&l~~~~~~u~~~~~~~~u~~~j~~~~~imw~~~~~~~m~o{g~~~i~~~...
TRANSCRIPT
do~duieci7i7 ~ J T a y n ~ ~ u w Y n ~ (umn7wcioci79 drinuo7~ii~~mneiiqn'u
~ d m ~ u ~ w & n ~ ~ ? u ~ u o e u d a : n u ~ ~ ~ v n u n c ~ u c c o ~ ~ ~ i o u i ~ o r ~ ~ ~ n 6sd?aq~ng~uiulnu.s $a& ~~oi~~iuu~cnunuwunaiuf~1i~$i~uI]T""11q~~ion~u jmcknuuscariumn f i e ~ a h u
* ,: d d aiuna'uldii i iR iu~?oi i i ln~ua~n~auni i udiary7.v ng~uiulnulu.rruuGwwm
QA~ihmfvoclnu & L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U ~ ~ " ~ J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I M W ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M " ~ O { G ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~
n:iunniiiwaciui~ d~~rv~eiini)~lCnd~~v~diuauu~n~u~~dlu.ii~a~u~ui;cil~~Y'u
n a ~ u ~ ? n m i n i o n a e ~ c ~ ~ ~ ~ v ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ " u c l ~ ~ u o ~ ~ n ~ ~ u ' n d a ~ a $ m r i u m n na~iluii2u
~ i e d ~ " i I ~ n 7 w ~ ~ ' w . & M " ~ o ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ " I I Q ~ ~ J H ~ ~ ] ~ ~ ~ w ~ ? ' ~ w ~ o L ~ ~ ~ ~ w ~ ~ I ~ (Socrates) . ~w a h (Plato) .... tiouuifiejuaon (Locke), 3 ~ 8 (J.S. Mill) M~ornhts (K. Marx) unriJ
i~ inaiuGad~qi i i l ty ty7 ' lnulKCun~~~d t ~ n ~ n ~ v i c u n c f i c n a i u t c ~ n ~ ~ k c ~ u u i u ~ ~
uiuuocliiilqg~mriumnlu~~in7si~ni~un7~8nu7d~~uaruu, ni~Jst2n$d3:~7n
ia7ni.i ~ ~ o u a c i u ~ i i u u n ~ e d i ~ ~ ~ q ~ ~ n a i u 6 ~ ~ i c 7 i ~ u ~ u u i n 6 n e ~ c ~ ~ c i i n i u d o n ~ ~
6 i s e o ~ u a e ~ ~ d ~ 0 u n a ~ u ~ ~ n ~ ~ l u11Arb(7w uoo~nu!dimrlunv7ln ~ u ~ d n (naiunu)
~n1r~uduuhiid~t~a~wcPIa'"~i]d~dn~~wu~~dn5"ce~'c~~u "nuiu" ou8c "hu.' (de~de
~ J ~ o u d m i u n d s t ~ n ~ d d W.R. 2482) l i ~nudnn~ds7a$~c ln@~.dus l r~uo ln l~
inmn27uiinnitori ic~~dC~~au uulji luna7uiln111~~40~711 ( L % J R ~ ~ u ? ~ ) ~iaud 0. a 60,
o7airnfi~niwsi~7 voc~ss~iwau~~nwru~nr]a~a~uicw~::n~6~~o~um~wsinuni
uica1Id~ilu~aiiouor'nda~n~a~a~~ft~d3ri~~i~i~Cnfimi~~
~ ' ) n ~ i u ~ ~ n i n u c ~ ~ m u n ~ ~ s ~ ~ r r ~ ~ p i i o n i ~ o ~ u o 6 m ~ i ~ d r ~ u n s : r r ~ n ' R u n ~ ~ P s ~ ~ d d n n D ~ ~ r ~ ~ ~ ~ c f o u ~ r$u~luff'~nulnurreid~6u~li ~ U S : G U I J I I ~ ~ R R ~ : L L I ~ U ~ ~ U L Q ~ ( I : ~ U & Q I U -
?mmnnssu oiiu~iqmainnssu n ~ i u r d ~ u u u d ~ ~ ~ u s ~ m r ? . ~ p l 0 ~ f ~ n u ~ ~ ~ : r n n l u ' 1 ~ d o i i ~ ui7~unns:nuoliu~u 16uya6~nrrdnnrrun~ry LAU~IUIO~?U(IU ijlm~137~163~njun ~ ~ ~ i n i ~ ? t m ~ o i W i ~ d u d ~ ~ q t t ~ z n i s l ~ ~ ~ i o ~ m (Nostalgia) i i n ~ i u r i l u n i ~ o o n n ~ ~ u n ~ n i s u ~ v i l ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ ~ U f ~ ~ i ~ i ~ ~ ~ r i ~ 0 6 ~ ~ J r ~ u ~ d i r ~ ~ n i f a ~ n ~ ~ m m n n s s u d r ~ o ~ ~ ' l u ~ ~ n u q m r i ~ n m q Alvin Toffler. ~ I W R k~3ssru rid^). "ouinms:~nu<ry", (nljmw, iiUln~uWCrru~~11i. 2534). nt j i 109- 1 1 o .
