analisis kebijakan publik_lay out
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
1/209
!
Ana l i s i s
KebijakanPublik
Modul Pembelajaran
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
2/209
!!
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
3/209
!!!
Ana l i s i s
KebijakanPublik
Modul Pembelajaran
Purwo Santosodibantu Joash Tapiheru
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
4/209
!"
!"#$% '()*(%+,+-+.
!"!#$%$% '()$*!'!" +,)#$'
/ '$-0" 1+.2"3"
4+5 6782+ #7%7.#$.97 :.#+.9;:.#+.9
!"" $%&'( $)*)+,)-
'(.$%73 < '$-0" 1+.2"3" =#7*+.2$ >"+3? @+87?(-$A
'(.B$.27.9 < :2+. '+-%7.#$.9+.
'(-+.C+.9 1+)8$% < D+-2" E.,+%+
'(.+2+ F(2+5 < E9$.9 !+8+
$)*).+/' 0)1()+ 23+ 43"%(%/* .1- 53,)+16)1(
>$-$3+. '"%7275 #+. '()(-7.2+?+.
:.7G(-372+3 H+#,+? !+#+
>%I 1"C7" >$327C7+ J K$%+53$)$-L M"9B+5+-2+ NNJOP
000I,88IQ7378"%I$9)I+CI7#
@(%8I =RJSTA NUVVUN (W2I JPJ
X1KD< YSO;YSY;YUSUJ;P;T
W7GZPYT ?+%L PN C) W JJ C)
6(2+5+. '(-2+)+< >$.7 JRPR
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
5/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' "
!"#$%#&%' !"#)*+,
!"#" %&% '(')'* +,(") "&-"# +'-'#")%'* .&')%/' 012%3'#'&
4"2)%# 5.046 (% 7"8"/'& 4,)%-%# ('& 41+18%&-'*'& 57446 9:;:4?@A ;12'B'%'+'&' #"8%#")"+ )'%&&C'D +,(") %&% 218B"&'
"&-"# +1&C'+E'%#'& +'-'#")%'* .04 (1&B'& 218,8%1&-'/% E'('
E1&F%E-''& !"#$%&$#' )*&'' /1#')%B"/ +1&B*'/%)#'& '&')%/ (1&B'& !+'&%&$#')%#,-&,. C'&B #,&/%/-1&A
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
6/209
"! .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
E1&B'+E" "&-"# /1F1E'- +"&B#%& +1+218%#'& 411-56#$* ('8% /1-%'E
-"B'/ C'&B (%#183'#'& ,)1* +'*'/%/G'D C'&B +'&' '#'& 218B"&'M 2'%#
"&-"# +1)'#"#'& E182'%#'& +'"E"& "&-"# +1&F1B'* +'*'/%/G'
+1)'#"#'& #1/')'*'& (')'+ +1&B183'#'& E1&"B'/'& (% /1/% 218%#"-&C'AL') C'&B -%('# #')'* E1&-%&BD E1&B'+E" (%-"&-"- "&-"# +'+E"
+18'&B/'&B #1'#-%H'& ('8% +'*'/%/G'D 2'%# (')'+ +1&B%#"-% /1/%
E18#")%'*'& +'"E"& (')'+ +1&B183'#'& E1&"B'/'& C'&B (%218%#'&A
:&% #'81&' C'&B &'+'&C' !"#$%&$#' )*&'' "&-"# +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/
*'&C' '#'& 2%/' (%('E'-#'& +1)')"% )'-%*'& ('& E8'#-1# +1)'#"#'&
'&')%/%/ /1F'8' %&-1&/%HA N'+"&D +%/% #")%'* %&% 3"B' %&B%& +1&3'(%#'&
+'*'/%/G' )12%* ('8% /1#1('8 +1&3'(% O-"#'&B '&')%/%/PD /1*%&BB' (')'++1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ +'*'/%/G' (%-"&-"- "&-"# +1&1&-"#'& (')'+
E,/%/% 'E' +181#' +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/A :&% +1&/C'8'-#'& +'*'/%/G'
+1+%)%#% E1&B*'C'-'& #1%)+"'& ('& -18F18+%& (')'+ '&')%/%/ C'&B
+181#' )'#"#'&A 0'81&' %-"D /1/%I/1/% 71%#5#,#'&)&) *'8"/ (%#'G')
(1&B'& 2'%#D #'81&' /1/% (')'+ #")%'* %&%D +'*'/%/G' '#'& (%'3'#
"&-"# 21)'3'8 +1&B*'C'-% E18/E1#-%HD +1-,(,),B% #1%)+"'&D 8#'01D ('&
1-%#' #1%)+"'& C'&B +1)'&('/% '&')%/' #12%3'#'&A 41&B"'/''& +1-'I
'&')%/%/ +18"E'#'& E8'/C'8'- ('/'8 "&-"# +1&B*'/%)#'& '&')%/%/ C'&B
218#"')%-'/D /12'2 /%H'-&C' C'&B +1&('/'8 %-")'* C'&B +1+2"'-&C'
/18%&B (%'2'%#'& (')'+ +'-'#")%'* .04A 0"8'&B&C' E1&B"'/''&
+1-'I'&')%/%/ 3"/-8" +1+2"'- /12'B%'& 21/'8 '&')%/%/ #12%3'#'& C'&B
(%*'/%)#'& /1)'+' %&% -%('# E"&C' #'8'#-18D #1#*'/'&D ('& #131)'/'&
E,/%/% C'&B (%'+2%)&C'A
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
7/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' "!!
.-'/ -182%-&C' +,(") %&%D E1&")%/ %&B%& +1&B"F'E#'& -18%+' #'/%*
#1E'(' 7,'/*Q'E%*18" C'&B /1)'+' %&% -1)'* +1+2'&-" E1&")%/'&
+,(") C'&B /1#'8'&B '(' (% *'('E'& E1+2'F'A >F'E'& -18%+'
#'/%* 3"B' E1&")%/ /'+E'%#'& #1E'(' R'*+'( ?"/-,+C C'&B -1)'*+1+2'&-" E1&")%/ +1&C"/"& (8'H- 'G') &'/#'* +,(") C'&B /1#'8'&B
'(' (% -'&B'& E1+2'F'A Q%('# )"E'D ;'C' 3"B' %&B%& +1&B"F'E#'&
-18%+' #'/%* #1E'(' #,)1B'I#,)1B' (% 7"8"/'& C'&B /1)'+' %&% +1&3'(%
!#"%,1" ;'C' (')'+ +1&B'+E" +'-'#")%'* .&')%/' 012%3'#'& 4"2)%#D
(%'&-'8'&C'M N"8 .S%S'*D L'/8") L'&%H ('& !'C" J'8(%'/ 0"8&%'(%A
0,)1B'I#,)1B' %&% -1)'* +1+218%#'& /'8'&D +'/"#'&D ('& #8%-%# C'&B
/'&B'- 218B"&' 2'B% E1&")%/'& +,(") %&%A
41&")%/ 3"B' %&B%& +1&B"F'E#'& -18%+' #'/%* #1E'(' /1+"'
E%*'# C'&B -18)%2'- (')'+ 1!&)%17&$ $+770,&%9 (% 744 9:;:4?@A
:(1 C'&B +1&('/'8% ('& (%-"'&B#'& (')'+ +,(") %&% +"&F") /12'B'%
*'/%) E18B")'-'& #1%)+"'& ('& (%/#"/% -%('# #1&') )1)'* ('8% /1+"'
E%*'# (')'+ #,+"&%-'/ %&%A Q%('# )"E' 3"B' E1&")%/ "F'E#'& -18%+'
#'/%* #1E'(' .2(") ?'HH'8 0'8%+D J%81#-"8 :1)1#"$; 21,%1" 4+" -'& 4'8)%&("&B'& ;%-"+1'&B ('8%
!%8, 4"2)%#'/% 4
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
8/209
"!!!
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
9/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' !5
-%.&%' +,+
!,)-()*(# !,)"./+AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA K
0(1*(# 2+/ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA%Y
!,#*,3"() 2
!45675879 :787 ;?
@,#A/B/# ;#/*/+ *,)*()- ;,C/D(B() !"C./B
E() !,)"()-())F( E(.(3 7)(./+/+AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAX
.A >"#&,)%+"7&,.AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAX
!A ?16"&14&,. AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAV
ZA ;1B+1&-'/% 418#")%'*'& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA [
JA !18/%#'E 08%-%/\ @1&/%#'E%@#&,)%"1#7.&')%/%/ 012%3'#'& AAAAAAAAAAAA ]
^A 41&"-"E 418#")%'*'& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA XW
!,#*,3"() 22
;G:!94>45'2H287' 075 ;4I75662>75
757=2'2' AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAXV
.A .&')%/%/ 012%3'#'& ('& 0,+E)1#/%-'/ 91&,+1&' 012%3'#'& AAAAAAXV
!A 4%)%*'& ;1,8'&B .&')%/ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA VX
ZA @1&B#8%-%/% =,B%#' :#%&+,#'I2+7!"1;1,)&81AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA VV
JA Q"B'/ .#*%8 ;1/% AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA V_
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
10/209
5 .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
!,#*,3"() 222
G@J4;82H287' 757=2'2'?
;%)*#%K,#+/ 7)(./+/+ ")*"B ;,C/D(B() E() 7)(./+/+
*,#L(E(A ;,C/D(B()AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAV`
.A 4%)%*'& J%)1+'-%/ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAV`
!A 0,&-8,K18/% .&')%/' "&-"# 012%3'#'& ('& .&')%/' -18*'('E
012%3'#'&\ 418(12'-'& ;1E"-'8
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
11/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 5!
!,#*,3"() H2
757=2'2' NG9:1,14&% A,#'9)&)AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA]c
JA ='-%*'& .&')%/' "&-"# 9,8+")'/% ('& 41&B'+2%)'&
01E"-"/'& 012%3'#'&\ /GHD A,#'9)&)AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAc`
^A ='-%*'& .&')%/%/ -18*'('E 41&B'+2%)'& 01E"-"/'&012%3'#'& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAXWX
9A 418/%'E'& "&-"# ;1/% !18%#"-&C' AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAXW[
!,#*,3"() H22
757=2'2' NG9:
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
12/209
5!! .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
!A @1+'*'+% @,(1)@&I1- /$#,,&,.AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAXX]
ZA !18)'-%* @1)'#"#'& .&')%/%/ "&-"# 41&B'+2%)'& 01E"-"/'&
012%3'#'& (')'+ =,B%#'@&I1- /$#,,&,. AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAXVW
JA ='-%*'& .&')%/%/ -18*'('E 41&B'+2%)'& 01E"-"/'& 012%3'#'&\
@,(1)@&I1- /$#,,&,. AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAXVV
^A 418/%'E'& "&-"# ;1/% !18%#"-&C' AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAXV[
!,#*,3"() 2T
757=2'7 2:!=4:4587'2 ;4@2M7;75 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAXVa
.A 418'& .&')%/' (')'+ :+E)1+1&-'/% 012%3'#'& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA XVa
!A @1+'*'+% 48,/1/ :+E)1+1&-'/% ('& 9"&B/% .&')%/%/
(')'+ 48,/1/ -18/12"- AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA XV_
ZA 41&(1#'-'& (')'+ :+E)1+1&-'/% AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAXV]
JA !18)'-%* @1)'#"#'& .&')%/%/ "&-"# :+E)1+1&-'/% 012%3'#'& AAA X[a
^A .&')%/' -18*'('E :+E)1+1&-'/% 012%3'#'& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA X[]
!,#*,3"() T757=2'2'@HCEDH:EC=;4@2M7;75AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAXaW
.A @1+'*'+%@+,&%+"&,.012%3'#'& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAXaW
!A !18)'-%* @1)'#"#'& .&')%/%/ "&-"#@+,&%+"&,. 012%3'#'& AAAAAXa`
ZA ='-%*'& .&')%/%/ Q18*'('E@+,&%+"&,.012%3'#'& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAX_W
JA 418/%'E'& "&-"# ;1/% !18%#"-&C' AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAX_X
!,#*,3"() T24H7=
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
13/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 5!!!
-%.&%' &%/"*
Q'21) ::AXA 41821(''& @,(1)I@,(1) 41&B'+2%)'& 01E"-"/'& AAAAAAXb
Q'21) ::AVA @'-8%#/ :/%'& ;%+")'/%AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA V[
Q'21) :::AXA @'-8%#/ 41821(''& .&')%/%/ ;12'B'% 01B%'-'& C'&B
+%%+7 F K! LLLLLLL X[W
Q'21) gAXA Z,&-,* 4,%& T18%H%#'/% "&-"# .&')%/%/ :+E)1+1&-'/%
012%3'#'&\ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAXab
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
14/209
5!" .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
-%.&%' /%$%#
!,Y ::A XA Z,&-,* 0'/"/\ 012%3'#'& 41&B"8"/'& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA Xa
!'B'& ::AXA 41-' 41+%#%8'& .&')%/%/ 012%3'#'& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA X_
!'B'& ::AVA J18'3'- 0,+E81*1&/%K%-'/ .&')%/%/ 012%3'#'& AAAAAAAAAAAAAVW
!'B'& :::AXA L"2"&B'& .&-'8' .&')%/%/ >&-"# 012%3'#'&
('& .&')%/%/ -18*'('E 012%3'#'& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA[W
!'B'& :::AVA :)"/-8'/% .&')%/ .#-%K%-'/ "&-"# @1+'*'+% 91&,+1&'
012%3'#'& ('8% 418/E1#-%H Q18-1&-" AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA [a!'B'& :TAXA 41-' =,&(,& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA _V
!'B'& :TAVA 41-' Q1,8% @1&"8"- 0)'"/ K,& !1C+1 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA_[
!'B'& :TA[A Z,&-,* T%/"')%/'/% 01/13'3'8'& :(1 =++- =+81",#,$1
('& J1+,#8'/% AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA _a
!'B'& :TAaA J%+1&/% 012%3'#'& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA_b
!'B'& :TA_A >8"-'& .&')%/%/ ;"2/-'&/% 012%3'#'& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA `V
!'B'& :TA`A ;%#)"/ 41&'&BB")'&B'& !1&F'&' AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA``
!'B'& TA:A R%&B#'/'& .)"8 48,/1/A.1,-# 5 /1%%&,. @1&"8"-
7,*& GA 0%&B(,& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA bc
!,Y T:AVA :)"/-8'/% .&')%/%/ Z!. ;1(18*'&' "&-"# 41&B'+2%)'&
01E"-"/'& AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAc[
!'B'& T:AXA .)"8 ;h
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
15/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 6
!01203456 +
!"#$%#&%' 7%&% 8)*+%9
/01:; 80?;@5566C5 B5A53 %65A;=;=
!"#" %" '&()*+",-,.
%*/#0,.#" %" '&()*+",-,.
!&012& '&()*+",-,.
7U >"#&,)%+"7&,.
