book review kenapa aku meninggalkan syiah

Upload: syahir-safwan

Post on 16-Feb-2018

249 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    1/25

    Book Review:Kenapa AkuMeninggalkan

    SYIAH?by Syeikh Al-

    Allamah Dr. HusainAl-Musawi

    Presenter:

    KUD 4111

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    2/25

    Book review :

    1- About the Author

    2- Review book ontent:-

    -Ab!ullah bin Saba" -Mut"ah -Khumus

    -Holy Sri#tures -Shiah view on the Ahlu Sunnah

    3- $ritial analysis

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    3/25

    About the Author

    Syeikh Al-Allamah Dr. Husain Al-Musawi

    He was a %amiliar name amon& the Shi'ahs.

    He was a &reat sholar o% the Shi'ahs who was born inKarbala an! stu!ie! in Hauzah until he &ot the title(mu)tahi!.

    His teaher is the &reat sholar o% Shiah * Ayatollah Kashi% Al-+hita".

    He ha! a s#eial #osition in the si&ht o% ,mam AyatullahKhomeini.

    A%ter &oin& throu&h a lon& s#iritual )ourney he nally le%tShi'ah beause he %oun! so many !eviations an! errors in it.

    /Hauzah is aa!emi institution o% mazhab Syiah

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    4/25

    (, stu!ie! the madzhab o% Ahlul-1ait but on the otherhan! , have %oun! re#roah an! attaks a&ainst theAhlul-1ait2

    , learne! about the issues o% Shari'ahto worshi# Allahbut in it were nas 3te4ts5 whih show kufr a&ainst AllahS67. "O Allah, what am I studying? Is it possible that allthis is the true madzhab of Ahlul!ait?"

    He said :

    When he was asked to his teacher about his doubtfulness, his teachersaid :

    Put away doubts from yourself because you are the follower of Ahli Baitand Ahli Bait are the followers of Prophet Muhammad !hen ProphetMuhammad recei"ed the re"elation from Allah#

    He read many books and start to search the truth After he finished the studyfrom Hau$ah, and %ot the title &mu'tahid(, he was decided to left )hiah andwrote this book

    At last, he was killed

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    5/25

    Shiah view on the Author :

    Shiah ar&ue! that Syeikh Husain Al-Musawi atually !i! not e4ist.

    Ahlu Sunni trie! to on!emn Shiah by

    usin& this name an! wrote this book. Syeikh Husain Al-Musawi"s teaher

    Ayatollah Kashi% Al-+hita " an! another

    sholars o% Shiah !elare! that they neverknew Syeikh Husain Al-Musawi an! never&ive any !e&ree mu)tahi! to him.

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    6/25

    ,ssues o% Ab!ullah bin Saba"

    Shiah !eny the e4istene o% Ab!ullah bin Saba" Sai! that only the tion o% Ahlu Sunni to on!emn Shiah.

    Abdullah bin Saba hanyalah khurafat dan

    rekaan golongan Umawi dan Abbasi kerana

    dengki terhadap ahli bait yang suci. Orang

    berakal sepatutnya tidak memikirkan danmengendahkan perkara ini*Ayatullah +asyif al*hita(

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    7/25

    Ab!ullah bin Saba" was e4ist. He was a 8ew %rom 9emen.Preten!in& onverte! to ,slam at the time o% $ali#h

    'thman. He says to ali#h Ali ra!iallahu' anhu that: ;9ou are my

    +o!.; Ali then allow to kill Ab!ullah bin Saba but %orbi!!enby ,bn Abbas. 7he su##orters o% Ali then e4ile him toMa!ain 3ol! ,ranian State $a#ital5.

    Ab!ullah bin Saba 'was the rst who a#ostatise the Abu1akr' mar an! 'thman an! !oes not reo&nize the$ali#hate but only %rom amon& the members o% the Ahlu1ait.

    Ahli Sunni view :

    -eferences :#./0123/ * al*!sa44afi51673/ * 8bn 9aud77;31? @ 5C >D1EF = 8bn )hahrin Asywab

    many more booksG

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    8/25

    Muta ikah mut'ahhas been #ratie! in the u&liest %orms to %ulll

    their lusts in the name o% reli&ion.

    7hey have brou&ht riwaayahs that &ive motivations to!o mut'ah, settin& an! !etailin& its rewar!s as well as

    #unishments on those who !o not !o it.

    ,n %at those who !o not #ratie mut'ahareonsi!ere! ka#r. As Sa!u< narrate! %rom As Sa!i

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    9/25

    7o stren&then %urther this mut'ah,the name o%Rasulullah was even brou&ht in suh as written

    in %&an a (ahdhuruhu Al )a*ih =>=??

    Anyone who do mutah with women was like to ha"e "isited the

    +aabah QR times#

    ,"#hoe$er does mutah with a woman! he will be safe from the wrath ofAllah! the &ompeller. #hoe$er does mutah two time! he shall be gathered

    together with the people of goodness. #hoe$er does mutah three times!

    he will be side by side with me in paradise.'