f i f i w o d 6 1 h d5 (LLdR~idf:kfi~) q y i (udaiin?iu$ d i d i a q j i ~ ~ t t d ~ ~ $ ~
~ i l u n ~ i u ~ ~ u n i : ~ ~ ? ~ $tnsrr7uri1~-tii : 66iYqryi9q ~ u k - a i u n u i u ~ l u i i n7iufyiQ.
n?iu.rouf, n-riuqu, n-diuaaln ciou~dxuim 8-9 fJ riouiin15~d~auud~~nir,
dnn5ac vc... 2475 ~ ~ I . i j i ~ i ~ a i ( i i u~~ispivl i: U I I ~ ~ U R ~ Y Y ~ Y ~ ~ ~ U W O ~ I ~ ~ T ~ Q G ~ nal io~nsaniu n1n~~d~n~iunuiu~~u~~uu61niwio'dnqw (Philosophy) ($do~u~l
2493 LLR:: 2525) nuisiid ' ~ i s 1 ~ ? 6 ~ u ~ ~ n ~ ~ v i d n 7 i u f ~ ~ n z n ~ i u o f d ~ ~ ( ~ ~I~LJ?UYL+%U
n?oriiunoaci~d (naiunuuo~-jl) n ~ i a l n l o u r ~ u d ~ u L~ULH~IM'~I 6 6 ~ ~ y i w w Yuniuaiu
nidn?~u~nuadnr?umn~"uLL9iu"Mu?. .b+~nuunu?uIciu~8rrd\d~ddsd *nrinn7iuRa d u a n ~ ~ ~ u v i ~ i Y r y y i ~ u ~ ~ ~ m a 1 ~ 2 ~ 1 ~ w " v r d ~ ~ ~ uinniirt~i luifotusc "Sryry~" 1750
s6n7iui~dj99 U aiun7iun~iunLJ ~~rrb) n 7 ~ ~ i a u d riiuynrniajlny 16~n u~siiIfin5iu
ii~7iiGauiu'uny? ~ J L ~ ~ U G ~ ~ R C ~ L ~ ~ B U M I I ~ ~ ~ U L ; U ri~nu6aniuni.rriini 6dd%ryiw OI w n
uil36u Philosophy ~duu"u 8, ?i??n$ ~nin~ai7u~uuud7 w i n ~ ~ ~ ~ d ~ d n i i W " u ~ n ~ l
n i5~oi Philosophy uiuiyq~tilu~~~~%~iu"uLiluIn'l?l r i i ~ ~ ~ s i ~ u u t r o u i u ~ ~ u ~ n 2 i u
~ a u o ~ d ~ ~ o e i i ~ ~ r j d ~ ~ n i n n ~ i u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 1 0 i ~ n u ~ ~ ) dYr
I u n ~ i u ~ n l o u h u o ~ n 1 5 b t ~ ~ n ~ i u y \ u i u ~ ~ u u n~~~u'aeii~ni7uu o~Gui~0d"un~iu <era *'I %:
n u l o ~ o ~ ~ o ~ ~ i j S ~ ~ i n 4 i u n ' u u ~ n u ~ r ~ u f i d n a i u u n n d i ~ u o ~ ! n u u ~ b v i d n i ~ d dYa u n?iu$i?oiol: ~uaiur~unisn%usun?~uji iiii "diayi" uodfiutiiu ( h ~ n q n ) I s d a d
n 7 1 u ~ n ~ a ~ ~ ~ i n n d n ~ a ~ 6 ~ 4 1 i n ~ d b t ~ 1 (n~iugniun k ~dsi;un-riua~iillurj?) h u
otiillfl Philosophy ii **nBrnBilzgP via ~ ~ i l e i i d c n i ~ ~ i ~ ? ~ ~ m n j i ( ~ ) hijnaiuwuiu
nd i~c i l iq *6n.rRu7P H ~ O wn-i3~urig lwni~Ri (~nqrn ~ J C ~ ~ - ~ I ~ ~ ~ U I I U ~ ' Y I ? ~ I ~ ~ J ' U
lunruldiiundsc6dnwi 6wnSi dri~unlw3o$'wii ~Ihqi~~ u r n ) riow
Jqryi~qonaiufii<~ fiu f6d~vqi" (Philosophy) lunaiunuiuuoe b*nfln800rpP nro
b ' n i ~ ~ u z f f n ~ r i x ~ I ~ ~ 1 l 6 6 i r n o d i daeu ~ J ~ ~ ' " ~ ~ * I ~ U L L U P J Philosophy u ocnr?winld
Id i ; twnuino~n'~~65nnic~~~~~~uad$iz?'~mn 91 a a r l d l d n ~ i u $ ~ b ~ ~ n ~ c l d n i i g i i
3ryqiIu~wocn:iuoandij^a~~$1u i ~ u a ~ ~ ~ u i m i c n i i ~ ~ i i ~ ~ ~ rinrn~u~&l6tied?u
n~ i lyq i&q 91 i#iu~lu&nulnu~nnoindc d h ~ i ~ u n ~ i u v u i u v o d ~ h i l d s o ~ h ) , d -d6nfia%~r' v!o b ~ 3 ~ w P o~ni~dnaiu~~ed~d~dbnudandiu~u&nu~nu ua:nin
r ~ i ~ s n " u ~ s ~ o l ~ x l d i ~ i ~ i ~ u i ~ u w ' ~ e ~ ~ x i u i n i i ~ ~ ) :
(')ynrnni~iin?. w y n a ~ i ~ n " Y n u ~ r i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l n u Z u ~ ~ i ~ ~ , (1Jioisum.r. ~ f l 1 4, au'ud 3 wqwninu - ~?UIUU, 2530), H& 147
(')f in' W U U U S ~ ~ . " f in ' vc~uu~dn*u&ft~~hu~, thduh nth r 7- ie: Unnzesh Mishra, 'History of Indian
Philosophy'. 1969