418-1+"'& %&% (%(1/'%& "&-"# +1+2'G' +'*'/%/G' +1&B1&') ('&+")'% 21)'3'8 +18'/'#'& (%+1&/%I(%+1&/% '&')%/%/ #12%3'#'& C'&B /1)'+'
%&% +"&B#%& -%('# -18)')" (%E18*'-%#'& ,)1* ,8'&B E'(' "+"+&C'A
>&-"# %-"D #1)'/ (%2"#' (1&B'& +1&'&C'#'& #1E'(' +'*'/%/G' 'E'
C'&B +181#' E'*'+% -1&-'&B '&')%/%/A J')'+ ,E%&% 2'&C'# ,8'&BD #1-%#'
+1&(1&B'8 #'-' e'&')%/'f '-'" e'&')%/%/fI%1"7#)0* #,#'&)&) *16&M#*#,I#'-'
-18/12"- /1)')" (%'/,/%'/%#'& (1&B'& E8,/1/ 8"+%- ('& #,+E)1#/ "&-"#
+1&B"#"8 /1/"'-"A 41&B"#"8'& %&% 3"B' *'8"/ (%)'#"#'& (1&B'& ')'- "#"8
C'&B 8"+%- ('& #,+E)1#/ E")'A ;1+'#%& ,M'&71%E8,/1/ E1&B"#"8'& ('&
')'- "#"8&C'D +'#' /1+'#%& "1''1('& '#"8'- *'/%) '&')%/%/&C'A N'+"&D
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
16/209
7 .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
"&-"# +18'&B/'&B #1218'&%'& +'*'/%G' (')'+ +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/D
(,/1& 2%/' +1+%&-' +'*'/%/G' "&-"# +1&B"-'8'#'& E1+'*'+'&
+181#' /1&(%8% -1&-'&B '&')%/%/D -'&E' *'8"/ /1)')" +1&B'F" E'(' (1H%&%/%
'&')%/' C'&B N$+77+, F )1,)&$#'O-18/12"-A;1-1)'* +1&C'8%&B E1+'*'+'& +'*'/%/G' -1&-'&B e'&')%/'f ('&
+1+1-'#'& E1&('E'- +181#' -1&-'&B +'#&' '&')%/%/D E18#")%'*'&
(%)'&3"-#'& (1&B'& E1&C18'E'& *'8'E'& +'*'/%/G' ('8% +'-'#")%'*
%&%A >&-"# %-"D +'*'/%/G' (%+%&-' "&-"# +1&")%/#'& (')'+ /1)1+2'8
#18-'/ 2182'B'% *') C'&B +181#' *'8'E#'&M 2'%# C'&B /%H'-&C' /"2/-'&-%HD
+1-,(,),B%/ +'"E"& -1#&%/A
;1-1)'* +'*'/%/G' /1)1/'% +1+218%#'& 3'G'2'&D (,/1&+1+'E'8#'& +'#&' 1-%+,),B%/ ('8% #'-' O.&')%/'P '-'" O.&')%/%/PA
>&-"# %-"D (,/1& 2%/' +1+")'% ('8% (1H%&%/% %/-%)'* N#,#'9)&)O('8% C1J
HI4+"- A71"&$#, ?&$%&+,#"9D C'&B +1&(1H%&%/%#'& '&')%/%/ /12'B'%\ O-1%#&'1-
1I#7&,#%&+, +4 %;1 1'171,%) +" )%"0$%0"1 +4 )+71%;&,.P %9!&$#''9 #) # 6#)&) 4+" -&)$0))&+,
#,- &,%1"!"1%#%&+,QA @1&"8"- /"+218 C'&B /'+'D E8,/1/ +1&B'&')%/' 3"B'
+1)%2'-#'&\ O!"+$1)) +4 )1!#"#%&,. )+71%;&,. &,%+ &%) $+,)%&%01,%R %;1 &-1,%&4&$#%&+,
#,- 71#)0"171,% +4i 1'171,%)M iPAJ'8% (1H%&%/% (% '-'/D (,/1& +1&B'3'# +'*'/%/G' "&-"# /'+E'%
E'(' #1/%+E")'& 2'*G'D /1F'8' /1(18*'&'M '&')%/%/ +1)%E"-%
#1B%'-'& +1&F18+'-% 51I#7&,16M +1+1F'* *') C'&B (%'&')%/%/ (')'+
1)1+1&I1)1+1& E1+21&-"#&C' C'&B )12%* #1F%)D /18-'M #1B%'-'&
+1&B%&(1&-%H%#'/% ('& +1&B"#"8A N'*D #'81&' +,(") %&% 2182%F'8'
-1&-'&B '&')%/%/ #12%3'#'& E"2)%#D 218'8-% +,(") %&% -18#'%- (1&B'&
*') +1&F18+'-%D +1+1F'* *') C'&B (%'&')%/%/ (')'+ 1)1+1&I1)1+1&
E1+21&-"#&C' C'&B )12%* #1F%)D /18-' +1&B%(1&-%H%#'/% ('& +1&B"#"8
#12%3'#'& E"2)%#A
@U?16"&14&,.
;1-1)'* +1+'E'8#'& /1F'8' /%&B#'- +'#&' 1-%+,),B% ('8% '&')%/%/D
(1&B'& +1&B#'%-I#'%-#'& E1&('E'- +'*'/%/G' C'&B /"('* (%'3"#'&D
(,/1& +1+'E'8#'& #1E'(' +'*'/%/G' 2'*G' '&')%/' #12%3'#'&D
218('/'8#'& -"3"'&&C'D 2%/' (%(1H%&%/%#'& 3"B' /12'B'% '#-%K%-'/ "&-"#
+1&F%E-'#'& E1&B1-'*"'& e-1&-'&Bf ('& e"&-"#f E8,/1/ E1+2"'-'&
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
17/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 8
#12%3'#'&AXJ% /%&% (,/1& E18)" +1&B%&B'-#'& +'*'/%/G' 2'*G' -"3"'&
('8% '#-%K%-'/ +1&F18+'-%D +1+1F'* C'&B (%'&')%/%/ (')'+ 1)1+1&I
1)1+1& E1+21&-"#&C' C'&B )12%* #1F%)D /18-' +1&B%(1&-%H%#'/% ('&
+1&B"#"8 #12%3'#'& E"2)%# '(')'* "&-"# +1&('E'-#'& E1&B1-'*"'&C'&B 81)1K'& 2'B% E8,/1/ #12%3'#'&A 41&B1-'*"'& C'&B 81)1K'& 2'B%
#12%3'#'& %&%D /1F'8' B'8%/ 21/'8D +1)%E"-% /12'2D '#%2'-D ('& #%&183'
#12%3'#'&A 41&B1-'*"'& %&% #1+"(%'&D +1/#% -%('# /1)')"D (%+'&H''-#'&
,)1* E1+2"'- #12%3'#'&D -18+'/"# E"2)%#D /12'B'% &,!0% ('& 2'*'&
E18-%+2'&B'& (')'+ E1&B'+2%)'& #1E"-"/'& #12%3'#'&A
J,/1& E18)" +1&1#''& E'(' +'*'/%/G' 2'*G' #1F'#'E'&
+1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ -%('# 2%/' (%('E'-#'& +1)')"% E8,/1/ E1+'*'+'&'-'/ ,2C1# #12%3'#'& C'&B (% '&')%/%/ /1+'-'A 01F'#'E'& '&')%/%/
-1&-'&B /"'-" #12%3'#'& *'8"/ (%("#"&B ,)1* #1+'+E"'& +1+2'&B"&
E1+'*'+'& -18*'('E #,&-1#/ #12%3'#'& C'&B (%'&')%/%/D ('& (%("#"&B
#1+'+E"'& "&-"# +1&"'&B#'& E1+'*'+'& -18/12"- #1 (')'+ &'/#'*A
>&-"# +1+2'&B"& E1+'*'+'& %&%D (%E18)"#'& -%('# *'&C' #'E'/%-'/
#,B&%-%HD -1-'E% 3"B' #1E1#''& /18-' #131)%'& #1-%#' +1&1)''* /"'-" E8,/1/
#12%3'#'&A 01E1#''& ('& #131)%'& %&% '(')'* '/E1# E/%#,+,-,8%/ ('8%
/1,8'&B '&')%/D ('& '/E1# E/%#,+,-,8%/ *'8"/ (%'/'* +1)')"% 2182'B'%
)'-%*'& 'B'8 /1/1,8'&B 2%/' +1&3'(% '&')%/ C'&B 2%/' (%'&(')#'&A
Q"3"'& 21/'8 ('8% E1&C1)1&BB'8''& +'-'#")%'* %&% '(')'*
+1+218%#'& #1+'+E"'& ('/'8 2'B% +'*'/%/G' "&-"# +1)'#"#'&
'&')%/%/ #12%3'#'&A 0'81&' %-"D "&-"# +1&%&B#'-#'& #1E1#''& ('&
#131)%'& +'*'/%/G' (')'+ +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ #12%3'#'&D E1&C1)1&BB'8'
E18#")%'*'& +'" -%('# +'" *'8"/ +1&B'&(')#'& E1&"B'/'& ('&
)'-%*'&A 0'81&' %-"D 1K')"'/% E1+21)'3'8'& 5E1&%)'%'&6 '#'& )12%*
(%('/'8#'& E'(' #1+'+E"'& "&-"# +1&")%/#'& #'8C'A
IU ',-3,)*(+/ !,#B"./(L()
.B'8 +'*'/%/G' )12%* /%'E (')'+ +1&B%#"-% ('& +1+E18/%'E#'&
(%8% "&-"# +1&18%+' +'-18% (')'+ E18#")%'*'& %&%D (,/1& +1+'E'8#'&
! #$%&'(() *$+,(- ./) -012304 -$($5 .266) 70((0$5 8!999: !"#$%#&%' )#%*+,%
-".+/%0%# !1.*+0) ;, ?$-@$A B$-$ C60D'+%03= E+'%%) A$(/ !
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
18/209
9 .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
/1B+1&-'/% E18#")%'*'& ('& B'8%/ 21/'8 +'-18% C'&B '#'& (%/'+E'%#'&
(% +'/%&BI+'/%&B /1/%A
J,/1& +1&C'+E'%#'& E'(' +'*'/%/G' 2'*G' "&-"# +1&3'(%#'&
-%'E /1/% E18-1+"'& (')'+ #")%'* %&% )12%* 1H%/%1&D E18#")%'*'& '#'& (%2'B% #1(')'+ ("' /1B+1&A ;1B+1&!1"%#7#'#'& (%/'3%#'& (')'+ a /1/% E18-1+"'&
E18-'+'A J')'+ /1B+1& %&% +'*'/%/G' (%'3'# "&-"# +1+'*'+% '&')%/%/D
/12'B'% E1&(')'+'& -18*'('E +'#&' '&')%/%/ /12'B'%+'&' (%/12"-#'&
(% '-'/A ;1B+1& %&% /121-")&C' '(')'* e'&')%/%/ I -1&-'&B j '&')%/%/f '-'"
e71%# F #,#'&)&)fA 41&"B'/'& E'(' /1B+1& %&% (%+'#/"(#'& "&-"# +1&B'3'#
+'*'/%/G' +1&B*'C'-% O-1,8% -1&-'&B '&')%/%/PA
;1B+1& *1-0#218%/% E1&18'E'& ('8% O-1,8% -1&-'&B '&')%/%/P C'&B-1)'* (%2'*'/ (% /1B+1& E18-'+'A @'-18% ('8% /1B+1& #1("' %&% '#'&
(%/'+E'%#'& E'(' /1/%I/1/% E18-1+"'& /1)'&3"-&C' ('8% +'-'#")%'* %&%A
41&"B'/'& E'(' /1B+1& %&% (%+'#/"(#'& "&-"# +1)'-%* +'*'/%/G'
+1)'#"#'& 2182'B'% #%/% '&')%/%/A
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
19/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' :
E1+1B'&B #1#"'/''& "&-"# +1+'/-%#'& -"3"'&I-"3"'& C'&B /"('*
(%8"+"/#'& ('& (%/1E'#'-% ,)1* E"2)%# 2%/' -18F'E'%Aa
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
20/209
; .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
E'(' +'*'/%/G' 2'*G' #1&C'-''& -18/12"- +1+2"'- /1,8'&B '&')%/
#12%3'#'& *'8"/ +'+E" +1+%)%* ('& +1&1+E'-#'& (%8%&C' /12'B'%
/')'* /'-" E%*'# ('8% '#-,8 C'&B -18)%2'- (')'+ E8,/1/ #12%3'#'&A
41+'E'8'& -1&-'&B (%+1&/% #12%3'#'& ('& E%)%*'& E,/%/% C'&B2%/' (%'+2%) ,)1* /1,8'&B '&')%/ %&% (%'G')% (1&B'& +1&B%&B'-#'&
+'*'/%/G' -1&-'&B E18(12'-'& 1E%/-1+,),B%/ -1&-'&B 81')%-'A J% /'-"
E%*'# '(' E1&('E'- C'&B +1&B'-'#'& 2'*G' E1&B1-'*"'& 5+'-18%
'&')%/%/6 '(')'* 81')%-'/ ,2C1#-%HM 81')%-'/ C'&B 218'(' (%)"'8 (%8% /%
'&')%/A J% E%*'# )'%&D '(' E1&('E'- 2'*G' 81')%-' /,/%') C'&B (% '&')%/%/
+'" -%('# +'" '(')'* 1#/E81/% /"2C1#-%K%-'/ /1/1,8'&BD -18+'/"#
/"2C1#-%K%-'/ /% '&')%/A 0'81&' %-" 2'B% E1&B'&"- )0691*%&8&)D +"/-'*%)81')%-'/ 218/%H'- ,2C1#-%HA R1')%-'/ C'&B (%'&')%/%/D -18+'/"# 81')%-'/
#12%3'#'&D E'(' ('/'8&C' '(')'* 81')%-'/ /"2C1#-%HA :+E)%#'/%&C'D 2'%#
2"8"#&C' '&')%/%/ 2"#'& (%-1&-"#'& ('8% ,2C1#-%K%-'/I&C' +1)'%'&
3"/-8" ('8% &,%1"5)0691*%&8&%#)I&C'A
!'B% #')'&B'& C'&B +1C'#%&% 2'*G' #"')%-'/ '&')%/%/ (%-1&-"#'&
,)1* ,2C1#-%K%-'/I&C'D '&')%/%/ C'&B %(1') (%2'C'&B#'& 218/%H'- &1-8')
('& -%('# +1+%*'#A 41+2"#-%'& /1F'8' 1+E%8%/ +1+"&B#%'& /% '&')%/+1&B'-'#'& 2'*G' O%-")'* #1&C'-''& /12'B'%+'&' '('&C'PA J% /%/% )'%&D
#')'&B'& C'&B +1&B1(1E''& /"2C1#-%K%-'/ 218E1&('E'- /12')%#&C'A
!'B% #')'&B'& %&%D 'E' C'&B (%/12"- #1&C'-''&D E'(' ('/'8&C' '(')'*
%&-18I/"2C1#-%K%-'/ E1+'#&''& ('& E1+'*'+'& (% '&-'8' ,8'&BI,8'&B
C'&B 218/%&BB"&B'& (1&B'& 81')%-'/ -18/12"-A !'B%&C'D -%('# '(' '&')%/%/
