRU�SHQ\HEDEQ\D�GL�DWDV��PDND�GDSDW�NLWD�VLPSXONDQ�EDKZD�XWN�PHQJHWDKXL�DMDUDQ�$OODK�GDQ�5DVXO�1\D�\J�EHQDU��NLWD�KDUXV�NHPEDOL�NH�PDVD�DZDO�,VODP��PHOLKDW�EDJDLPDQD�SDUD�VDKDEDW�SDGD�XPXPQ\D��XWDPDQ\D�DV�VDELTXQ�DO�DZZDOXQ��NKXVXVQ\D�DO�NKXODID�DU�UDV\LGXQ��PHQJLPDQL�GDQ�PHQJDPDONDQ�DO�4XUDQ�GDQ�DV�6XQQDK��,WXODK�,VODP�\J�PDVLK�EHUVLK�GDUL�GLVWRUVL�GDQ�NRQWDPLQDVL�VHNWH�VHNWH�GDQ�SHQDIVLUDQ�SHQDIVLUDQ�\J�PHQ\LPSDQJ��%XNDQNDK�DQGD�VHQGLUL�SHUQDK�EHUNDWD��$NLGDK�NDXP�0XVOLP�OLEHUDO�DGDODK�EDKZD�VHWLDS�SHPDKDPDQ�NLWD�DWDV�,VODP�DGDODK�UHODWLI��NDUHQD�WLGDN�DGD�\DQJ�WDKX�NHEHQDUDQ�PXWODN�VHODLQ�$OODK�GDQ�UDVXO�1\D��.LWD�DGDODK�PDQXVLD�UHODWLI�\DQJ�PHQFRED�XQWXN�PHPDKDPL�NHEHQDUDQ��:DK\X�WHODK�EHUKHQWL��6HWLDS�RUDQJ�ELVD�PHQJXWLS�D\DW�DWDX�KDGLV��WHWDSL�SDGD�DNKLUQ\D�DSD�\DQJ�LD�NDWDNDQ�DGDODK�SHQGDSDWQ\D�VHQGLUL��EHOXP�WHQWX�VHVXDL�GHQJDQ�DSD�\DQJ�GLNHKHQGDNL�7XKDQ����6D\D�NXWLS�WDQSD�SHUXEDKDQ��GDUL�HPDLO�DQGD�WDQJJDO����'HVHPEHU�������0HPDQJ�SDUD�VDKDEDW�WHUPDVXN�GOP�SHUNDWDDQ�DQGD��NLWD�DGDODK�PDQXVLD�UHODWLI���7DSL�VHSHUWL�\J�VD\D�NHPXNDNDQ�GL�DWDV��VLNDS�SDUD�VDKDEDW�WHUKDGDS�DO�4XUDQ�GDQ�DO�+DGLWV�WLGDN�VHSHUWL�NLWD��3DUD�VDKDEDW�WLGDN�VXND�EHUWDQ\D�GDQ�

Page 22: Diskusi Islam Liberal

<DKRR��0DLO���\XVXIDQVKDU#\DKRR�FRP 3DJH�� RI��

����6KRZ/HWWHU"0VJ,G ����B�����B����B���B����B�B��B�����B����������,G[ � ���'HV���

EHUGHEDW��GHPLNLDQ�SXOD�WLGDN�VXND�PHQDNZLO�GDQ�PHQDIVLUNDQ��$SD�\J�PHUHND�WHULPD�GDUL�$OODK�GDQ�5DVXO�1\D��DO�4XUDQ�GDQ�DV�6XQQDK��PHUHND�VLNDSL�GHQJDQ�LPDQ�GDQ�DPDO��6HKLQJJD�DSD�DSD�\J�PHUHND�VHSDNDWL��LMPD�SDUD�VDKDEDW��EXNDQODK�KDVLO�SHQDIVLUDQ�GDQ�SHPDKDPDQ�SULEDGL�PHUHND�PHODLQNDQ�KDVLO�GDUL�VLNDS�PHQJLPDQL�GDQ�PHQJDPDONDQ�DSD�DSD�\J�GLVDPSDLNDQ�ROHK�$OODK�GDQ�5DVXO�1\D��,MWLKDG�EDUX�PHUHND�ODNXNDQ�PDQDNDOD�PHQHPXNDQ�KDO�KDO�EDUX�\J�WLGDN�PHUHND�GDSDWL��VHFDUD�HNVSOLVLW��GDODP�DO�4XUDQ�GDQ�DV�6XQQDK��LWXSXQ�GHQJDQ�FDUD�\J�VDQJDW�KDWL�KDWL�GDQ�WHWDS�EHUODQGDVNDQ�DTLGDK�GDQ�NDLGDK�\J�PHUHND�GDSDWL�GOP�DO�4XUDQ�GDQ�DV�6XQQDK��'DUL�XUDLDQ�GL�DWDV��GDSDW�NLWD�WDULN�NHVLPSXODQ�NHHPSDW�\J�PHUXSDNDQ�KDVLO�DNKLU�GDUL�GLVNXVL�NLWD�\DLWX�����-DODQ�EHUDJDPD�\J�KDT��EHQDU��OXUXV�PHQXUXW�$OODK�GDQ�5DVXO�1\D�DGDODK�MDODQ�EHUDJDPD�VHEDJDLPDQD�\J�WHODK�GLVHSDNDWL��LMPD��ROHK�SDUD�VDKDEDW�5DVXOXOODK�VDZ�VHGDQJ�MDODQ�EHUDJDPD�\J�EDWKLO��VDODK��VHVDW�DGDODK�MDODQ�EHUDJDPD�\J�EHUWHQWDQJDQ�GHQJDQ�NHVHSDNDWDQ��LMPD��SDUD�VDKDEDW�5DVXOXOODK�VDZ��.HHPSDW�NHVLPSXODQ�GL�DWDV���NDODX�DQGD�PHQHODDK�EDLN��GLVNXVL�NLWD�GDUL�DZDO�KLQJJD�NLQL���SDGD�GDVDUQ\D�GLVDULNDQ�GDUL�SULQVLS��DWDX�SHUQ\DWDDQ��DQGD�VHQGLUL��-DGL�VD\D�KDQ\D�PHQFRED�PHPHWDNDQ�NHPEDOL�SULQVLS��DQGD�GDODP�ELQJNDL�,VODP�\J�WHUOHSDV��VHPHQWDUD�DQGD�VHQGLUL�WLGDN�PDX�PHOHSDVNDQ�ODEHO��LVODP��GDUL�QDPD�MDULQJDQ�DQGD��HQWDK�NDUHQD�SHUWLPEDQJDQ�VWUDWHJLV�GXQLDZL�DWDXNDK�XNKUDZL��$OODKX�$ODPX���6HNDUDQJ�PDUL�NLWD�LQWURVSHNVL��$GDNDK�GLDQWDUD�SDUD�VDKDEDW�\J�WLGDN�PHQJDQJJDS�NDILU�RUDQJ�\J�PHPSHUWXKDQNDQ�<HVXV�.ULVWXV"�$GDNDK�GLDQWDUD�DO�NKXODID�DU�UDV\LGXQ�\J�PHQJNDILUNDQ�VHVDPD�PHUHND�VHEDJDLPDQD�6\LDK�\J�PHQJNDILUNDQ�$EXEDNDU�GDQ�8PDU"�$GDNDK�GLDQWDUD�SDUD�VDKDEDW�\J�PHQJKDODONDQ�ZDQLWD�PXVOLPDK�PHQLNDK�GHQJDQ�SULD�QRQ�PXVOLP"�%DJDLPDQD�GHQJDQ�NRPXQLWDV�DQGD"%HQDQJ�GDQ�MDULQJ�NXVXW�-,/�WHODK�VD\D�XUDLNDQ�VHKLQJJD�WHUSLVDKODK�WDOL�,VODP�GDUL�WDOL�OLEHUDO�GHQJDQ�HPSDW�VLPSXO�GL�DWDV��.LQL�WHUSXODQJ�NHSDGD�DQGD��PDX�PHPHJDQJ�WDOL�\DQJ�PDQD���$O�KDTTX�PLQ�UDEELND�IDPDQ�V\D�D�IDO\XPLQ�ZD�PDQ�V\D�D�IDO\DNIXU���6D\D�WLGDN�ELVD�EHUEXDW�DSD�DSD�ODJL�VHODLQ�PHPEHULNDQ�VDUDQ�GDQ�LPEDXDQ�EHULNXW�����%LOD�DQGD�PDX�EHUSHJDQJ�GHQJDQ�NHHPSDW�DVDV�GL�DWDV��EHUDUWL�DQGD�KDUXV�PHQDQJJDONDQ�SHPLNLUDQ�OLEHUDO�DQGD�\J�EHUWHQWDQJDQ�GHQJDQ�LMPD�DWDX�NHVHSDNDWDQ�NDXP�PXVOLPLQ��$QGDLNDWD�LWX�WHUMDGL��VD\D�PHQ\DUDQNDQ�DJDU�DQGD�PHQJJDQWL�QDPD�-,/�PHQMDGL�-03��-DULQJDQ�0XVOLP�3URJUHVLI��PLVDOQ\D��6HRUDQJ�PXVOLP�\J�SURJUHVLI��EHUSLNLUDQ�PDMX��WLGDN�PHVWL�PHQDQJJDONDQ�DTLGDK�GDQ�TDLGDK�NHLVODPDQ�PHUHND��$QGD�ELVD�PHPEDKDV�EHUEDJDL�LVX�LVX�DNWXDO�VHSXWDU�XPPDW�,VODP�GHQJDQ�MXMXU��WHUEXND�GDQ�NULWLV�WDQSD�SHUOX�PHODQJJDU�DMDUDQ�,VODP�����%LOD�DQGD�WLGDN�PDX�PHOHSDVNDQ�SHPLNLUDQ�OLEHUDO�DQGD��PDND�DQGD�KDUXV�PHOHSDVNDQ�ODEHO��,VODP��GDUL�QDPD�NRPXQLWDV�DQGD��PLVDOQ\D�PHQMDGL�-8/��-DULQJDQ�8PPDW�/LEHUDO�����%LOD�DQGD�WLGDN�PHQJLQGDKNDQ�VDODK�VDWX�GDUL�NHGXD�VDUDQ�GL�DWDV��EHUDUWL�DQGD�WHWDS�EHUSHJDQJ�GHQJDQ�WDOL�OLEHUDO�\J�NXIXU�GDQ�PHOLOLWNDQQ\D�GHQJDQ�WDOL�,VODP�VHKLQJJD�PHQJKDVLONDQ�SHPLNLUDQ�\J�NXVXW�GDQ�VHVDW�ODJL�PHQ\HVDWNDQ�EDQ\DN�NDXP�PXVOLPLQ��,QQD�OLOODKL�ZD�LQQD�LODLKL�UDMLXQ�:DVVDODP��<XVXI8OLO�$EVKDU�$EGDOOD��XOLO��#\DKRR�FRP! ZURWH