(B)60~~Gu+i'u, ndi 4 - ,
' 4 LW 201 (S)
I 3 r
~ins0uiulunnnuzomnt7"~mn~~n-Sjia usm ouiusioiiu yulJ'?.n'1116 yn~cii ,*& 2' viib ~ u ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ : M R I V I ~ ~ L ~ U $ ~ ~ R ~ J H U ~ i ~ r y i ~ ~ o u r i a s i ? ~ u I ~ u y n ~ ~ n u lu
iwuar~uuatauynnii un:qn~:&~&uo~nu~dun'~ ri?u~o~iidi;aqidria$~#uu"uar
~iludinqi~u3:n'LI "nnnu:" n3otrCu d*ilryryl" n~~ilu"ond~r~6unup7:~"os~di~win
1
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ u i u ~ ~ ~ n d d o ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ f l u n ? i u ~ a i n m i e u o ~ n ~ . r u d a n ? ~ u ~ u ~ u ttarnil ' d d dnngkuo~kn~sun i i "dinryi" (~riiio:8niionnu~ui~~m) lwknulna nnuo3c
uAin~.runnn?iunuiouoJin diary1 l~i i ludo~ "5lyryi" uuun:iwoon aa: "nhn
ynnaiaui, uoie:. l?r~Gn-., mduu:. lent, iiuidm ~t+:ranium~('~) RITIYBJ
d inryimdi~munL?~l ld~c~w'~u~u"uu~o~nn~iu 46&ui~9' mtn~iuRm ~~~zdie$Ga
unron - 6 Ilru~pros+nlmruu~y~upu .8 L IILNHN~ )(l(.)rpHuoNugaWeplebHnuHg
r~un~~nyinou~o~bbI;'gbn~y~u;u~nul ~ugnro:un~r$c~amn~ba;puuskng1
nyma_ron~ba~v~~ yn~yn~o~i~,nnua~~~ n~rngn~~~oinu~uoon~:bu~~~~~ba&p .8
do?iRiRnfn3iu~ol11oJm:?'~mnb"so~11a~d?T~ib~~:Ln2?nUi (Theology) Cnqnuun
ni.i$oi.rruiaanoin& u n ~ ~ u u i ~ q n u i ~ ~ $ u ~ d u l u y n n a i ~ (Middle Ages) $n%w -
Cn~ui~ilulrr~lu<~nulu~ru::$~~a::%~~i~aa'n~~u~mm:?'uoanil:d~~ddo rn7inui(l6)
aLnR (Thales) f l6?unisunrio~l$~i l wfimi~a~da'"~~qim:?'umn <LI ~ g u n u ~ n n 7 4
(")R.T. Blackwood & A.L. Hennnn (Eds), 'Probbms in Philosophy : West and East'. (Prentice - Hall. Inc, le75), PP. 3. 7
(")E.w.F, Tomlin, 'The Eastern Philosophers : an introduction' Op.cit., P. 21
(1T)iim7 L R ~ S ^ R W ~ (qlrda), 1 ' d % ~ i 8 ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d * t , (ri7Cn~uw"luiauinq0v, 2520). HJI 5 O U I J ~
~ W 1 ~ 1 ~ ~ 7 f i ~ d d f ; a ~ i W : ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ d r ) n ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 ~ ~ ~ ~ n ' l ~ 8 J ~ ~ ~ 2 ~ ~ d ~ H ~ Q ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d l l ~ \ ~ O i 9 ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ ~ l l ~ ~ 2 l ~ ~ f l H ~ ~ ~ ~
~dQiJinrrliund~wmnosk (Pythagoras : 570-497 BC) ~ n d ~ r y i n ~ n ~ u r ) ~ i \ d ? u n i ~ u n u ~ ~ ~ i l u p l l u ~ iuourioa *41?tiuvi~nirn?olfiu** ~ r ~ ~ i ~ u n ~ d ~ u 3 r ~ a n ~ i u n ~ m ~ u i i 6*Cnd%qi** (~i~luw~:rrrtsnuinsn~d (ds:ys
ayuiqln). udhry in in l~ntu" , g ? d t t h , ndi 27) ~ n ~ r u : ' ~ a ~ "d?vryi" I U L ~ U U ~ U C U U O ~ \ W ~ P I R ~ ? U L ~ U ~ R J ~ ~ ~ ~
unndi~nird?vry1~~0121unu7ulla~ "gryryi" ~ ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ ~ d u n ' j d l < n i n i ~ u i u R i
(")i~d l(ryr$a. 6zlisryi3uriiuv*. (ola~nwr : h l i n G u h ~ n u a . 2522). MJI GJoliiirnniinnnur & n a i ~ u s n o i i ~ a i n ~ i ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ 1 ~ 1 1 1 6 m n " ~ ~ 0 i i ~S~.ry~n~~n~~ui~^nmri~uilryryini~~1'nryi ~wsiri~u~wlir~oriou8n niurnqua L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I U ~ ~ J ~ ~ I ' J B ~ ~ I J ~ ~ ' ~ ~ ~ I ~ S O ~ ~ . Q ~ I ~ I ~ R 2 RGCIJ l(n7-1~1, * ~ ~ $ ~ I W S ~ ~ U W ~ U R ~ ' O ~ ~ I I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