C'&B &1-8')A .&')%/%/ '#'& /1)')" 218/%H'- 8#'01 6+0,-1-A
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
21/209
#$%&' )*+,'-'
#1("' 218#,&-8%2"/% 21/'8 -18*'('E +"&F")&C' -8'(%/% '&')%/%/ "&-"#
#12%3'#'& 5#,#'9)&) 4+" !+'&$96A .&')%/%/ (')'+ -8'(%/% C'&B E18-'+'D /''-
%&%D 81)'-%H )12%* E,E")18 ('& 2'*#'& +1&3'(% /-'&('8 2'B% /12'B%'&
21/'8 '&')%/A .&')%/ ('& '#-,8 #12%3'#'&D 2'%# C'&B '(' (% (')'++'"E"& (% )%&B#'8'& E1+2"'- #12%3'#'&D 2'&C'# +1&BB"&'#'& +,(1)
'&')%/' C'&B +1+2%(%# ,2C1#-%K%-'/ -18/12"-A
418/E1#-%H %&% +1&B'/"+/%#'& 2'*G' #12%3'#'& e2%/'f ('& e*'8"/f
(%'&')%/' /1F'8' ,2C1#-%HA J1&B'& %&/-8"+1&I%&/-8"+1& %)+%'*D '&')%/D
(')'+ E18/E1#-%H %&%D (%'/"+/%#'& /12'B'% 'B1& C'&B -18212'/ ('8%
/1B')' %#'-'& #,&-1#/-"')D 2'*#'& %#'-'& #1-182'-'/'& 8'/%,&')%-'/D ('&
+1+'&('&B 2'*G' '&')%/%/ C'&B (%)'#"#'&&C' +1&B'&("&B /12"'*#121&'8'& C'&B ,2C1#-%H ('& 3"B' )1'4518&-1,%A
0'81&' #121&'8'& ,2C1#-%H (%81("#/% +1&3'(% #1%)+%'*'&D ('&
#1%)+%'*'& (%81("#/% +1&3'(% /1E18'&B#'- E8,/1("8 %)+%'*D E18/E1#-%H
%&% +1)%*'- #12%3'#'& E"2)%# *'&C' /12'B'% E8,/1/ -1#&%/IE8,/1("8')A
J1&B'& (1+%#%'&D (%*'8'E#'&D &1-8')%-'/ '&')%/%/ #12%3'#'& 2%/' (%3'B'A
01218*'/%)'&&C' *'&C' (%-1&-"#'& ,)1* #1*'&(')'& ('& #1-1E'-'&
E1)'#/'&''& E8,/1("8 '&')%/%/ C'&B %)+%'*A ;1)'+' E8,/1("8 *'&(')('& (%-''-% (')'+ E1)'#/'&''&D +'#' (%#1/''& 2'*G' /1+"' '&')%/%/
#12%3'#'& E'/-% +1+218%#'& *'/%) C'&B +1+"'/#'& ('& "1''1A
;12'B'% #,&/1#"1&/%&C'D #'81&' 218,8%1&-'/% E'(' #121&'8'&
,2C1#-%HD +,(1) '&')%/' %&% +1+'&('&B 2'*G' #121&'8'& *'&C')'*
#121&'8'& 3%#' #121&'8'& %-" 218)'#" (% /1B')' -1+E'- ('& (% /1-%'E
/''-A >&-"# +1+'/-%#'& 2'*G' #121&'8'& C'&B ,2C1#-%H %-" -18F'E'%D
+,(1) E1&(1#'-'& %&%D /1F'8' (1-%)D +1+218%#'& E18*'-%'& )12%* E'('
E%)%*'&IE%)%*'& %&/-8"+1& ('& E8,/1("8 '&')%/' C'&B (%E'#'%&C'A
Q1&-" /'3' E'&('&B'& %&% -%('# /1E1&"*&C' /')'*D -1-'E% (% /%&% '('
/'-" #1F1&(18"&B'& "&-"# -18312'# (')'+ #1/1+E%-'& F'8' E'&('&B C'&B
+1+2"'- ,8'&B S%&-#* U7#0V %#;0 6#;J# - %&-#* %#;0QA 01-%('#I-'*"'&
C'&B E')%&B +1&('/'8 '(')'* #1-%('#I-'*"'& -18*'('E #121&'8'& )'%&
C'&B (%*'/%)#'& ,)1* E18/E1#-%H '&')%/' )'%&D C'&B +1+E"&C'% F'8'
E'&('&B C'&B 21821(' -18*'('E '&')%/' ('& #12%3'#'&A
012')%#'&&C'D E18/E1#-%H '&')%/' C'&B #1("' )12%* +1&1#''&
E'(' E8%&/%E 2'*G' #121&'8'& /1)')" 218/%H'- /"2C1#-%HA !1B%-" E")'
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
24/209
6? .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
(1&B'& '&')%/'A ;1+"' '&')%/' E'/-% +1&B'&("&B "&/"8 /"2C1#-%K%-'/A
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
25/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 66
#6 WR
A,#'&)# X16&M#*#,P7'#'8-'\ ^)1Y @1(%'
0,+E"-%&(,P >#6 Y ('&>#6cM
UZ[[\P W,-1-&%&+,VP &%K18/%-C 481//J'*)D R,218-D 5XcbX6D
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
26/209
67 .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
!01203456 ++
8D7!'"9"#,+E+&%,
-%# 8"F%#$$+9%# %#%*+,+,
!"#" %" '&()*+",-,.
%*/#0,.#" %" '&()*+",-,.
!&012& %" '&()*+",-,.
7U7)(./+/+ ;,C/D(B() E() ;%3A.,B+/*(+ N,)%3,)( ;,C/D(B()
4'(' E18-1+"'& #1IV %&%D (,/1& +1&B'3'# +'*'/%/G' "&-"#
+1&B1&') ('& +1+'*'+% 2'B'%+'&' /1,8'&B '&')%/ #12%3'#'&+1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ (1&B'& -%&B#'- #1F'&BB%*'& ('& #,+E81*1&/%K%-'/
-18-1&-"D C'&B +1+21('#'& /1,8'&B '&')%/ (1&B'& ,8'&B 'G'+A
>&-"# %-"D (,/1& +1&B'G')% /1/% %&% (1&B'& +1&B%&B'-#'& #1E'('
+'*'/%/G' -1&-'&B #12%3'#'& /12'B'% H1&,+1&' +")-%(%+1&/%,&')A L')
%&% -1&-" -1)'* (%#1-'*"% ,)1* +'*'/%/G' (')'+ +'-'#")%'* 012%3'#'&
4"2)%#A J1&B'& +1+E18)%*'-#'& 2'*G' H1&,+1&' #12%3'#'& 2%/'
(%E,-81- /12'B'% 81')%-' C'&B 21821('I21('D (,/1& 2%/' +1&"&3"##'&2'*G' '(' 2'&C'# F'8' "&-"# +1)%*'- ('& +1+E18)'#"#'& #12%3'#'&
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
27/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 68
/12'B'% /12"'* ,2C1# '&')%/%/A 41821(''& E18/E1#-%H +1)%*'- #12%3'#'&
('& #18'&B#' '&')%/%/ #12%3'#'& '#'& +1&B*'/%)#'& #1/%+E")'& C'&B
21821('D +1/#%E"& ,2C1# #12%3'#'& C'&B (%#'3% /'+'A
;12'B'% F,&-,*D (,/1& 2%/' +1&B'3'# +'*'/%/G' "&-"# +1)%*'-E8,/1/ #12%3'#'& #,&K18/% 2'*'& 2'#'8 +%&C'# -'&'* #1 2'*'& 2'#'8
B'/A J'8% /'-" E18/E1#-%HD E8,/1/ #12%3'#'& -18/12"- 2%/' (%)%*'- /12'B'%
/12"'* /12"'* E8,/1/ C'&B (%B18'##'& E'(' /"'-" -"3"'& C'&B 31)'/D
1H%/%1&/% H%/#') +1)')"% E1&B"8'&B'& 212'& /"2/%(% &1B'8' (% /1#-,8
1&18B%D (1&B'& )'&B#'*I)'&B#'* C'&B (%('/'8% ,)1* E18*%-"&B'& C'&B
#,+E81*1&/%HD +%/')&C'\O!18'E' 3"+)'* 8"+'* -'&BB' C'&B *'8"/
(%/"E)'% /"2/%(% 2'*'& 2'#'8 B'/dPDO;%'E' C'&B +1&C')"8#'&dDPO!'B'%+'&' E1&C')"8'&&C'dPD OJ'8% +'&' '&BB'8'&&C' '#'&
(%'+2%)dPD ('& /1-18"/&C'A N'+"&D ('8% E18/E1#-%H C'&B )'%&D #12%3'#'&
%&% 3"B' 2%/' (%)%*'- /12'B'% /12"'* E8,/1/ C'&B 218B18'# #1 '8'* ('&
-"3"'& C'&B 21)"+ E'/-% ('& E8,/1/ #12%3'#'& %-" /1&(%8% (%%/% ,)1*
E18-'8"&B'& 2182'B'% #1E1&-%&B'& C'&B &'&-%&C' '#'& +1&1&-"#'&
'8'* ('& *'/%) #12%3'#'&A @%/')&C'D O;%'E' C'&B (%'3'# "&-"# +1+2"'-
#1E"-"/'& #12%3'#'& #,&K18/% #1 2'*'& 2'#'8 B'/ -18/12"-dPD O4%*'#
+'&' C'&B (%"&-"&B#'& ('& (%8"B%#'&dPD OJ'+E'# /,/%') C'&B
+"&B#%& (%-%+2")#'& ('8% E8,/1/ #,&K18/% -18/12"-dPD ('& /1-18"/&C'A
Z,&-,* /18"E' 2%/' #%-' ('E'-#'& 3"B' (')'+ #'/"/ E1&BB"/"8'&
C'&B (%-'+E%)#'& (')'+ @%V 22UPU I%)*%L ;(+"+? ;,C/D(B()
!,)--"+"#()A J'8% #'F'+'-' E1+18%&-'*D /12'B'% E%*'# C'&B
+1&B1)"'8#'& #12%3'#'&D )'&B#'* %&% (%'&BB'E E18)" (1+% #12'%#'&
+'/C'8'#'- /1&(%8%A J')'+ #'/"/ 1#/1#"/% -'&'* +%)%# 418"+ 418"+&'/D
'8B"+1& ('& ),B%#' C'&B (%B"&'#'& "&-"# +1&3"/-%H%#'/% E1&BB"/"8'&
'(')'* (1+% -18F%E-'&C' #1'(%)'& ('& -18E1&"*%&C' E8%&/%E /"E81+'/%
*"#"+D C'&B (')'+ #'/"/ -18/12"- +1&C'-'#'& -'&'* -18/12"- '(')'*
+%)%# 418"+ 418"+&'/D ('& #'81&'&C' +181#' 218*'# +1&BB"/"8
,8'&B C'&B (%'&BB'E -%('# 218*'# +1&(%'+% -'&'* -18/12"-A
N'+"&D (')'+ E18/E1#-%H C'&B )'%&D /1E18-% (%#1+"#'#'& (')'+
'8-%#1) -18/12"-D '(' ('+E'# ('8% #12%3'#'& E1&BB"/"8'& -18/12"- C'&B
/'&B'- 218E,-1&/% +1+"&F")#'& E18+'/')'*'& E"2)%# 2'8"A h'8B'
C'&B -18B"/"8 -1&-"&C' +1&B')'+% B'&BB"'& (')'+ #1*%("E'& /,/%')
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
28/209
69 .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
('& 1#,&,+%&C'A !'B% '&')%/ #12%3'#'&D -1&-"&C' *') %&% -%('# 2%/'
(%#1/'+E%&B#'& 21B%-" /'3'D +1&B%&B'- -"3"'& ('8% #12%3'#'& E"2)%#
'(')'* +1&C1)1/'%#'&E18+'/')'*'& E"2)%#D 2"#'& +1&F%E-'#'&
+'/')'* E"2)%# 2'8"A
@%V 22UPU I%)*%L ;(+"+? ;,C/D(B() !,)--"+"#()
;'8'E'& 4'B% !18/'+' \ Q"2'B"/ 0'82C'&-,
!,)--"+"#() 7E(.(L 8,#%# :,)W,B(3
41&BB"/"8'& '(')'* -18,8 2'B% +'/C'8'#'- #,82'& #'81&' /1&(%
#1*%("E'& +181#' -18F'2"- ('8% '#'8&C' "&B#'E E1+18*'-% +'/')'*
E18#,-''& Q"2'B"/ 0'82C'&-,A O41&BB"/"8'& '(')'* -18,8 C'&B
+1&F1#'+DP #'-' Q"2'B"/ /''- (%*"2"&B% 0Z@D 0'+%/ 5VkXW6A
;1-%('#&C' )12%* ('8% ("' +%&BB" #1 21)'#'&BD G'8B' 7'#'8-' '#8'2
(1&B'& 218%-' E1&BB"/"8'&A ;1-1)'* 8'-"/'& G'8B' 0'+E"&B !'8"D
Z1&B#'81&B #1*%)'&B'& -1+E'- -%&BB') +181#' #'81&' )'*'& C'&B
(%E'#'% (%'+2%) E1+%)%#&C' 418"+ 418"+&'/D B%)%8'& G'8B' 0'+E"&B
;'G'*D Q'&3"&B J"81& 218&'/%2 &''/A 0'+%/ E'B%D XWW G'8B' C'&B
+1&(%'+% )'*'& (% Rh W_ ('& Rh W`D E18/%/ (% /'+E%&B @') Q'+'&
.&BB81# #')'* '(" H%/%# (1&B'& /1#%-'8 [_WW E1-"B'/ -8'+-%2 218%#"-
E,)%/%A Q1+E'- -%&BB') +181#' E"&D 8'-' (1&B'& -'&'*A
iiiiiiA@1&"8"- Q"2'B"/ C'&B 3"B' h'#%) 01-"' 9,8"+
h'8B' 0,-' 59'#-'6 %&%D E1&BB"/"8'& /1E18-% (%31)'/#'& (% '-'/ '#/1/
+'/C'8'#'- #,82'& "&-"# +1&('E'-#'& *'#I*'# *%("E +181#'
21-")I21-") -18-"-"EA O@181#' -%('# 2%/' )'B% +1+%#%8#'& E1#183''&
+181#'A .&'#I'&'# E"& -'# )'B% 2%/' /1#,)'*A @181#' E"& F1+'/ '#'&
'&F'+'& E1&BB"/"8'&IE1&BB"/"8'& /1)'&3"-&C'DP #'-' Q"2'B"/A
;"+218\ *--E\kkGGGA#,+E'/AF,+k"-'+'k&1G/kW[XWkW[kWbV`acA*-+D
>1,#"*#; !1,..0)0"#, #-#'#; )1)0#%0 9#,. 71"0.&*#,T >0*#,*#; %0M0#, -#"&
!1,..0)0"#, *1!1,%&,.#, +"#,. 6#,9#*T
J,/1& +1&B'3'# +'*'/%/G' "&-"# +1)%*'- 2'*G' +'/%&BI+'/%&B
E18/E1#-%H +1&B1(1E''& '/E1# -18-1&-" (1&B'& +1&B1/'+E%&B#'&
'/E1# C'&B )'%&A J% '-'/D E18/E1#-%H C'&B E18-'+' +1&B1(1E''&'/E1# -1#&%/I'(+%&%/-8'-%HI1#,&,+%/D (1&B'& +1&B'2'%#'& '/E1# /,/%,I
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
29/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 6:
E,)%-%/A ;12')%#&C' E18/E1#-%H C'&B #1("' )12%* +1&B1(1E''& '/E1#
/,/%,IE,)%-%/D ('& +1&(,8,&B "E'C' +1&F'8% /,)"/% ')-18&'-%H "&-"#
E18+'/')'*'& #1E1+%)%#'& ('& E1+'&H''-'& )'*'& C'&B +1&3'(%
E,#,# E18+'/')'*'& #12%3'#'& (% '-'/A 4%)%*'& E18/E1#-%H /1,8'&B'&')%/ '#'& 218#,&/1#"1&/% E'(' +,(1) '-'" #18'&B#' '&')%/%/ C'&B
(%B"&'#'&&C' 5@,(1) #12%3'#'& '#'& (%2'*'/ E'(' !'2 :T6A 4'('*')D
("' F,&-,* -18/12"- *'&C')'* /12'B%'& #1F%) ('8% 2182'B'% E18/E1#-%H
-1&-'&B #12%3'#'&A .8-%&C'D '(' (1+%#%'& 2'&C'# F'8' "&-"# +1+'*'+%
#12%3'#'& E"2)%# ('& +1&B'&')%/' #12%3'#'& E"2)%#A :&% 2%/' #%-' )%*'-
E'(' @(-() 22UPU !,*( !,3/B/#() 7)(./+/+ ;,C/D(B() C'&B
+1&"&3"##'&D /1-%('#&C'D 1+E'- E18/E1#-%H #12%3'#'&D C'%-" #12%3'#'&
/12'B'% H1&,+1&' E,)%-%/D (1)%218'-%HD -1#&%/D ('& /-8'-1B%/A
@(-() 22UPU !,*( !,3/B/#() 7)(./+/+ ;,C/D(B()
;"+218\ N"B8,*,D R%'&-D 5VWWb6DA,#'&)&) X16&M#*#,D 7'#'8-'\ ^)1Y @1(%'
0,+E"-%,&(,D *')A X_]
0,&(%/% /1E18-% (% '-'/D (% /'-" /%/%D +1+218%#'& 8"'&B C'&B )1)"'/'
2'B% ,8'&B "&-"# +1&B1+2'&B#'& 2182'B'% +,(1) ('& +1-,(1 '&')%/%/
#12%3'#'&A N'+"&D (% /%/% C'&B )'%&D +1&1+E'-#'& '&')%/ #12%3'#'&
E'(' /%-"'/% C'&B (%)1+'-%/ "&-"# +1&1&-"#'& E18/E1#-%H +'&' C'&B
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
30/209
6; .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
*'8"/ (%E'#'% "&-"# +1&B*'/%)#'& '&')%/%/ C'&B #,+E81*1&/%HA
01%&B%&'& "&-"# +1&B*'/%)#'& /12"'* '&')%/%/ C'&B
#,+E81*1&/%HD -%('# 3'8'&B +1+2'G' /1,8'&B '&')%/ "&-"# 218"E'C'
+1+E18*%-"&B#'& /1+"' H'#-,8 C'&B +1+E1&B'8"*% E8,/1/ /12"'*#12%3'#'&A L'8'E'&&C'D (1&B'& +1+E18*%-"&B#'& /1+"' H'#-,8D /%
'&')%/ 2%/' +1&B*'/%)#'& %&H,8+'/% ('& 8'+')'& #12%3'#'& C'&B '#"8'-A
;'C'&B&C'D #1%&B%&'& /1E18-% (% '-'/ 3'8'&B /1#')% +1&3'(%
#1&C'-''& (')'+ E8'#-1# '&')%/%/ #12%3'#'&A ;')'*I/')'*D '&')%/ C'&B
218/'&B#"-'&D 3%#' -%('# *'-%I*'-%D 2%/' -18312'# (')'+ E1&BB"&''&
&')'8 :#%&+,#'52+7!"1;1,)&81/1F'8' 218)12%*'&D #1-%#' (%' -18)')" E18F'C'
(%8% E'(' 8'/%,&')%-'/ ('& #'E'/%-'/&C' /12'B'% /1,8'&B -1#&,#8'- '-'"'&')%/ #12%3'#'&A ;12')%#&C'D '&')%/%/ C'&B /%H'-&C' *'&C' E'8/%')D '-'"
+1&C1)"8"* &'+"& *'&C' 218E%)'8 E'(' E8%&/%EIE8%&/%E &,8+'-%H
"+"+D#"8'&B +1+%)%#% ('C' 8'+') ('& /1(%#%- /1#')% "-%)%-'/&C' 2'B%
#12"-"*'& E8'#-%/ #12%3'#'&A
J')'+ +1&1&-"#'& E%)%*'& E18/E1#-%H ('& #,&/1#"1&/% -"&-"-'&
(18'3'- #,+E81*1&/%K%-'/ C'&B (%-%+2")#'&D /12'B'% /1,8'&B '&')%/D
+'*'/%/G' *'8"/ +1&B1&')D +1+'*'+%D ('& +1&B*'C'-% E18/E1#-%HIE18/E1#-%H ('/'8 C'&B /1)'+' %&% (%B"&'#'& "&-"# +1+'*'+%D
+1&31)'/#'&D ('& +1+E18)'#"#'& #12%3'#'&A >&-"# %-"D (,/1&
+1+E18#1&')#'& ("' +'S*'2 E1+%#%8'& (')'+ /-"(% #12%3'#'& E"2)%#
('& '&')%/%/ #12%3'#'& E"2)%#A 01("' +'S*'2 %-" '(')'* :#%&+,#'5
2+7!"1;1,)&81('& =#"6#.1 F 2#, @+-1'A 01("' +,(1) ('/'8 %&% 2'&C'#
(%E'#'% "&-"# +1&31)'/#'& ),B%#' (')'+ E8,/1/ #12%3'#'& E"2)%#A
41821(''& #1("'&C' '(')'* E'(' #1C'#%&'& C'&B +181#' )1-'##'& (%
'-'/ 8'/%,&')%-'/D /1E18-% -'+E'# (')'+ D#61' EELEL !,#C,E(() :%E,.X
:%E,. !,)-(3C/.() ;,A"*"+()U
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
31/209
#$%&')*+,'-'
6
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
32/209
6=
.+*/!-!-012!3*4*+
#$2/!4
Z'#"E'& '&')%/%/ ;"2/-'&/% ;"2/-'&/% ('& E8,/1/ 48,/1/
01E"-"/'& C'&B
(%*'8'E#'& '#'&
(%*'/%)#'&
^H1#-%H ('& 1H%/%1&D (1&B'& '/"+/%
#)'%+ %)+%'* ('& ,2C1#-%H -%('#
E18)" (%-"&("##'& E'(' (%&'+%#'
E,)%-%# C'&B '(' (')'+ /%-"'/%
#1E"-"/'& #12%3'#'&
^H1#-%H ('& 1H%/%1&D &'+"& 3"B' *'8"/
2%/' (%-18%+' ,)1* '#-,8I'#-,8 C'&B
-18)%2'- ('& %#"- +1&F%E-'#'& /%-"'/%
#1E"-"/'& #12%3'#'&
;1/"'% (1&B'& #1'(''& C'&B
(%*'('E%D &'+"& 3"B' -%('# -18)')"
2'&C'# +18"2'* #12%'/''& C'&B
/1)'+' %&% -18)1+2'B'
4,/%/% '&')%/ ;12'B'% ,8'&B )"'8 C'&B %+E'8/%')
;12'B'% 2'B%'& C'&B %#"-
+1+E1&B'8"*% E8,/1/ ('& *'/%)
E1&B'+2%)'& #1E"-"/'&
;12'B'% 2'B%'& ('8% /%/-1+ C'&B
+181E8,("#/% e#12%'/''&f
Q1#&%# ('& +1-,(1
'&')%/%/ C'&B 2%'/'
(%B"&'#'&
Z!.D ;h
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
33/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 6>
J%'&-'8' #1("' +,(1) -18/12"-D '(' +,(1) C'&B 218"/'*'
+1&B'+2%) 3')'& -1&B'*D C'&B (%/12"- /12'B'% @,(1)@&I1- 5 /$#,,&,.A
01-%B' +,(1) -18/12"- +1+%)%#% (1H%&%/%I&C' /1&(%8% -1&-'&B E8,/1/
#12%3'#'&A @,(1) =#"6#.1 F 2#,+1)%*'- E8,/1/ #12%3'#'& C'&B /1(%#%-/1#')% +1)%2'-#'& E8,/1/ C'&B 8'/%,&')D (')'+ '8-%'& %)+%'*A 48,/1/
#12%3'#'& )12%* (%B18'##'& ,)1* #12%'/''&I#12%'/''& C'&B /"('*
E18&'* (%)'#"#'& (% +'/' /121)"+&C' '-'" (%-1+E'- )'%&A
;12')%#&C'D @,(1) :#%&+,#'52+7!"1;1,)&81 +1&(1H%&%/%#'& E8,/1/
#12%3'#'& /12'B'% E8,/1/ C'&B /1E1&"*&C' 8'/%,&')A 48,/1/ #12%3'#'&
+1)%E"-% '#-%K%-'/ #')#")'/%D E8,C1#/%D E181&F'&''&D ('& H,8+")'/% C'&B
,M'&71%A ;1B')' #1E"-"/'& (%'+2%) 218('/'8#'& %&H,8+'/% C'&B )1&B#'E('& E18*%-"&B'& C'&B #,+E81*1&/%HA
@,(1) @&I1-5/$#,,&,. +1&F,2' +1&B'+2%) E,/%/% (% '&-'8'
#1("'&C'A @,(1) %&% +1&B'#"% #1-182'-'/'& &')'8 +'&"/%'D ('& +1)%*'-
E8,/1/ #12%3'#'& -%('# /1+'-'I+'-' (%-1&-"#'& ,)1* E18*%-"&B'&
8'/%,&') j 1H1#-%H j 1H%/%1&D -1-'E% 3"B' E18*%-"&B'& 8'/%,&') j E,)%-%/D
C'&B +1&B'#%2'-#'& E8,/1/ #12%3'#'& (%G'8&'% ,)1* E8,/1/ -'G'8I
+1&'G'8 '&-'8 2182'B'% '#-,8 ('& #1E1&-%&B'& C'&B -18)%2'-A 48,/1/-'G'8I+1&'G'8 %&% 3"B' (%'&BB'E -183'(% (')'+ /12"'* #,&-1#/ /,/%')
C'&B /E1/%H%#D (1&B'& &%)'%D &,8+'D ('& #12%'/''& C'&B +1&B#18'&B#'%
E8,/1/ '(+%&%/-8'-%H ('& E,)%-%# C'&B -183'(%AX
J,/1& +1+'E'8#'& 2'*G' E1&BB"&''& #1-%B' +,(1) %-" (')'+
'&')%/' #12%3'#'&D 218%+E)%#'/% E'(' -"&-"-'& #,+E81*1&/%K%-'/ ('&
#1E%'G'%'& '&')%/' C'&B 21821(' ('8% /1,8'&B '&')%/A Q1&-"&C'D
%&% (%/12'2#'& ,)1* E1821(''& '/"+/% C'&B (%3'(%#'& /12'B'% ('/'8
'&')%/' (')'+ -%'E +,(1)A :&/-8"+1& '&')%/' C'&B (%E'#'% (')'+ -%'E
+,(1) 3"B' 21821('I21('A
! #0A$3 @2
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
34/209
7? .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
@(-() 22URU
0497M78 ;G:!94>45'2H287' 757=2'2' ;4@2M7;75
@%/')&C'D '(' /1,8'&B '&')%/ C'&B +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ "&-"#
E1&B'+2%)'& #1E"-"/'& #12%3'#'&A 01-%#' (%' +1+%)%* +1&BB"&'#'&
@+-1' :#%&+,#'52+7!"1;1,)&81D +'" -%('# +'"D '&')%/ -18/12"- (%-"&-"- "&-"#
+1)%*'- ('& +1+E18*%-"&B#'& /1F'8' #,+E81*1&/%H /1B')' #1+"&B#%&'&
C'&B +1&3'(% #,&/1#"1&/% ('8% /1-%'E ')-18&'-%H E%)%*'& #12%3'#'& C'&B
'('A ;1*%&BB'D '&')%/%/ #12%3'#'& (')'+ +,(1) %&% -%('# *'&C' (%)'#"#'&
"&-"# +1&B'&')%/%/ E8,/1/ E1&B'+2%)'& #1E"-"/'& #12%3'#'&D -1-'E% 3"B'
/'+E'% E'(' E1+2"'-'& H,8+")' ('& (1/'%& #12%3'#'&A
J')'+ +,(1) %&%D E18B1/18'& E8'#-1# ('& 81')%-' #12%3'#'& ('8%
(1/'%& '-'" H,8+")' C'&B /"('* (%8"+"/#'& +18"E'#'& *') C'&B E')%&B
-%('# (%*'8'E#'&D +1/#%E"& 2"#'& 218'8-% -%('# (%'&-%/%E'/%A !%'/'&C'
(1/'%& ('& H,8+")' #12%3'#'& C'&B (%2'&B"& (1&B'& +,(1) %&% -1)'*
+1&C%'E#'& (1/'%& '-'" H,8+")' $+,%&,.1,$9 '-'" 1I&% !'#, 3%#' /%-"'/%
#12%3'#'& 218#1+2'&B #1 '8'* C'&B -%('# (%'&-%/%E'/% /121)"+&C'A :&%
218'8-%D E%)%*'& "&-"# +1)'#"#'& '&')%/' (1&B'& +,(1) %&% +1+'&B
+1&"&-"- /1,8'&B '&')%/ "&-"# 21&'8I21&'8 +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ C'&B
#,+E81*1&/%HA
;12')%#&C'D '&')%/ C'&B 21#183' (1&B'& @,(1) =#"6#.1 F 2#, '-'"
018'&3'&B ;'+E'*D #1-%#' +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ "&-"# E1&B'+2%)'&
#1E"-"/'& #12%3'#'&D +"&B#%& /1#')% *'&C' (%-"&-"- "&-"#
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
35/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 76
+1&B%(1&-%H%#'/% E1&B')'+'&IE1&B')'+'& C'&B +%8%E (1&B'& #,&(%/%
C'&B /1#'8'&B (%'&')%/%/A 01+"(%'& +1&B%(1&-%H%#'/% #1E"-"/'& 'E'
C'&B e2%'/'&C'f (%'+2%) (')'+ /%-"'/% C'&B (%'&BB'E /18"E' %-" ('&
/1218'E' 21/'8 #1E"-"/'& %-" 218*'/%)A 9,8+")' ('& (1/'%& #12%3'#'&(%8'&F'&B /1F'8' B'8%/ 21/'8 ('& /'&B'- +"&B#%& "&-"# +1&B')'+%
E18"2'*'& /1%8%&B (1&B'& E18#1+2'&B'& /%-"'/% C'&B (%*'('E%A N'+"&