& J L L ~ . HUI'I 454
(201i'ln7 ~AniBuf, ~sn i . rdn~J i ;d ry iAu5~~JSu~~ f iu~w. ( ~ I ~ R I ~ F ~ ~ U U I R B ~ ~ . $6 10 rdui 1 . DU~CIU 2524), H ~ I 9
( 2 ' ) n n ~ ira-mru ($LLJR). "JTnry~Bu'~, (rku'nfiuw'lor4uwaT~1f~2~23). nci 5-6
LW 20 1 (S) 9
i n o i (Epistemology) n!oqun?o~innf d~aq i~uunu! r j~n i . r~~unnuoono in
n3iuCoioJnim7~oiannu u a r n m d ~ u ~ ~ u $ ~ m u o d ~ n n ~ ~ n u ~.rn~unn~tio~n"Jnunun~
diaryi3uo{d.h s:ou.ruilnclumulKiatiiioJ!.r ua:a:h~%nulriAouioo&aiSni.r
b~uulnu &~~uR'nomruyooniw~uu (Humanism) ~ v ~ n ~ d n 7 i o ~ ~ i u o i o n ~ 3 u u ~ ~ n ' u
nis~iioio~(~~) Ahniyor i i t~ t lu~~lauo~dinry i3u&~r iudatn~iun~un~ud~:~ iuf iu
b d o d h u o d ~ ~ i i d ~ r?dnsiulu~an & ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o d d ~ n r y i u d d ~ o n n i w ~ o d n ~ . r ~ d ~ ~ ~ : Y a: Y uywkoou~ro. rn3tddq~mnuuo~n.r3w$dndd3d~iud7~ouuooil3doo (Chuang Tzu)
nio~snniw d~nDuun:nu'~~u~nB~di~3uqi~ ~~1iluo~d?nry~iuci~u8~u'uiiluu'o
u~nriiio~w"u~iu~~iayi~:~umn;I~~Ia~nw.iIu~.rr~~un~iu~'~~~e~'~ua~~~A~~~nrii~~u
iriun~iuU'~uk~:ni~io~nun'uw.r:~41, senii~gnunin'un3lu~3~03d. riJnurYuil~~snynnn
~ ~ ~ ~ I U I ~ ~ ~ U L ~ ~ ~ I W ( ~ ~ )
n i ~ f i ~ i ~ ~ i l r y ~ i n ~ i u ~ ~ m n r i i ~ ~ : ~ i i ~ ~ n w m : : ~ 4 o n ~ . r ~ ~ n i G u o ~ d ~ n y i ~ r ? ' ~ o o n
n ' L l m : h m n s i ~ ~ 8 n a i ~ o ~ s J ' i ~ ~ 6 ~ ~ i ~ : n ~ 1 1 ~ ~ ~ u ~ l i _ ~ n ~ i u ~ u ' i 1 ~ ~ ~ u ~ & ~ ~ u d o ~ ~ n i d d P. ~6o~<udiny~ngnuiu!nado!d oito'o~iluhundcuotdin~i!nonuanwm:uoc
a dinyi~~uumriuasn~?iu& d.r:~Run~iuruiIaci~uuntn~ol%~rno@~noCudinryi
ngnuio~~uun:?'umn~iui.r'nfiuln~u~uni.r~d~~urfiuu~ud~~ingnuiu~shu$u A' u o n ~ i n u n d ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ u d i n o u u o i o ~ u d a ~ n u d o ~ y ~ i n n ~ ~ u d r i o u n ~ u ~ o d n i ~ r r d a ~ w 6 ~
~daio~.rsoh luni.n$?ou6id?nryi, ayyi. Philosophy n~onfin$qqr nionnnur A r d ~ i n ~ i u ~ ? n ~ i ~ u m u i ~ u ~ n ~ m d ~ ~ d a n ~ i u ~ ~ ~ q y i ~ ~ i u f ~ ~ ~ d a~nsnqnu8atiouyn$u
dd P. "n d dn ntii~rruuu~uCu~nwmruo~ds'aqimt?'~oonnuan~-~lb:~ilu 3n"113ww ilinni.rnaou6~
~od~fi<u~inuioliidin6d ~ d $ g m u n ~ ~ ~ o f d d n ~ . r i l r ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ n ~ ~ n i i u o d n a i u ~ i u uwA a:
Philosophy n ~ o d j ; l r ~ i u u u n : ? ' u n n ~ ~ ~ < ~ ~ o i o ~ o o n o i n ~ i ~ u i m d ~ ~ 6 ~ ~ ~ o ~ m ~ a 61 (Thales)
a d 4- auun:~uoond~rl~:~w~nis~~kf~.r~~~%aw~~uinsnaa~n~mrnuui?uiuian~ln a:
~nrriioirRur n?onijnqruriiuugt~n (ukirnate values) Grhwiu~maausioaniwi.2ad
nqnih (Static) Y oani~m:7u00n(~~) L~BJ!~W uiuiumouriiniu&ndi?odi~"ru~?u A' .a
Y ~ : ~ ~ i n ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ ~ l ~ ~ 9 ~ ~ t ~ n 6 d ~ Z f \ @ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 7 ~ ~ d ~ ~ ~ 9 L ~ ~ ~ l 3 7 ~ ~ t L ~ ~ ~ 1 1 ~ 9 d ~ ~ ~ i ?
.a a: ~~u?<ud?acyin~nuiu\wu~uni~~k o d ~ b f l n i u G ~ T Z L ~ U ~ rii~~uuums~3uu"a
~'~Lnn~do~riunaiuds::ni~ni ia80 nis~h~dis~an~iu~6~u~uastniiadr'"11~im:7uaan
n'Y~i~uiw?isn~n~iwui (QrGiIwirln pisiwnituuv9 ~ i a n ~ u d o ~ i l u ~ o l r u 6 i i d iagi
nriunon Plddiacyijuu6ilia) naka~&#n6an~iu~~in~~idun?iuGmuoar l ia~ i -
ntiuosn T ~ ~ ~ A ~ ~ T ~ ~ ~ J ~ ~ ~ U M U ~ U ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U ~ ~ J ~ ~ ~ S I ~ ' ~ Q ~ ~ M Y ~ Y W I I S ~ ~ ~ ~ I U M U I U a i - J r 4 l u n n m i c ~ i l d o t n ~ i u ~ u w ' ~ ~ ~ ~ i i a ~ ~ w i i < ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i l " i n ~ o a a ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ w ~ i a ivii$u & o i G
e l - P, fiiauiLau (miuriiaou&~lunuau?8~n4im~iiau uo~ws:umis:~~i lu~imi) 6 d d d.r:nouh unijninliiaryi ~ % d ~ c y i ~ ~ i f l u d s a u o ~ n i ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ j w ~ d \ i ~ n a ~ s o ~ ~ ~ ~ m i
M ? € I W J ~ ~ L ~ ~ L ' ~ ~ i ~ Q n n " o ? n ' u ~ n r ~ l f f ~ 7 7 ( ~ J ~ ~ ~ L Q ~ ~ ~ \ ~ L $ ~ ~ ~ u H ~ J ~ ~ ~ R u ~ L ' I I M ) d
('')E.w.F. Tomlin, "The eastern Philosophers : an in~roduction", Op.ci1.. P, 20
( Z 7 ) l i ~ $ ~ ~ n n i ~ ' 1 ~ n ~ ~ ~ z n ~ ~ u ' n u ~ y ~ ~ 3 n u ~ y w u 3 ~ ~ a~mn6 (Levi Strauss) nrSYuo~i7 ~ O J V O J
~~nr4'1n?o~nwdnsnG ( ~ y t h ) t f l u n 1 ~ u o ~ a s s u a 1 b 1 ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ n d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d ~ u ~ ( 1 ? ~ ~ n * ~ i n ~ 1 f l 1 1 ~ r6u~vii~tums~ ~ C D ~ U ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ L ~ U ~ ~ ~ ~ O J ~ ~ U ~ ~ I I B U O ~ K U L C I ' ~ O J ~ O ~ W ~ J ~ ~ ~ ' B I A ? U ~ ' ~ ~ ~ U ~ Q I ~ U ~ ~ ~ W U ~ U ~ ~ H ~ L W ' J O J ~ O I H ~ ~ mnomr?ai irz~u~~Ilin~s~o13nu1~11nfn'~~nwdnsd~u1~d~u~1fi~~~~~fi~n~1~u'~uil~n'~ di~lu ?.rr u u y d ((ude),
~ ~ ~ U I R I R ~ ~ ~ ~ U ~ J ~ U ~ U ~ ~ , (hsanisGt4udnuId ysliidmr~nisrl?n R ' J ~ ~ R ~ R ~ ~ L L ~ ~ w ~ ~ Y u ~ R Q ~ ~ , 2532), HCI 6
(~ I~osso 1) ; t!~du~4u f ina l rdurdi n o o l a p ~ . u ~ # ~ l a s ~ ~ ~ u 6 s t u n ~ . r a n w C ~ ~ u d i U d n ~ ~ ~ IWRR L R ~ -
rrmnli". ~I.~NI'IFI'IU(~R~~ ili 1 7 C I U Y U ~ I O~UCIUU 2533, HGI 49-54
( 2 " d ~ ru i l a u ~ n n ~ cud^), u m n p ~ ~ o . a ? ' ~ ~ ~ s ~ ~ t ? ' u m n ~ * , disnfi, nri7 ae, so
c
B s
' S e 5 P
2 b- a
2 c C a
z
e
$
-=5 a a s
a
32 7 -3
Q
'2 -1
e
C
a
*5
9
C
-a
0
- ffi x 6-
5
- 9
-5
2
!!! 2
aa b-
2 5'
"6 c
h
C
QP
L
F 'f s
F
F
t= a
'S 3
TP
w
a-
E -?
Q
Q
?