E%)%*'& '-'/ +,(1) %&% 3"B' +1&B*'(%8#'& #,&/1#"1&/% 2'*G' '&')%/
*'8"/ /1)')" /%'E (1&B'& E18"2'*'& /%-"'/% C'&B 2%/' -183'(% /1#1-%#'A
J,/1& +1&1B'/#'& #1E'(' +'*'/%/G' 2'*G' E%)%*'& +,(1) (')'+
+1)'#"#'& '&')%/' #12%3'#'& 2"#'&)'* /12"'* '#-%K%-'/ C'&B -%('#
218+'#&'D -1-'E% +18"E'#'& /"'-" E%)%*'& C'&B /1)'&3"-&C' +1&3'(%#18'&B#' 'F"'& 2'B% /1,8'&B '&')%/ (')'+ +1+2'&B"& '&')%/'&C'A !'%#
2"8"#&C' '&')%/' C'&B (%)'#"#'&D %#"- (%-1&-"#'& ,)1* #,&/%/-1&/% '&-'8'
+,(1) C'&B (%B"&'#'& ('& '&')%/%/ C'&B (%*'/%)#'& ('8% /"'-" '&')%/%/A
;1+1&-'8' @,(1) @&I1- F /$#,,&,. 218"/'*' +1&'G'8#'&
H)1#/%2%)%-'/ (% '&-'8' #1-1B'&B'& ("' +,(1) /121)"+&C'A :&% #'81&'
'/"+/% @,(1)@&I1- F /$#,,&,.+1)%*'- 2'*G' +1/#%E"& E8,/1/ #12%3'#'&
+1)%2'-#'& #,&H)%# #1E1&-%&B'& ('& -'G'8I+1&'G'8 '&-'8 '#-,8D /1)"8"*'#-,8 -18/12"- 2182%F'8' (')'+ /"'-" 2'-'/ 8'/%,&')%-'/ +%&%+"+A
@U !/./L() ',%#()- 7)(./+
=12%* )'&3"-D (,/1& +1+'E'8#'& 2'*G' C'&B +1+E1&B'8"*%
E%)%*'& E,/%/% /1,8'&B '&')%/ 2"#'& /1#1('8 #1"&BB")'& ('& #1)1+'*'&
+'/%&BI+'/%&B +,(1)A ;18%&B#')%D (')'+ +1+%)%* +,(1)D '&')%/ 3"B'
*'8"/ +1+E18-%+2'&B#'& H'#-,8 G'#-" C'&B -18/1(%'D '#/1/ -18*'('E
/"+218 ('-'D ('& H'#-,8IH'#-,8 )'%&&C'A Q1&-"&C' #%-' -%('# 2%/'
+1&B'2'%#'& H'#-,8IH'#-,8 -1#&%/ %&% (')'+ E%)%*'& +,(1) '&')%/%/A
N'+"&D -18)1E'/ ('8% %-" /1+"'D E1&-%&B "&-"# (%E'*'+% ,)1*
/1,8'&B '&')%/ 2'*G' #1F'&BB%*'& '&')%/%/ /121-")&C' -1-'E +1&3'(%
E,%& "-'+' C'&B (%-"&-"- ('8% /1,8'&B '&')%/A 01F'&BB%*'& /1,8'&B
'&')%/ %&% '#'& 218"3"&B E'(' 81)%'2%)%-'/ ('& '#"8'/% '&')%/%/ C'&B
(%*'/%)#'&A 01F'&BB%*'& %&%)'* C'&B #1+"(%'& *'8"/ (%#,+E8,+%#'&
(1&B'& H'#-,8IH'#-,8 -1#&%/ C'&B /18%&B#')% *'8"/ (%E18-%+2'&B#'&
,)1* /1,8'&B '&')%/ (')'+ +1&1&-"#'& E%)%*'& E,/%/%&C'A
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
36/209
77 .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
J')'+ +1&1&-"#'& E%)%*'& E,/%/% %&%D /1,8'&B '&')%/ *'8"/
/'&BB"E +1+'*'+% ('& +1+E8,C1#/%#'& #,&/1#"1&/% C'&B +"&F")
('8% -%'E E%)%*'& E,/%/% C'&B (%*'('E%&C'A 0,&/%/-1&/% /1,8'&B '&')%/
(1&B'& E%)%*'& E,/%/% C'&B (%'+2%)&C'D (1&B'& /1B')' #,&/1#"1&/%&C'D+18"E'#'& E,%& "-'+' E1&%)'%'& 2'%# 2"8"#&C' /1,8'&B '&')%/D /1)'%&
#1F'&BB%*'& '&')%/' C'&B (%*'/%)#'&A :&% +1&B%&B'- 2'*G' /%-"'/% C'&B
+1+E1&B'8"*% E%)%*'& /1,8'&B '&')%/ -%('# E18&'* /'+'A
>&-"# 2%/' +1+'*'+% ('& +1+E8,C1#/%#'& #,&/1#"1&/% ('8% -%'E
E%)%*'& E,/%/%D /1,8'&B '&')%/ +1+18)"#'& #1+'+E"'& "&-"# 218E%#%8
#8%-%/A 08%-%/%/+1 %&% -18"-'+' (%-"3"#'& E'(' 2182'B'% E%)%*'& E18/E1#-%H
('& +,(1) #12%3'#'& C'&B '('A J'8% /%-" /% '&')%/ '#'& 2%/' +18'2'#1"&BB")'& ('& #1)1+'*'& ('8% +'/%&BI+'/%&B E18/E1#-%H ('& +,(1)
#12%3'#'&M /18-' #,&/1#"1&/%&C' (')'+ '&')%/%/ C'&B '#'& (%)'#"#'&A
4'(' #1/1+E'-'& %&%D (,/1& 2%/' +18'&B/'&B #1+'+E"'&
218E%#%8 #8%-%/ +'*'/%/G'D (1&B'& +1&B'3'# +181#' "&-"# +1&B#8%-%/%
),B%#' +,(1)I+,(1) #12%3'#'& :#%&+,#'52+7!"1;1,)&81 ('& =#"6#.152#,
C'&B /"('* (%E'E'8#'& /121)"+&C'A
IU :456;9282'2 =G62;7 :ADEHCA352H@&-"# +1+%F" #8%-%/%/+1 +'*'/%/G'D (,/1& +1&BB"&'#'&
/%+")'/% C'&B '#'& 218B"&' /12'B'% 2'*'& 81H)1#/% 2'B% +'*'/%/G'A
;%+")'/% %&% 218#'%-'& (1&B'& +'/')'* #,+E81*1&/%K%-'/ E1&B1-'*"'&D
+1&B%&B'- #)'%+ ),B%#' :#%&+,#'52+7!"1;1,)&81 +1&C'-'#'& 2'*G' E8,/1/
#12%3'#'& C'&B 2'%# '(')'* E8,/1/ C'&B /1E1&"*&C' (%#1&(')%#'& ,)1*
8'/%,&')%-'/ ,2C1#-%H +'&"/%'A
J')'+ /%+")'/% %&%D !1"%#7#D +'*'/%/G' (%2'B% (')'+ 21218'E'
#1),+E,#A ;1)'&3"-&C'D +'*'/%/G' (%+%&-' "&-"# +1&B,+1&-'8%
/"'-" %/" #12%3'#'& -18-1&-"A J,/1& 2%/' +1&B"/'*'#'& /'-" F,&-,* %/"
#12%3'#'& C'&B #,&-8,K18/%') C'&B /1('&B *'&B'- +1&3'(% E1+2%F'8''&
+'/C'8'#'-A ;1-1)'* %-"D #,+1&-'8 +'*'/%/G' (%#"+E")#'&D ('&
218/'+'I/'+'D +'/%&BI+'/%&B #1),+E,# (%+%&-' "&-"# +1&B%/% #,),+
C'&B -18/1(%' /1E18-% (')'+ D#61' EELWL @#%"&*) E), /&70'#)&A
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
37/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 78
8(C,. 22URU :(*#/B+ 2+/() '/3".(+/
J756 :494;7 87>< J756 :494;7
8207; 87>#.& ?&)*0)&A
;1+1&-'8' #,+1&-'8 #1),+E,# )'%& C'&B 21821(' (1&B'& #,+1&-'8
#1),+E,#&C'D (% +'/"##'& (')'+ #,),+ D&%&* >0%# /#9#A 0,+1&-'8 ('8%
#1),+E,# C'&B 218/'&B#"-'&D C'&B -%('# (%/%&BB"&B ,)1* #1),+E,#
)'%&D (%+'/"##'& (')'+ #,),+ D&%&* >0%# @1"1*#A
0%-' '#'& +1&1+"#'& #,+1&-'8I#,+1&-'8 (')'+ #,),+ D1"60*#
>#.& ?&)*0)&A 0,+1&-'8 C'&B '(' (')'+ #,),+ %&% 2%/' (%/12"- /12'B'%
%&-18I/"2C1#-%K%-'/ C'&B '(' (% '&-'8' E'8' +'*'/%/G' -18/12"-D -18#'%-
(1&B'& %/" C'&B (%#,+1&-'8%A .-'" (')'+ 2'*'/' E1&B'&"- E18/E1#-%H
,2C1#-%K%/D (%/12"- /12'B'% E1&B1-'*"'& C'&B ,2C1#-%HA
J'8% /%+")'/% -18/12"-D (,/1& 2%/' +1&B'3"#'& E18-'&C''&D O.E'
C'&B +1+2"'- /1/1,8'&B +1+218%#'& #,+1&-'8 C'&B 21821('dPA 7%#'
%&H,8+'/% -1&-'&B %/" #12%3'#'& C'&B (%B"&'#'& (')'+ /%+")'/% %&%
81)'-%H /1(%#%- (%+%)%#% ,)1* +'*'/%/G'D,E%&% +'*'/%/G' '#'& 2'&C'#
-18#"+E") (% #,),+ #"'(8'& D&%&* >0%# /#9# ('& D&%&* >0%# @1"1*#A
.8-%&C' /1+'#%& #1F%) %&-18I/"2C1#-%K%-'/ C'&B +"&F")A
0'81&' /1)"8"* +'*'/%/G' C'&B +1&B%#"-% +'-' #")%'* .&')%/%/
012%3'#'& 4"2)%# E'/-% /"('* E18&'* +1+2'*'/ +'/')'* #)'%+
,2C1#-%K%-'/ %)+" (')'+ +'-' #")%'* :)+" ;,/%') J'/'8D (,/1& 2%/'
+1&B'3"#'& E18-'&C''&D O.E'#'* ,2C1#-%K%-'/ 2%/' +1&C1)1/'%#'&
+'/')'*dPA @1)')"% /%+")'% (% '-'/D /121-")&C' '#'& &'+E'# 2'*G'
,2C1#-%K%-'/ +1&3'(% -%('# 81)1K'& #1-%#' E1&B1-'*"'& -%('# )1&B#'ED 2'%#
E1&B1-'*"'& C'&B #%-' +%)%#% +'"E"& (%+%)%#% ,8'&B )'%&A ;121-")&C'D
,2C1#-%H '-'" -%('# %-" (%-1&-"#'& ,)1* 'E' C'&B #%-' #1-'*"% ('& ,8'&B
)'%& #1-'*"%A
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
38/209
79 .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
/1F'8' #,&/1E-"') +'"E"& /%+2,)%#A Q'E%D ,2C1#-%K%-'/ %-" -%('# '#'&
-1821&-"# 3%#' /')'* /'-"&C' -%('# '-'" 21)"+ E18&'* +1&B1&') B'3'*A
?0)D 'E' 21('&C' ,2C1#-%K%-'/ (1&B'& %&-18I/"2C1#-%K%-'/d
J1&B'& %&/E%8'/% ('8% /%+")'/% C'&B (%)'#"#'& /121)"+&C'D (,/1&+1+%&-' #,+1&-'8 +'*'/%/G' -1&-'&B /"2C1#-%K%-'/A 418-'&C''&D
O.E'#'* /"2C1#-%K%-'/ %-" /1)'+'&C' 2"8"#dPA ;1-1)'* +'*'/%/G'
+1+218%#'& #,+1&-'8 +181#'D (,/1& 2%/' +")'% +1+'E'8#'& 2'*G'
81')%-'/D '-'" 'E' C'&B #%-' '&BB'E /12'B'% 81')%-'/D /'&B'- +"&B#%&
*'&C')'* /12"'* H1&,+1&' C'&B #%-' +'#&'% /1F'8' %&-18/"2C1#-%HA
J'8% /%-"D (,/1& 2%/' +")'% +1+'E'8#'& -1&-'&B E1&-%&B&C'
/1,8'&B '&')%/ "&-"# +1&B'+2%) ('& +1&1&-"#'& E,/%/%&C' (')'++1&B'&')%/%/A 4,%& E1&-%&B C'&B E18)" (%"-'8'#'& ,)1* (,/1& (%
/%&% '(')'*D (1&B'& +1&1&-"#'& E,/%/%&C' /1,8'&B '&')%/ 2%/'
+1&(1H%&%/%#'& 'E' C'&B (%' -'*" ('& 'E' C'&B (%' -%('# -'*"A 0'81&'
2'&C'# *') C'&B (%' -%('# -'*"D +'#' E1&-%&B 2'B% /% '&')%/ "&-"# /1)')"
+1+2"#' E%#%8'&&C' -18*'('E E1&('E'- ,8'&B )'%&A
4'(' /1/% /121)"+&C'D +'*'/%/G' -1)'* (%+%&-' "&-"# +1+2'F'
-")%/'& ^"B1&1D 5!'8('F*D ^"B1&1D VWW_D
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
39/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 7:
*'8"/ (%E18-%+2'&B#'& (')'+ +1&1&-"#'& E,/%/% '#'& +1&3'(%
H,#"/ E1+2'*'/'& (% /1/% 218%#"-&C'A !18'&B#'- ('8% E1+'*'+'&
C'&B (%('E'-#'& E'(' /1/% %&%D E'(' ("' /1/% 218%#"-&C' (,/1& '#'&
+1&B'3'# +'*'/%/G' "&-"# +1&B*'C'-% 2'B'%+'&' ('8% E1+'*'+'&-18/12"- #1E%'G'%'& +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ 2%/' (%2'&B"&A ;1)'%& %-"D
+'*'/%/G' 3"B' '#'& (%'3'# "&-"# +1&B*'C'-% E,/%/%&C' /12'B'% '&')%/
('& #,&/1#"1&/% ('8% E%)%*'& E,/%/%&C'A
0U 8"-(+ 7BL/# ',+/
;121)"+ #1)'/ (%-"-"ED +'*'/%/G' (%+%&-' +1+E18/%'E#'& (%8%
"&-"# /1/% 218%#"-&C'D (1&B'& +1+2'F' ('& +1I"18&1J("' )%-18'-"8 C'&B'#'& (%B"&'#'& /12'B'% 'F"'& ('& E182'&(%&B'& "&-"# /1/% 218%#"-&C'A
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
40/209
7; .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
!01203456 +++
D/G"8&+E+&%, %#%*+,+,
8H621HI01=; %65A;=;= 4624< 80?;@5&-"# %-"D (,/1& +1&B'G')% /1/%
%&% (1&B'& /1(%#%- +1&B")'&B #1+2')% +'-18% /1/% /121)"+&C'D -1&-'&B
E18/E1#-%HIE18/E1#-%H ('/'8 :#%&+,#'52+7!"1;1,)&81D =#"6#.152#,D ('&
@&I1-5/$#,,&,.C'&B 2'&C'# (%B"&'#'& (')'+ #'3%'& #12%3'#'& E"2)%#A
J,/1& +1&B'3'# +'*'/%/G' "&-"# +1&F18+'-% 2'*G' (')'+ +'/%&BI
+'/%&B E18/E1#-%H '&')%/' ('& /% '&')%/ (%'/"+/%#'& +1&B'+2%) E,/%/%
-18-1&-" -18*'('E ,2C1# #12%3'#'& C'&B (%#'3%&C'A
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
41/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 7#.#, EEELZL
^060,.#, A,%#"# A,#'&)&) 0,%0* X16&M#*#, -#, A,#'&)&) %1";#-#! X16&M#*#,U
J')'+ 2'B'& -18/12"-D L,BG,,( ('& ?"&& +1+'#'% %/-%)'* !+'&$9
)%0-&1)"&-"# '&')%/' -18*'('E #12%3'#'&D ('&!+'&$9 #,#'9)&) 2'B% '&')%/%/
"&-"# #12%3'#'&A
@(-() 222UPU >"C")-() 7)*(#( 7)(./+/+ 7_7 X,+3,6 _ O,54$6=) 4'+3$5$ 1$(0 -042L(01$%01$6 !9]] -'6
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
45/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 86
J,/1& +1+%&-' +'*'/%/G' "&-"# +1+E18*'-%#'& 2'*G' (')'+
#,),+ '(K,#'/% #12%3'#'&D L,BG,,( ('& ?"&& +1&1+E'-#'& (%
2'G'*&C' '&')%/ #12%3'#'& C'&B 52%/'6 /1#')%B"/ 218E18'& /12'B'%
'#-,8 E,)%-%#D ('& /12')%#&C'D '#-,8 E,)%-%# C'&B 52%/'6 218E18'&/12'B'% '&')%/ #12%3'#'&A J% /%&% '&')%/%/ (%)'#"#'& "&-"# +1)'C'&%
#12"-"*'& ('& E18+'/')'*'& E8'#-%/ C'&B +1+'&B +1&1+E'-#'&
'&')%/ #12%3'#'& '-'"E"& '#-,8 E,)%-%# C'&B 218/'&B#"-'& (')'+ /%-"'/%
(% +'&' #12%3'#'& C'&B (%2"'- *'8"/ 2%/' +1&B'-'/% E18+'/')'*'&
C'&B (%*'('E%A ?0)D '&')%/%/ /1+'F'+ %&% -%('# '#'& (%#8%-%/% 3%#'
-%('# /1E1&"*&C' +1&-''-% #'%('* #1%)+%'*'&D /1)'+' '&')%/%/ C'&B
(%)'#"#'& +1&B*'/%)#'& #12%3'#'& C'&B 81)1K'& (1&B'& /%-"'/% C'&B
(%*'('E%A !'%#I-%('#&C' '&')%/%/ #12%3'#'& (')'+ F,8'# %&% (%"#"8
('8% 1H1#-%H -%('#&C' #12%3'#'& C'&B (%*'/%)#'& ('8% '&')%/%/ -18/12"-
+1&B'-'/% E18+'/')'*'& E"2)%# C'&B (%*'('E%A
.&')%/%/ C'&B (%)'#"#'& (')'+ F,8'# '&')%/%/ "&-"# #12%3'#'&D
-1&-"&C' +1+2"-"*#'& ('/'8 -1,8%-%#A J'/'8 -1,8%-%# %&%D /12'B%'&
21/'8D (%*'/%)#'& +1)')"% '&')%/%/ -18*'('E #12%3'#'& (')'+!+'&$9 )%0-&1)A
J% /%&%D E8,/1/ E1+2'&B"&'& -1,8% +1+'&B -"&("# E'(' #'%('*I
#'%('* %)+%'*D ('& 2'%#I2"8"#&C' '&')%/%/ (')'+ F,8'# %&% (%)%*'-
('8% /13'"* +'&' E8,/1/ '&')%/%/ ('& -1,8% C'&B (%2'&B"& +1+1&"*%
#'%('*I#'%('* #1%)+%'*'&A N'+"&D #1-%#' 218'(' (% -'&B'& '&')%/
'-'" '#-,8 E,)%-%# C'&B +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ (1&B'& F,8'# '&')%/%/
"&-"# #12%3'#'&D -1,8%I-1,8% %&% '#'& (%"3% (')'+ ("&%' &C'-' "&-"#
+1+2"#-%#'& O*1.0,##,,9#P (')'+ /%-"'/% #12%3'#'& C'&B /E1/%H%#A !%)'
-182"#-% +1+%)%#% #1B"&''& (')'+ E8'#-1# &C'-' #12%3'#'&D +'#'
E1&18%+''& -18*'('E -1,8% C'&B 218/'&B#"-'& '#'& /1+'#%& 21/'8AN'+"&D 3%#' /12')%#&C'D -1,8% C'&B 218/'&B#"-'& -%('#I/18-' +18-'
(%&C'-'#'& /')'*D &'+"& *'&C' '#'& (%E'&('&B -%('# 81)1K'& (1&B'&
/%-"'/% #12%3'#'& C'&B -1&B'* (%*'('E%A :&% #'81&' -1,8% -18/12"-
+18"E'#'& *'/%) '2/-8'#/% ('8% H1&,+1&' E8'#-1# #12%3'#'& -18-1&-"D
C'&B +"&B#%& /'3' 21821(' (1&B'& E8'#-1# #12%3'#'& (% +'&' -1,8%
-18/12"- #1+"(%'& (%B"&'#'&A
J,/1& +1&31)'/#'& #1E'(' +'*'/%/G' 2'*G' (')'+ /1B+1("' +'-' #")%'* %&%D +'*'/%/G' 212'/ +1+%)%* /')'* /'-" (% '&-'8'
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
46/209
87 .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
#1("' F,8'# '&')%/' #12%3'#'& -18/12"-A @'*'/%/G' E18)" (%%&B'-#'&D
/121)"+ +1&1&-"#'& E%)%*'&D +'*'/%/G' *'8"/ +1+'*'+% *')I*')
C'&B /%H'-&C' +1-'I'&')%/%/ /121)"+ +1&C1&-"* E18/,')'& -18-1&-"A
01)'-'*'& ('& #1-%('##8%-%/'& '#%2'- #"8'&B&C' E1+'*'+'& -18*'('EE18+'/')'*'& +1-' j '&')%/%/ %&% E1&-%&B "&-"# (%*%&('8% +1&B%&B'-
#1F1&(18"&B'& /1-%'E E18/E1#-%H '-'" E1&(1#'-'& "&-"# +1+H,#"/#'&
E18*'-%'&&C' E'(' /"'-" '/E1# -18-1&-" ('& '2'% (1&B'& '/E1# C'&B
)'%&A >&-"# %-"D!1"%#7#D '&')%/ *'8"/ -'*" 'E' C'&B (%#1-'*"%&C' ('&
'E' C'&B +"&B#%& (%*'/%)#'& ('8% E1&B1-'*"'&&C' +1)')"% #1F'#'E'&
('& %&/-8"+1& '&')%/%/ C'&B (%+%)%#%&C'A
X1-0#D /% '&')%/ *'8"/ +1+'*'+% E,-1&/% #'8C'&C' (%'&')%/%/ ,)1*,8'&B )'%& ('& (%#8%-%# #'81&' F,8'# '&')%/%/&C'D 2"#'& #'81&' /"2/-'&/%&C'A
J1&B'& +1&B1-'*"% )"2'&B '-'" #1#"8'&B'& ('8% E1&B1-'*"'& ('& *'/%)
'&')%/'&C'D /% '&')%/ 2%/' +1&B'&-%/%E'/% '('&C' #8%-%# C'&B (%),&-'8#'&
,)1* ,8'&B )'%& '-'/ F,8'# '&')%/%/ C'&B (%B"&'#'&&C'A
7U :,3(L(3/ !,#() 7)(./+ E(.(3 0"( 8#(E/+/ 7)(./+/+
;,C/D(B() !"C./B
.B'8 +'*'/%/G' +1+%)%#% E1+'*'+'& )12%*D /12'B'% 2'*'&
E18-%+2'&B'&D (,/1& E18)" +1+'E'8#'& #,&-8,K18/% /1E"-'8 ,2C1#-%K%-'/
-18#'%- (1&B'& E,/%/% ('& F,8'# '&')%/' C'&B (%E%)%* ,)1* /1,8'&B '&')%/A
J,/1& +1&31)'/#'& 2'*G' E%)%*'& E,/%/% ('& F,8'# '&')%/' /1,8'&B
'&')%/ '#'& +1+"&F")#'& #,&/1#"1&/% -18/1&(%8%D /')'* /'-"&C' '(')'*
E18'& -18-1&-" C'&B (%-"&-"- ('8% /% '&')%/A .&')%/%/ -18*'('E #12%3'#'&
+1&"&-"- #1E%'G'%'& /% '&')%/ "&-"# +1&B'2/-8'#/%#'& H1&,+1&'
#12%3'#'&A;1+1&-'8'D '&')%/%/ "&-"# #12%3'#'& +1&"&-"- #1E%'G'%'&
/% '&')%/ (')'+ +1&F%E-'#'& 81')%-'/ #12%3'#'&A 0'81&' '#-%K%-'/&C'
21821('D +'#' *'/%) C'&B (%*'8'E#'& 3"B' 21821('A
;'C'&B&C'D '(' /1+'F'+ '8,B'&/% ('8% E'8' '&')%/ C'&B
+1&B'+2%) E,/%/% /12'B'% '&')%/ -18*'('E #12%3'#'&A @181#' +1&"&-"-
'B'8 '&')%/ C'&B +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ "&-"# #12%3'#'& 218/%#'E e,2C1#-%H f
(')'+ "#"8'& O,2C1#-%HI&C'P '&')%/ C'&B +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ -18*'('E
#12%3'#'&A 4'('*') 2'%# j 2"8"#&C' '&')%/%/ (%"#"8 (1&B'& "#"8'&C'&B 21821(' "&-"# +'/%&BI+'/%&B E,/%/% -18/12"-A
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
47/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 88
;1+1&-'8'D (')'+ +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ (1&B'& F,8'# "&-"#
#12%3'#'&D /1,8'&B '&')%/ +'" -%('# +'" *'8"/ +1&1&-"#'& "&-"#
/%'E' ('& "&-"# 'E' #12%3'#'& %-" (%2"'-A L'&C' (1&B'& ('/'8
%-" /% '&')%/ 2%/' +1&B1+2'&B#'& '&')%/'&C' "&-"# +1&B*'/%)#'&H,8+")' #12%3'#'& C'&B (%*'8'E#'& /1/"'% (1&B'& -"3"'& #12%3'#'&
C'&B (%%&B%'&A Q"&-"-'& E18'& /1+'F'+ %&%D &%/F'C'D +1+2"'- /%
'&')%/ 218'(' (')'+ E,/%/% 218#1E1&-%&B'& (1&B'& #12%3'#'& C'&B
(%'&')%/%/&C'A Q"&-"-'& /1+'F'+ %-" 3"B' +1+2"'- 2'%#I2"8"#&C'
#%&183' /% '&')%/ -%('# 2%/' (%"#"8 ('8% /1218'E' ,2C1#-%H '&')%/%/ C'&B
(%)'#"#'& ('& E1&B1-'*"'& C'&B (%*'/%)#'&M +1)'%'& /1218'E' 3'"*
'&')%/%/ C'&B (%)'#"#'&&C' +1&B*'/%)#'& H,8+")' C'&B 1H1#-%H "&-"#
+1&F'E'% -"3"'& #12%3'#'& C'&B /"('* (%B'8%/#'&A
.B'8 )12%* +"('* (%E'*'+% ('& (%*'C'-% ,)1* +'*'/%/G'D (,/1&
2%/' +1+218%#'& E18-'&C''& /12'B'% 218%#"-\ O.E' E1821(''& E18'&
C'&B (%-"&-"- ('8% /1,8'&B '*)% +'/'#D #1-%#' (%' 21#183' "&-"# /12"'*
81/-,8'& (1&B'& #1-%#' (%' 21#183' /12'B'% #,&-1/-'& ),+2' +1&")%/
81/1EdPA :)"/-8'/% /18"E' 3"B' 2%/' #%-' ('E'-#'& ('8% 2182'B'% /1#-,8
#1*%("E'& C'&B #%-' -1+"% /1*'8%I*'8%A :-" 2%/' #%-' )%*'- (')'+ D#61'
EEELWLX+,%"#) A,%#"# A,#'&)&) 0,%0* X16&M#*#, -#, A,#'&)&) %1";#-#! X16&M#*#,
-#'#7 X1;&-0!#, /1;#"&5;#"& -& >1"6#.#& A"1#
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
48/209
89 .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
2'B%'& ('8% /12"'* (%/%E)%& %)+"D 3"B' +18"E'#'& /12"'* /1&%AVJ% /%&%D
/1)'%& (%('/'8#'& E'(' +1-,(1 ('& #'%('* %)+%'*D /1,8'&B '&')%/ 3"B' *'8"/
+1&B'&(')#'& %&-"%/% ('& eF%-'I8'/'&C'fD )'C'#&C' /1,8'&B '*)% +'/'#A
01+2')% #1 E18-'&C''& /121)"+&C'D /1,8'&B '*)% +'/'# C'&B/1('&B +1+'/'# "&-"# E1)'&BB'& 81/-,8'& '(')'* /1,8'&B '*)% +'/'#
C'&B +1)'C'&% ,8'&B C'&B +1+2"-"*#'& e81')%-'/f +'/'#'&I&C'D -18)1E'/
('8% F'8' +1&B,)'* ('& 81/1E C'&B (%E'#'% ,)1* /% '*)% +'/'#A ;1+1&-'8'D
/1,8'&B '*)% +'/'# C'&B /1('&B 218"/'*' +1&C"/"& 2"#" +'/'#'& '-'"
+1&C'+E'%#'& E1)'3'8'& (')'+ /12"'* #"8/"/ +1+'/'#D '(')'* /1,8'&B
'*)% +'/'# C'&B +1)'C'&% ,8'&B C'&B +1+2"-"*#'& e%)+"f +1+'/'#&C'D
-18)1E'/ ('8% E18+'/')'*'& 'E'#'* /1/"('*&C'D +181#' +1&F%F%E% *'/%)(1+,&/-8'/% C'&B (%E18'B'#'& ,)1* /% '*)% +1+'/'#A
@(-() 222URU
2."+*#(+/ 7)(./+ 7B*/K/*(+ ")*"B :,3(L(3/ N,)%3,)(
;,C/D(B() E(#/ !,#+A,B*/1 8,#*,)*"
F G$+-$`A) Y2
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
49/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 8:
0,&(%/% C'&B /'&B'- +%8%E 3"B' -183'(% (')'+ '&')%/%/ "&-"#
#12%3'#'& ('& '&')%/%/ -18*'('E #12%3'#'&A 01-%#' +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/