$ e
ffi P
c
'b- G
a- $
s
A 6
:
rCi; r a
z F
E : 23
ek
s
<P
G
a
b-
='a
+
6 IE
a&
3
-a ;
91s I
b-
-1 -
s -
9
'E "3 :
2 N
q
Q
aa y
:
: -c .
ex
k
'2 5
$
a-
P
: c
5
$5
:
q2
s
a%
f
Q
tm
e E
2 ale
.. 9
6
iF2 c
2
!$ B
- -a
+ 5
3
$=
9
v
-'a
;J
s ?
s
p
pe
l-
C
b r
as c
w
9 0
e
1
e- b- c
C
:
E -6
a
aE ffi Z
-z TS 9
C
ffi c
G
9- 6
C
h
C
6
C
f
a
' c
C
a
*5
s
-5
c
!? C
'9
a
Q
b- G
b-
C c
-h2
a
L
05 be
rJnuluknuluirouhld (The ominpresent dictatorships of consumption, produc- -a
tion, advertising, commerce, consummer culture in the uan-JinwuJ2n
~ n d h ~ ^ o ~ n ~ s n : ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ m T ' o d i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ " T o o ' i ~ ~ i ~ n ~ i ~ ~ i ~ m ~ ~ ~ u g l " i m a ~ iin?ulnfo cdn k ~ g n d o u n ~ ~ u n ' u n ~ ~ ~ d ~ o ~ u y w ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ n ~ w u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ w ~ ~ f j n ~ ~ o ~ ? o ~ i ~ m ~ u
%nlln q d~ i~ur ioza f i~n2 iur~dan~~une iou~ w d u ~ i n u luuiu"riiorliy~~dou 91
ndri c i o ~ 6 ~ ~ n ~ r n u z ~ a t i ~ ~ n u ~ ~ ~ u ' (Ludwig Wittgenstein) duonii+arnmuo~u~udli
HBILILLUU L L ~ I ~ L L U U ~ U ~ ~ J T ~ L ~ ~ O ~ ~ ' M L ~ J L ~ I ~ ~ R ~ J L O I M < ~ ~ M ~ J ~ ~ ~ ' ~ ~ ~ H ~ ~ M ~ ~ Ldu 44- ~ i ; u ~ ~ ~ n ? ~ ~ ~ i n ~ n S n ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ d < ~ n ~ n ~ i ~ ~ ~ i n " a o n ~ n d T ' n ~ i ~ ' 2anmuuu
Comte) o i o ~ ~ u d d u n u o n r i o ~ ~ u n 1 ~ ~ ~ r i ~ u o n ~ ~ u 1 n 1 . m 1 o m 1 u A m ~ 4 t ~ T ' n ~ i ~ o~ E
uyrranqloonrilu 3 yunou: qnmfinui, ynaf id ia~i uae yndfiziuituu (Posi- d ad4 P. 2'
tivism) d~u~wd~uuium?anrn~,~u?noi~ir& ninumudoum3ry~ninnu.n"3ld~cn*2i~d
.L
('O)nssnw:uo~ Vaclav Have1 $ ~ i u o ~ ~ r : ~ n u ~ a n T n ~ ~ ~ 7 i ~ f i u ( H S ~ J ~ I S ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ S ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ B I U L ~ ~ ~ ~ U ~ R J
drrmfloins:uu~~nuiiuu) d i ~ l u Newsweek, March 5. 1990. P. 17
,LW 201 (S)
i l g l n i d r i i ~ n i o ~ o a i n (rdeii) i id iny ina iu8r lnu ( i h ld ) r~ iS1 +irilu
ngnuiuaina (%%.an) C/<m~~uhu~~~uaada"agl id~z~n6 (Applied Philosophy)
dunnn ioan91ndh~ iu i~n$ (Pure Philosophy) a i n n ~ ~ u n u s i a a ~ ~ u ~ s n i r 6 i s ~
nn~i io~niroinnaiu 9 uiquniod~unnic~5uniwin~nisi1 naiunainhr inln
(School of Thoughts) ~ ~ d a : h ~ n f i a n ' ~ u ' o ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ u ~ u u o ~ v o ~ n u ~ o c ~ i ( u ? ~ ~ d o ~ t a u - w r d n.r~uniWrn~nglnuiu r r~ : :~ouc ls~nunawind i~ i . r~na iuGnr~~ i iunna~uwiouq
ni!d<w hu'n~nni~ic~d%ryi~~~m~umndi in 'qn*d oin' ~~r ind~ryinpnuio~.runi?i
(Natural Law). i i r i n d ~ ~ i u ~ u u n i ~ n g c l u i u (Legal Positivism), i i ~ n n p n u i u
ds:R~i am$ (Historical School of Law) n%iiu'n &Qsunitnpnui LI (Legal
Realism) n i ' I ~ ~ d s u u n ~ i ~ n ~ a & n ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ u n i s ~ ~ ~ t m i u ~ n ~ ~ : u o ~ ~ ~ ~ a n a i u ~ ~ i j ld d a- ~ i l u n i s u d ~ m i u i i r y n i ~ n i o t ~ o m ~ ~ o t u ' n i 9 nuoniwaluaia.-hrinGn$u9
h ~ t n ~ ~ ~ ? @ i ~ n w i ~ ~ n r y i n ~ ~ u ~ ~ w ~ ~ u m n ~ . n i ~ l d d n i s a ' n n u ? n c l ~ n i ~ ~ n w i ~ ~ u
diirryingnuiuojnqlt. d i n r y ~ n ~ ~ u i u c l t ~ ~ ~ a n'?odinryingnuiu~uosu o:~sriiua~
od i4b i ia Lda<uu iu0~~d~%~7~~nu iu1nu q ~ i ~ ~ ( 1 i n ~ ~ i u ~ u h ~ n ~ @ n i ~
~ ~ d ~ n ~ i o n l u a ~ n ~ ~ u n n ~ ~ a ~ ' n u r u r i w I n d n i ~ n ? 7 u ~ n ~ ~ ~ a t ~ u n ~ ~ l d u l m l 6 ~ i u
6~ru~l~r~uii~ni.rlinialrilillin~~n~~uiuhu~~lh nlu.riruaaTuo2uau30gliu
M~nunuiu<uL6~Jsiuug?-iiqulnbiidr~r"kqq nuln siinis~$np~rnu~8ud.r:rwriin~.r
dnnro~~iu~i io~ui~~ iu ,a l~rncw~~<2 Aw~annmR~yomu~n s (~ar ;u~ui tnu) 6; > , '
6 a m ~ u n i ~ n ~ ~ u i u ~ i a n ~ ~ u i u l r ) n ~ ~ t ~ ~ u ~ o , ~ ~ ~ d t j ~ u 4 i ~ ~ a ~ l n u 0 w ' n ~ ~ ) ~ 1 ~ ~ u {J '1 j ;
u&t~J8n1.rusnuu=:~i]uer'iu'n~mii~q ud~~nnuio~uuumtiumn~miu au'm.r6t>ild!
~nftn~ndna$ni~np~uiund'bd~<~ id; wah, a i~ ln iG~. 9~al.r (Cicero), nln?&
~~asrbsioiia:~~kd.rin~luiisid~'~~~~n~r;l~~iumt?'umn ~ i n m n " ' L i o i a l l a ~ a ~ ~ \ G ~ i u
Cuii~aniutn!ounuin n?iu~iluCndialynpnuib~~uiuooru~.miauxw.nnud a " '. ' y
~~ow.rru~i.r ian;~aiuq riiu d2iunu~nni~niun~lr1uiusii~ 7 lu~ i~hr in l .us i ru . *
~ o h i i i ~ L ~ R L ~ J L ~ ? ~ U L ~ L I U W ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ C t d ~ ~ i d p i ~ ~ i o m : i u n n i r i l r i n f t n n ~ i ~ l n ~ i n i
a i ~ i u a ~ ~ u a i 6 n g m u i u ~ r ~ n ~ i ~ ~ u & ~ d & ~ a h r ? n ~ u a ~ n p ~ u i u ~ ~ ~ d a ~ ~ a u ~ ~ ~ n d
~ ~ u ~ ~ ' o ~ f i u l a a ~ . r u ~ i o ~ 1 ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ r . r ~ u ~ l r l i ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ t c - (hrinn~)tluiuar.rua11) UIJ
k ~ n ~ a ~ a i n p n u i u ~ ~ 5 i u i a 5 " ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ ~ U ' ~ ~ u (h r ind j~ iu i tuun i~np~u iu ) .* ' .
a i r ~ n u L u i o n ~ i u c i l ~ q v a ~ ~ 1 1 ~ ~ ~ . r 2 : ~ w i i t ~ ~ ~ w ~ n ~ r y q i a ~ o t ~ ~ = : a i n u w dd.nnnoi
~5u.nnyiuuo~np~uiu ($irinnp~u~ud~5%pl'isp6i) ~ j h ~ i n ~ ~ u i ~ l l n u r i a u ~ n d t " :
~ n ~ w ~ n ~ i u ~ n m r ~ u m n ~ 1 z ~ u ' i u i ~ ~ n " a w a (nauci~$u?aniad 4 atui) ?3t?i~hn~+4dg d " u ~ n ~ i ~ ~ i ~ n L ? ' l d u a ~ d ~ a ~ i m = : ~ ~ ~ a n n ~ ~ ~ n d ~ n y i ~ u ~ i ~ u i ~ ~ i ~ u i u ~ u d u %b
~awi:8nhan?iuAnluni wui~nn cjnwa:~du~~i~plidiagin~~uiu~nu&~~~u o b i u
m w . r ? u u a ~ n g a u i s o i n g i u g m u n ~ n ~ ~ m ~ ~ u i ~ ~ ~ u I : ' a ~ ~ f l ~ d ~ J ~ ~ . r u t e i i rnhda~ nirl%~iuirRiuq u o ~ ~ n - r ~ ($iruZ~$uuciuGu) 1a.i n-nu~~oulu~ua~diirtgi
n p a u i u l n o ~ ~ ~ ~ u n ' u ~ i a ~ i ~ ~ n i i ~ r:Tnii~~u~nwm:~awi:~~e,e,lnu$l~~~~ou2n3R
n ~ I J q n W ~ l o ? l i n l i i k ~ n n i i ~ ~ ~ o o n o : a r l i ? u n " u d a ' ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ u i u ~ ~ a ~ n i y n d ~ v o ~