"&-"# #12%3'#'&D /% '&')%/ /1('&B +1)'C'&% ,8'&B C'&B +1+2"-"*#'&
eE8,("#f #12%3'#'& C'&B 1H1#-%HD +1&"8"- #8%-18%' ('8% ,8'&B -18/12"-A;1+1&-'8'D #1-%#' +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ -18*'('E #12%3'#'&D /% '&')%/
/1('&B +1)'C'&% ,8'&B C'&B +1+2"-"*#'& e%)+"f "&-"# +1&B'&')%/%/D
-18+'/"# "&-"# +1+2"'-D #12%3'#'& C'&B 1H1#-%H ('& "1''1A
;1(18*'&'&C'D #')'" #%-' "+E'+'#'& '&')%/%/ /1E18-% /12"'*
)1&/' #'F'+'-'D (')'+ E,/%/% +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ -18*'('E #12%3'#'&D /%
'&')%/ 218#"-'- (1&B'& *') j %#*G') +1+2"'- ('& F'8' +1&BB"&'#'&
)1&/' C'&B -1E'- ('& -18E18F'C' "&-"# #12%3'#'& /1F'8' "+"+A;1+1&-'8'D (')'+ E,/%/% +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ "&-"# #12%3'#'&D /% '&')%/
218#"-'- (1&B'& *') j %#*G') +1&BB"&'#'& )1&/' -18/12"- (1+%
+1&('E'-#'& E'&('&B'& C'&B 31)'/ ('& 318&%*A L'/%) ('8% '&')%/%/
C'&B E18-'+' '(')'* e21&('f )1&/' ('& F'8' E1&BB"&''& C'&B 2'%#D
/1('&B#'& ('8% '&')%/%/ C'&B #1("'D C'&B (%*'8'E#'& '(')'* /1/"'-"
C'&B (%)%*'- /1F'8' -1E'- (1&B'& )1&/' -18/12"-D C'&B +"&B#%& -%('#
'#'& -18)%*'- 3%#' )1&/' C'&B (%B"&'#'& 21821('A =%*'- >#.#, EEELWL
E'0)%"#)& A,#'&) A*%&8&%#) 0,%0* @17#;#7& a1,+71,# X16&M#*#, -#"& &-"# +1&3'(% /1,8'&B '&')%/ C'&B 2'%#D #%-' *'8"/ /1&/%-%H ('&
-'&BB'E -18*'('E E1821(''& -"&-"-'& ('& #12"-"*'& C'&B (%)'C'&%
('8% E,/%/% C'&B (%'+2%) /12'B'% '&')%/A 0'81&'D "&-"# +1+1&"*%
#12"-"*'& -18/12"- +1+18)"#'& E1&(1#'-'& ('& #1'*)%'& C'&B
21821('A@%/')&C'D #1-%#' /'+'I/'+' +1&BB"&'#'& %&/-8"+1& 2+)%5
>1,14&% A,#'9)&) I Z!.D '&')%/ (')'+ E,/%/% +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ "&-"#
#12%3'#'& '#'& +1&BB"&'#'&&C' (1&B'& 218H,#"/ E'(' *'/%) '&')%/%/
C'&B '#"8'- ('& "1''1D /12'2 %-" C'&B (%2"-"*#'& "&-"# +1+2"'-
/12"'* #12%3'#'& C'&B 1H1#-%HA ;1+1&-'8'D '&')%/ C'&B 218'(' (')'+
E,/%/% +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/ -18*'('E #12%3'#'& '#'& +1&BB"&'#'&
%&/-8"+1& C'&B /'+'D -1-'E% 218H,#"/ E'(' (1-%) F'8' E1&BB"&''&&C'A
@%/')&C' "&-"# +1)%*'- 'E'#'* %&/-8"+1& %&% /"('* (%B"&'#'& /1F'8'
21&'8 '-'"#'* Z!. +1+218%#'& *'/%) C'&B 21&'8I21&'8 '#"8'- ('&"1''1D '-'"D 2%/' 3"B'D +1)%*'- 'E'#'* Z!. +1+%)%#% #1)1+'*'&I
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
50/209
8; .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
#1)1+'*'& ('& 'E' C'&B 2%/' (%)'#"#'& "&-"# +1&"-"E #1)1+'*'&
-18/12"-A
>&-"# +1+218%#'& E1+'*'+'& #1E'(' +'*'/%/G'D (,/1& 2%/'
+1+218%#,& F,&-,* +1)')"% %)"/-8'/% #'/"/ 8%%) '&')%/%/ #12%3'#'&A@%/')&C'D +'*'/%/G' 2%/' (%'3'# "&-"#+1)%*'- 1#/E81/% '&')%/%/ ,8'&BI
,8'&B 744 5/''- %-" +'/%* 7:46 >?@ #1-%#' 218(%8% /12'B'% ,8'&B )"'8
('& +1&B,+1&-'8% E8,/1/ R'&F'&B'& >&('&BI"&('&B 01%/-%+1G''&I
R>>0 U,BC'#'8-'A ;1)'&3"-&C'D #%-' 2%/' 2'&(%&B#'& 1#/E81/% -18/12"-
(1&B'& 1#/E81/% ('8% ,8'&BI,8'&B C'&B /'+' #1-%#' +181#' -1)'*
+1&3'(% 2'B%'& ('8% )%&B#'8'& E1+2"'- #12%3'#'& "&-"# #'/"/ R>>0A
Q1&-"&C' (')'+ E,/%/% C'&B #1("' #%-' +1&('E'-% '('&C' #1(1#'-'&1+,/%,&') C'&B %#"- +1G'8&'% 1#/E81/% ('8% ,8'&BI,8'&B 744 >?@D
(%2'&(%&B#'& /121)"+&C' #1-%#' +'/%* 218(%8% /12'B'% ,8'&B )"'8A
0U ;,A/($(/() 0(+(# F()- 0/C"*"LB() %.,L ',%#()- 7)(./+
J,/1& +1&31)'/#'& 2'*G' '&-'8' F,8'# '&')%/%/ "&-"# #12%3'#'& ('&
'&')%/%/ -18*'('E #12%3'#'&D (%/-%&B/% "-'+'&C' -18)1-'# E'(' -"3"'& C'&B
%&B%& (%F'E'% +1)')"% '&')%/%/ #12%3'#'&A b#,. !1"%#7#D '&')%/%/ (%)'#"#'&
"&-"# +1+2'&B"& /12"'* #12%3'#'& C'&B (%'&BB'E 81)1K'& (1&B'&
/%-"'/% #12%3'#'& C'&B (%*'('E%A ;1+1&-'8'D9#,. *1-0#D "&-"# +1+2'&B"&
E1+'*'+'& C'&B )12%* #,+E81*1&/%H -1&-'&B 81')%-' #12%3'#'&A
>&-"# +1+218%#'& B'+2'8'& C'&B )12%* -1&-'&B -"&-"-'&
E18'& C'&B *'8"/ (%)'#,&% /1,8'&B '&')%/ /1/"'% (1&B'& E%)%*'& F,8'#
'&')%/'&C'D (,/1& +1&B'3'# +'*'/%/G' "&-"# +1&F18+'-% Q'21) :::A[A
Q'21) -18/12"- +1+218%#'& (1/#8%E/% 'E' C'&B 2%'/'&C' (%)'#"#'& ,)1*
'&')%/ #1-%#' 218'(' (% E,/%/% '&')%/ "&-"# #12%3'#'& ('& '&')%/ -18*'('E
#12%3'#'&A J')'+ -'21) -18/12"-D (1&B'& +1&BB"&'#'& H,8+")'
_IhIXIL L'8,)( JA ='/G1))D +'*'/%/G' (%'3'# "&-"# +1+'*'+% E,/%/%
('& -"&-"-'& C'&B *'8"/ (%*'('E% ,)1* /1,8'&B '&')%/D /1/"'% (1&B'&
E%)%*'& F,8'# '&')%/%/ C'&B (%)'#"#'&&C'A
J')'+ -'21) %-" '#-%K%-'/ ('& #1E%'G'%'& C'&B (%-"&-"- ('8%
'&')%/ (% +'/%&BI+'/%&B E,/%/% (%(1/#8%E/%#'& +1&"8"- e.E' C'&B
+181#' )'#"#'&dfD e;%'E' C'&B +1)'#"#'&dfD e>&-"# /%'E'k'E' '&')%/%/
(%)'#"#'&dfD e!'B'%+'&' %-" (%)'#"#'&dfD ('& e;'+E'% /13'"* +'&'
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
51/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 8
8(C,. 222USU;"(E#() !%+/+/ 7)(./+ ;,C/D(B()
!%+/+/ 7)(./+
7)(./+/+ ")*"B ;,C/D(B() 7)(./+/+ *,#L(E(A ;,C/D(B()
G#()- ="(# G#()- 0(.(3 G#()- ="(# G#()- 0(.(3
;9284927
^+J
E))01 )1#"$;'-'" &))01 4&'%"#%&+,R
@1)'#"#'& '#/% &C'-'
C'&B -%('# #1)"'8
('8% #1G1&'&B'&&C'D
F'8'&C' (1&B'& /12'-'/
+1&BB"&'#'& /"+218('C'
C'&B (%+%)%#%D '-'"M
@1&C%/%E#'& #1 (')'+
E18-1+"'& %&H,8+') '-'"
,1%J+"*&,.A
@1+21&-"# 2'/%/ ("#"&B'&D
#,&/,)%('/% /1F'8' %&H,8+')D
+1&B%&%/%'/% 'B1&('
/1F'8' H8,&-') (1&B'&
,-,8%-'/ #12%3'#'&A @%/')D
+1)')"% E18-1+"'& H,8+')
(1&B'& ,-,8%-'/ #12%3'#'&D
+1&BB"&'#'& ,1%J+"*&,.D
E1G'F'&''& +1(%' '-'"E"&
'#/% +'//'
L'&C' /12'-'/ +1&F'8%
%&H,8+'/% C'&B (%2"-"*#'&A
Z'8'&C'D +1&B%(1&-%H%#'/%
(,#"+1&I(,#"+1&D
'-'"E"& &,-")1&/% #1B%'-'&
@1&B'&')%/' #1+"(%'&
(%E"2)%#'/%#'& (% 2182'B'%
+1(%' +'//'D 3"8&')D '-'"E"&
#'3%'& %)+%'* )'%&&C'D
+1&B"-'+'#'& #1(')'+'&
'&')%/'
D+G;#%
BI%1,%
@1)'#/'&'#'& 8'&F'&B'&
#1 (')'+ E8,/1/ C'&B
)12%* #,%- 5H,8+")'/%D
%+E)1+1&-'/% ('& 1K')"'/%6D
+1+E1&B'8"*% E1+2"'-'&
('& ('+E'# #12%3'#'&
@1&BB')'&B #1/1E'#'-'&D
+1+E1&B'8"*% E1+2"'-'&
('& ('+E'# #12%3'#'&
31#",&,.P 18#'0#%&+, 31#",&,.P 18#'0#%&+,
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
54/209
9?
.+*/!-!-012!3*4*+
#$2/!4
8(C,. 222UYU:(*#/B+ ;(A(+/*(+ 0/#/ 7)(./+
D&!1 A,#'&) A*%+"b#,. 71,M#-& &,%&
-+"+,.#, 7+%&8#)&
/%#,-#"
*1)0*)1)#, /0761"
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
55/209
#$%&')*+,'-'
96
Z/#(+$(+*($()
UB,%"1!"1,10"V
D;&,*5%#,*
=%-2'&B &,)%&%0)&
01/1+E'-'&
"&-"#
+1&1)"/"8%
E%)%*'&IE%)%*'&
#12%3'#'& 5!+'&$9
!"141"1,$1)V
J%-18%+'
/12'B'%
#12%3'#'&I
#12%3'#'&
C'&B ('E'- (%
%+E)1+1&-'I
/%#'& C'&B
('E'-
+1+2'G''#%2'- +'&H''-
41+'*'+'&
!'0)#1'*)%'&
#,+"&%#'/%
('&
#,,8(%&'/%
418/E1#-%H
/1%+2'&B
\ 3'&B#'
E'&3'&B ('&
3'&B#' E1&(1#
4,)%-%/ ('&
'&')%-%/\
'&')%/%/ /12'B'%
-"3"'& "&-"#
+1+E1&B'8"*%
#12%3'#'&
.8B"+1& /12"'*
#12%3'#'&=%*'-
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
56/209
97 .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
>&-"# )12%* +1+E1831)'/ -%E,),B% '&')%/D 218('/'8#'& E%)%*'&
E,/%/%&C'D /18-' #,&/1#"1&/% C'&B (%-%+2")#'& ,)1* E%)%*'& -18/12"-D
(,/1& +1&B'3'# +'*'/%/G' "&-"# +1+2'&(%&B#'& -%E,),B% '&')%/
#12%3'#'& (')'+ Q'21) :::A[AD (1&B'& -%E,),B% C'&B (%2'&B"& .8&,)(7A @1)-/&18 (')'+ 8(C,. 222UYU :(*#/B+ ;(A(+/*(+ 0/#/ 7)(./+A
J,/1& +1&31)'/#'& 2'*G' -%E,),B% C'&B (%B"&'#'& (')'+ Q'21) :::Aa
'(')'* -%E,),B% .8&,)( 7A @1)-/&18A ;1/"&BB"*&C'D /1)'%& -%E,),B%
C'&B (%2'&B"& ,)1* @1)-/&18 +'/%* 2'&C'# -%E,),B% C'&B )'%&D
/1*%&BB' +'*'/%/G' -%('# E18)" +18'/' F'&BB"&B 3%#' +181#' %&B%&
+1&BB"&'#'& -%E,),B% C'&B )'%&A J')'+ +1+2'&B"& -%E,),B%&C'D
@1)-/&18 -1)'* +1)'#"#'& E1&1)%-%'& (1&B'& +1&B'+2%) /'+E1) XX`
'&')%/ #12%3'#'&A J')'+ E1&1)%-%'&&C' -18/12"-D #'E'/%-'/ (%8% '&')%/
(%E%)'* +1&3'(% 1+E'- #'-1B,8% C'&B +18"3"# E'(' &%)'% ('& F'8'
#183' +181#' (')'+ +1)'#"#'& '&')%/'A[0'-1B,8% E1+%)'*'& (%2"'-
218('/'8 E'(' %&(%#'-,8 O#1-18'+E%)'& E,)%-%#P ('& O#1-18'+E%)'&
'&')%/'PA L'/%) E1+%)'*'& -18/12"- '(')'* 1+E'- #'8'#-18 '&')%/
218('/'8#'& )*&'' C'&B (%+%)%#%D C'%-" h%8'"/'*'G'& 5B,%1"!"1,10"6D
Q1#&%/%kQ"#'&BD 4,)%-%/% /18-' .&')%/ e;,# Q'*"f 5
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
57/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 98
C'&B '#'& +1&(1&B'8 #'81&' '&')%/ %&% )12%* +1)%*'- #1E1&-%&B'& E"2)%#
/12'B'% #)%1& "-'+'&C'A 012'&C'#'& -%E1 %&% '(')'* E'8' '*)% '&')%/%/
#12%3'#'& C'&B 218'/') ('8% #')'&B'& '#'(1+%/% '-'"E"& 2%8,#8'-A
.&')%/%/ '(')'* #1#"'/''&D 21B%-")'* #%8'I#%8' 7+%%+/1,8'&B '&')%/G%8'"/'*'G'&A .&')%/ 31&%/ %&% E'*'+ 21&'8 2'*G'!+'&$9 7#*&,.(%E1&"*%
,)1* 2'&C'# '#-,8 21/'8D +'#' +181#' +1&B1+2'&B#'& #"'/'&C' /1&(%8%
"&-"# +1+'&H''-#'& /1+"' E1&B'8"*A J%' +1&C'('8% #1#"'-'&&C'D
C'%-" +1+2"'- #12%3'#'& (1&B'& +1+E1&B'8"*% #1E"-"/'&A .&')%/ %&%
)12%* +1&1+E'-#'& (%8% /12'B'% %;&,*5%;#,*#1E1&-%&B'& E"2)%#A .&')%/
31&%/ %&% 8'3%& +1+2'&B"& -'#-%#D 2'%# (% (')'+ +'"E"& (% )"'8 2%8,#8'/%A
;%&B#'-&C'D /1,8'&B '&')%/ 1,%"1!"1,10" '(')'* '&')%/ C'&B e%(1')f #'81&'-%('# *'&C' +'*%8 +1)'#"#'& '&')%/' #12%3'#'&D -'E% /1F'8' (%'+I(%'+
3"B' E'&('% (')'+ +1+2'&B"& #1#"'-'& E,)%-%#A
RU 8,B)/+/
;1,8'&B -1#&%/% '(')'* E1&1)%-% '#'(1+%/ I/1,8'&B %&-1)1#-"')I
(')'+ '81' 2%8,#8'/%A !'C'&B#'& ,8'&B C'&B (%#1)%)%&B% #,+E"-18D
+,(1)I+,(1) -1,8%D /-'-%/-%#'D ('& )'%&I)'%& -1-'E% /1E18-% ")'- (')'+
#1E,+E,&BA J%' *'&C' 218#1E1&-%&B'& (1&B'& 8%/1- '-'" -%&('#'&
C'&B 218*"2"&B'& (1&B'& '&')%/' #12%3'#'&A J%' -'*" E,)%-%# -'E%
-%('# 2'&C'#D #'81&' E,)%-%# '(')'* /1/"'-" C'&B )'%& (% )"'8 #12%3'#'&A
J%' +1&18'E#'& /-'&('8 "&-"# (%8%&C' /1&(%8%D /1*%&BB' 7+%%+I&C' N'16&;
6#&* 71,M#-& 61,#" -#"&!#-# %1!#% J#*%0OA Q%E1 %&% 2%'/'&C' '(')'* E'8'
'#'(1+%/% ('& E1&1)%-% C'&B (%#,&-8'# ,)1* 2%8, E1+18%&-'* -18-1&-"A
@,-%K'/% "-'+' ('8% '&')%/ -%E1 %&% '(')'* #1/1+E'-'&&C' "&-"#
+1)'#"#'& 8%/1- C'&B 218*"2"&B'& (1&B'& #12%3'#'& (')'+ /12"'*
)%&B#"&B'& E1+2"'-'& #12%3'#'& 5!+'&$9 7#*&,.VL ;1*%&BB' #12'&C'#'&
('8% E'8' -1#&%/% %&% '(')'* E'8' %&-1)1#-"') C'&B 218'(' (% +1&'8'
B'(%&BD (1&B'& +1&3'(% E1&B'+'- ('& -%('# -18)%2'- (')'+ !+'&$9
7#*&,.L !'B%&C' '#"8'/% E1&B'+'-'& ('& E1&31)'/'& )12%* E1&-%&B
('8%E'(' E8,/1/.+#'I&C' #12%3'#'&A
;1,8'&B -1#&%/% +'+E" +1&3'(% B"('&B ('-'D #'81&'
#1+'+E"'&&C' +1&B,)'* 218'B'+ ('-' /-'-%/-%#D J+"*);11%D )'E,8'&
E1+18%&-'*D ('& /1+'F'+&C'A ;1*%&BB' +181#' F1&(18"&B "&-"#
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
58/209
99 .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
+1&1+E'-#'& '&')%/' /12'B'% ')'- "&-"# +1&1+"#'& #"&F% (')'+
+1+'*'+% +'/')'* #12%3'#'& '-'" /,)"/% #12%3'#'&A ;"2/-'&/% ('8%
#12%3'#'& )12%* +1&'8%# 2'B% +181#' ('8%E'(' E8,/1/ (%(')'+&C'A
SU !%./*/+/
@1/#% +1&C'('8% (%8%&C' 2"#'& 2%8,#8'-D /1,8'&B '&')%/ E,)%-%/%
)12%* 218E%#%8 #'# 2%8,#8'- ('8%E'(' /1,8'&B '&')%/A ;1,8'&B '&')%/
E,)%-%/% )12%* +1+E18*'-%#'& (%+'&' (%' ("("# ('& #1E'(' /%'E'
(%' 21#183'AJ%' )12%* #*'G'-%8 E1&%)'%'& C'&B 2"8"# E'(' #%&183'
E1)'C'&'&&C' ('8%E'(' #"')%-'/ '&')%/'&C'A .-8%2"- #'&-,8 /1,8'&B
'&')%/ E,)%-%/% )12%* +1&,&3,)#'& /%+2,) C'&B +1&"&3"##'& (%8%&C'/12'B'% /1,8'&B E,)%-%/% ('8%E'(' /12'B'% B"('&B ('-'A @1/#% +181#'
+1&C'('8% (%8%&C' B1&18')%/D &'+"& +181#' -1-'E +1)%*'- (%8%&C'
21821('A Q%E1 %&% 2%'/'&C' '(')'* E'8' E,)%-%/%A
.&')%/%/ #12%3'#'& #1)%*'-'& /1E18-% +1&'G'8#'& #1/1+E'-'& 2'B%
E,)%-%/% "&-"# +1+E18)"'/ G'G'/'& (%8%&C'A ;1E18-% *')&C' 81#'C'/'
/,/%')D+181#' +1)%*'- E1&B')'+'& /12'B'% E18)"'/'& #1/1+E'-'&
(')'+ 8'&'* /,/%') ('& +1+2'&-" +181#' +1+E1)'3'8% -1&-'&B
21218'E' '#-%K%-'/ E1+218('C''& #,+"&%-'/A 01E18F'C''& (%8%
('8% '&')%/ E,)%-%/% '(')'* #1C'#%&'& '#'& #1+'+E"'&&C' +18"2'*
B'B'/'& +1&3'(% #1&C'-''&A @181#' E18F'C' 2'*G' (%8%&C' +'+E"
+1&-8'&/H,8+'/% E1&1)%-%'& %)+" /,/%') #1 (')'+ #12%3'#'& E"2)%#A
@181#' %&B%& 218'(' (%(')'+ #1B%'-'& #12%3'#'& %-" /1&(%8% ('&
21#183' (%(')'+&C'A .#%2'-&C' (%' )12%* +1&B"-'+'#'& 'B1&(' #)%1&
('8%E'(' 'B1&('&C' /1&(%8%A
YU ['%B 8(L"\ O!"1%1,-1"Q
0%8'&C' "&-"# -%E1 '&')%/ /1E18-% %&% -%('# E18)" #%-' 2'*'/ /1F'8'
)12%* +1&(1-%) #'81&' #,&-8%2"/%&C' E'(' '&')%/' #12%3'#'& /'&B'-)'*
/1(%#%-A N'+"& (1+%#%'&D +"&B#%& -%E1 %&%)'* C'&B E')%&B 2'&C'#
('& E')%&B +"('* #%-' -1+"#'&A 0%-' ('E'- +1&1+"#'&&C' *'+E%8
(%/1-%'E 3')'&D G'8"&BD F'HoD ('& (%+'&'E"& -1&-'&B B,/%EIB,/%E E,)%-%#
(%2%F'8'#'&A .&')%/' E'8'!"1%1,-1"-%('# ('E'- (%E18-'&BB"&B3'G'2#'&/1#')%B"/ -%('# +1+%)%#% 1H1# C'&B E,)%-%/A N'+"& 3'&B'& /')'*D 2%'/'&C'
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
59/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 9:
E'8'!"1%1,-1"E")' C'&B +'+E" +1&C12'8#'& B,/%E #12%3'#'& +1&3'(%
E18*'-%'&D C'&B /'&B'- +"&B#%& '#'& (%81/E,&/ /1F'8' /18%"/ ,)1* E'8'
-1#&%/%D E,)%-%/% +'"E"& 1,%1"!"1,10"A
;1#')% )'B% (,/1& +1&B%&B'-#'& +'*'/%/G' 2'*G' #'-1B,8%/'/%(%'-'/ *'&C')'* /121&-"# E1&C'8%&B'&A0')'" #%-' F18+'-%D .8&,)( 7A
@1)-/&18 +1+2'&B"& -%E,),B%I&C' *'&C' (1&B'& +1&BB"&'#'& ("'
K'8%'21) '&')%/'D C'%-" #1+'+E"'& '&')%/' ('& #1-8'+E%)'& E,)%-%#&C'A
7%#' #%-' +'" +1)'#"#'& %&K1/-%B'/% )'%& C'&B )12%* /18%"/D #%-'E"& ('E'-
+1&18'E#'& /-'&('8 &%)'% C'&B '#'& #%-' "#"8A J'8% H1&,+1&' -18/12"-D
#%-' /1+'#%& /'('8 ('& +1&B'#"% 2'*G' /1-%'E '&')%/ +1+%)%#% /-'&('8
&%)'% C'&B 21821('A!'B'%+'&' (1&B'& #,&-1#/ :&(,&1/%'d Q1&-" #%-' +1+%)%#% -%&B#'-
8'/%,&')%-'/ 21821(' ('& 3"/-8" E18)" +1+'/"##'& E18'&B#'- '&')%/'
C'&B 21821(' E")'A !,)1* 3'(% #%-' -%('# E18)" +1&B"#"8 #1/18%"/'&
/12"'* #12%3'#'& ('8% #1(')'+'& &')'8 E%#%8 !+'&$9 7#*1"D +1)'%'&
/1218'E' #"'- /1,8'&B O%/-8%P '-'"D +"&B#%& 3"B' OE1&'/1*'- /E%8%-"')P
/1,8'&B E1+2"'- #12%3'#'& +1+E1&B'8"*%&C'A .8-%&C'D +'/%* -182"#'
)12'8 2'B% #%-' "&-"# +1&F'8% /1&(%8% #8%-18%' 1-%#' ('& &%)'% C'&B -1E'-(%B"&'#'& (% :&(,&1/%'A
4U !,)"-(+()
J% '#*%8 E18-1+"'& %&%D +'*'/%/G' C'&B -1)'* (%'3'# "&-"#
+1&B1&') -%E,),B% '&')%/ +1&"8"- #'E'/%-'/ +181#'A J%+%&-' "&-"#
+")'% +1+E18-%+2'&B#'& E,/%/% ('& F,8'# '&')%/%/ 'E' C'&B '#'&
(%E%)%*&C' (')'+ +1)'#"#'& )'-%*'& '&')%/%/ #12%3'#'& (% /1B+1&
#1("' ('8% E18#")%'*'& %&%A >&-"# +1&B'/'* #1E1#''& +'*'/%/G'
(')'+ +1)'#"#'&!+)&%&+,&,.D +'*'/%/G' (%+%&-' "&-"#\
-18/12"-M
('8% E,/%/% C'&B (%E%)%*&C' -18/12"-A ;12'B'% %)"/-8'/%D +'*'/%/G'
2%/' +18"3"# E'(' 8(C,. 222U]U @/(+ ;L(+ 8/A, 7)(./+
;,C/D(B()M
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
60/209
9; .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
8(C,. 222U]U @/(+ ;L(+ 8/A, 7)(./+ ;,C/D(B()
8/*/B !/D(B ;,W,)E,#")-() 0\ &%K18/%-C 481//
@1)-/&18D .8&,)( 7D 5Xcb`6D 10"1#0$"#$9D =.\
>&%K18/%-C ,H Z')%H,8&%' 481//
;-,&1D J12,8'*D 5Xccb6D
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
61/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 9&-"# %-"D /1/% E18-1+"'& :T %&% (%8'&F'&B "&-"# +1&B'3'#
+'*'/%/G' +1&B1&') ('& 218)'-%* +1+2'&B"& #18'&B#' '&')%/' #12%3'#'&
218('/'8#'& E%)%*'& E,/%/% ('& F,8'# '&')%/%/ +'/%&BI+'/%&BA
J,/1& +1&B'G')% #")%'* %&% (1&B'& +1&B%&B'-#'& +'*'/%/G'2'*G' #12%3'#'& '(')'* 81')%-'/ C'&B #,+E)1#/ ('& 218/%H'-
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
62/209
9= .+*/!-!- 012!3*4*+ #$2/!4
+")-%(%+1&/%,&')A 0,+E)1#/%-'/ %&% *'8"/ (%*'('E% (1&B'& 2'%# ,)1*
/1,8'&B '&')%/A J'& /12'B'% /1,8'&B '&')%/D -"B'/ "-'+' C'&B *'8"/
(%)'#"#'& '(')'* +1&1)''* ('& +1&"'&B#'& #,+E)1#/%-'/ -1/12"-
(')'+ E'E'8'& C'&B /1(18*'&' /1*%&BB' +"('* (%E'*'+%AX
J')'+ +1&C1(18*'&'#'& #,+E)1#/%-'/ 81')%-'/D /18%&B#')% /1,8'&B
'&')%/ +1&BB"&'#'& ')'- 2'&-"A 018'&B#' '&')%/%/ +18"E'#'& ')'-
2'&-" 2'B% /1,8'&B '&')%/ #12%3'#'&AV.)'- 2'&-" %&% 2%/' 218+'F'+I
+'F'+A Q1,8% 2%/' (%E'*'+% /12'B'% /"'-" ')'- 2'&-" "&-"# +1+'*'+%
81')%-'/A N'+"&D -%('# 218'8-% 2'*G' E,/-")'-IE,/-")'- C'&B -%('#
+1&F'E'% /-'-"/ /12'B'% -1,8% -%('# 2%/' (%B"&'#'& /12'B'% ')'- 2'&-"
"&-"# +1)'#"#'& '&')%/%/A4,/-")'-IE,/-")'- -18/12"- 2%'/'&C' (%#1&')(1&B'& &'+' 7+-1'('&4"#71J+"*A[
J,/1& +1+'E'8#'& /1F'8' /%&B#'- E1821(''& '&-'8' -1,8%D +,(1)
('& 4"#71J+"*A >&-"# %-" (,/1& 2%/' +1&B'F" E'(' E'E'8'& ^)%&,8
-
7/26/2019 Analisis Kebijakan Publik_lay Out
63/209
#$%&' )*+,'-' 9>
/E1/%H%# -18#'%- /1E18'&B#'- E'8'+1-18 ('& K'8%'21) -18-1&-" /1F'8'
/E1/%H%#Aa
;1-1)'* +1+'E'8#'& E1821(''& #1-%B' #,&/1E -18/12"-D (,/1&
+1)'#"#'& #)'8%H%#'/% 'E' C'&B (%+'#/"( (1&B'& %/-%)'* e+,(1)f (')'+
E18#")%'*'& %&%A @,(1) (')'+ E18#")%'*'& %&% )12%* (%+'#&'% /12'B'%
4"#71J+"*A 0)'8%H%#'/% %&% E1&-%&B (%)'#"#'& +1&B%&B'-D ('8% E18#")%'*'&
%&%D +'*'/%/G' (%*'8'E#'& 2%/' +1+2'&B"& +,(1)&C' /1&(%8%A
@U :,3A,#B,)(.B() :%E