.Z$UR~ nh?flod%cyinpwuiua.rsu~il ~ ~ ~ I ( U ~ L R ~ ~ ~ ~ R ~ R M I J O I ~ ~ J ~ ~ U L L I L Y R
n ~ i ~ u o ~ m r - ? u n n ( d ~ ~ . r m i i ~ n i a n ~ r ~ w 6 5- 16) ~ ? T ~ I ~ ~ M U I I I R ~ R ~ ~ ~ ~ W I ~ H W T ~
n ~ o n . r o u h i ~ u ~ n ~ i ~ 1 ~ n a i n ~ 1 i ~ t b i n 3 ~ ~ ~ u u ~~o~irruiinrl.niunino^nndij~uu"nwi~
, l n q j l u n ~ ~ h u w i n d i a r y i n ~ w u ~ u s r r u a i l k n d i ~ ~ ~ i u ~ ~ o a k & ~ ~ c o o n l r i a ~ n ~ ~
~ I U I P U R Z Z ~ ~ S W ~ n i ~ n ? i u q n r o ~ ~ 7 ~ ~ i ~ d ~ L ? ~ i d o ~ 7 ~ ~ j l i n n i 3 L ~ o u h u i a v o ~
mwui insb r iun inof in w i o u h ~ u d l i a r y i n g ~ u i u ~ n u a i l & n i i ~ R ~ R I U I T O ~ ~ U
~ d o ~ u n u i n n t o h ~ t d n i w a ~ ~ u ~ i ~ l ~ ~ i u ~ n k 6 ~ u o ~ ~ 5 l d i a ~ i ~ r ~ u n n l 6 ~ u a ~ u A Y ~ i o i i ~ ~ f i n i ~ n - n s a d I 8- I 9 i r ~ n n ~ ~ i ~ r y ~ n ~ ~ u i ~ ~ ~ a o u r ~ u i i i ~ ~ m ; ~ e , n e , i n
s d p l L $ ~ ~ ~ J U ~ J H ? O R U $ I J DIG ---. ~ ? % ~ I ~ Q H U I ( I ~ O J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M ~ J ~ U ~ T Z % B I I A ~ J mua1?iq$
w P.. (Friedrich Carl Von Savigny : 1 779- 186 1 ) unun~lR~li"IIvL~~o.r~uL~~$do~J,
.- . d ia ry iu s~lilGndfi~iu~iuni.sngnuio (Legal Positivism) d r i o n i l n o w u u a u w (Jeremy Bentham : 1 748- 1832) U ~ W ~ R I R R ~ ~ ~ a : ~ n d ~ ~ d n ~ n u i ~ ~ f l u d ~ < ~ " ~ ~ i ~ ~ t n q w
n i . r A u n i ~ n ~ o w l ~ ~ u o ~ i i ~ n / ~ ~ w ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ a " ~ ~ ~ i ~ n u " ? w u i 5 u ~ T . I u n - i r ~ ~ a n ~ i u 6 n n i ~
P ~ R I R W ~ I ~ d ? J ~ k 1 2 3 5 ~ 6 1 9-20 d ~ u u i ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ ~ n ~ i n u o t n ~ ~ u i u ~ u ~ t n u
d . r ~ m u ~ u n i r d n ~ i u ' o ~ ~ . ~ ~ f i a ~ ~ 4 n ~ ~ i i J n u 6 i u ~ i ~ 7 dsmoun i~n i tnm6inou inu-d
n.r:uan~iu~nddrin~o~#?ldRlridf~~~n ( n i w l i i n i ~ I S ~ m i u A l ~ o ~ Francois
Geny : I 861 - 1944, Leon Duguir : I 859-1 We), ~um.bJ"9.b (4 Rudolf Jhering : 181 8-
I a92 i i l u ~ i i n i t n ~ i u i i n ) n i g I u o ~ u i n i ( ~ i u u ~ n t o s n $ n 7 i u ~ n m Roscoe
Pound : I 870- I 964) ~ ~ u ~ ~ 6 o ~ ~ n u i n ~ ~ 2 1 u ? u n 1 3 n ? ~ u ~ n n i ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ n f l u
d?triusn?nw# 20 d ~ ~ u n u i u ? i U k Q ~ u m t n g n u 7 u 1 1 (Legal Realism) a t d n n D n i
luoi&?n1u~tn~ud3:~nfiaunsbAii~50 \ uu?wn7~n?iud~~douuituo~n~vu7olu~rd
w h ~ ? u ~ 6 ~ i ) u s i ~ u o ~ n 7 ~ d ~ ~ n u * i 6 l i l ~ . ~ n ~ ' y 1 1 ~ 1 u ' ~ o t 9 ' ~ ~ ~ a r a u ~ s ~ o d n i r m r ~ ~ ~ o ~ l ~ w i n d w dr. inrdw qRnnu~o~~~inuin~iung~uiuri15 q n ~ ~ ~ ~ f i ~ a ? ~ d ~ u ~ ~ ~ o ~ n ' u w ' w u i n 7 r
n ~ ~ 5 3 l l i a r y ~ 1 ~ o ~ m t i i r . n r i i r i ~1nn i i r i sud~aw i i f u~~~4oas~n~ . r~dduunde rn i~ d n ? i u ~ n ~ u ~ : n . i i ~ n i ~ ~ ~ . r ~ w n , $ i a - 18 g ~ n ~ o u l l ~ ~ i n g ~ ~ i ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ u a i R ~ ~ ~ ~ u n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