    !ake

    Ha"it

    ##

    Sonclusion : Mut(ah is hala for )hiah and haram for Ahlu sunnah

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    10/25

    $apterreview %3&'(

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    11/25

    KH)M)S KHMS is one-%th o% the #ro#erty that

    omes %rom their livelihoo! whih must be

    #ai! by the Shi'ahs. ,t is somethin& that is bein& e4#loite! in a

    manner that is very worse by the

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    12/25

    *ra"ual +ro,le-. e-erge" ini-ple-enting ku-u.

    @. Payin& khumus is an obli&ation in shiah

    . Khumus was belon&e! to ,mam +haib. As a results B#ersons !elare! themselves as ,mam +haib.

    =. 7he wealth>#ro#erties must be #lante! until ,mam +haibreturn.

    C. 7he authorize! #eo#le in shiiesm were a##ointe! to mana&ekhumus !istribution o% wealth. 6ho are the authorize!#eo#leE 7hey kee# &htin& to be the re#resentative.

    F. 7he #ro#erties shoul! be &iven to Gu

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    13/25

    KH)M)S I/ i.la-i0tra"ition

    Iur"an mentione! in surah Al-nahl : Know thatwhatever o% a thin& you a

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    14/25

    ,n Sunni tra!ition &hanim is !ene! asthe s#oils o% war an! the tra!ition o%

    #ayin& khums has la#se!. HoweverSunnis #ay Lakat whih involves a one-%ortieth ta4ation o% total wealth

    7he #ratie o% shiah in the way they

    #ratise! khumus totally ontra!it withIurani a##roah.

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    15/25

    ter .a0re" .0ripture.

    Shi"ites #rolaime! that there are other sri#tures reveale!to Muhamma! besi!es Iuran. 7hose books are Al-8ami'ahSahi%ah An amus Sahi%ah Al-Abithah Sahi%ah DzuabahAs-Sai% Sahi%ah Ali Al-8u%r Musha% Gatimah Al- Iur'an.

    An! the Iur'an is %ake beause it has been altere! by the

    %ollowers Ahl Sunnah. A thousan! riwaayahs whih state! that there has ourre!

    alterations. ulama's o% Shi'ah o#enly state! that the Iur'anthat is in the han!s o% mankin! to!ay has been han&e!%rom the ori&inal.

    ,n!ee! the most urious an! sur#risin& thin& is that all o%these books ha! been han!e! !own %rom Allah an!!e!iate! to ,mam Ali an! the imams a%ter him but theyare all hi!!en %rom the ummah. ,% ,mam Ali really ha!those books why he hi!e! itEE

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    16/25

    SHII +R$+I/S4AR5 AH6 S)//AH

    @. All the %ollowers o% sunni are onsi!ere! astheir enemy.

    -sunni was alle! as NAl-Ammah an! nawasib.- Gollowers o% Sunni are e

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    17/25

    27 .iite -u.t oppo.eagain.t .unni. ,elie8

    As narrate! by Hussain bin Khali! in his bookentitle! Fusul al-Muhimmah: #a&e: F:

    %pengikutpengikut shiah adalah golonganyang menyerahkn +iwa raga kepada kami,menerima pandangan kami, dan menyalahi

    pendapat musuh kami$ Sesiapa tidakmelakukan sedemikian maka mereka

    bukanlah termasuk daripada golongan kami$

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    18/25

    37 Siite are not allow toe9er0i.eper8or- on wat

    .unni pra0ti0e.7

    Aor!in& to Al-Hur al-Alimi in his book entitle!Wasail Syiah:

    ( -emi Allah, tiada terdapat suatu perkara punyang kamu lakukan bersamaan dengan alhisunnah$ !egitu +uga dengan mereka, tiadaterdapat suatu apa pun yang bersepakat

    dengan kita$ &aka bertentangan lah merekakerana apa yang mereka lakukan bukan

    daripada agama$

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    19/25

    C7 /o 0o-pliant BetweenSiite an" Sunni

    As what mentione! by Sayi! ikmatullahAl-8aza"iri in his book entitle! % anwar al

    +azairiyah #a&e OJ :

    ( sesungguhnya kita tidak akan sepakat dengan

    mereka golongan sunni sama ada pada tuhan,nabi dan imam$ Ini kerana mereka mengatakanbahawa tuhan mereka men+adikan &uhammad

    sebagai abi dan khlifah selepasnya adalahAbu !akar$ .ita tidak pernah menyebut tuhan

    sebegitu +uga tiada nabi sebegitu/$

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    20/25

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    21/25

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    22/25

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    23/25

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    24/25

  • 7/23/2019 Book Review Kenapa Aku Meninggalkan Syiah

    25/25

    onlusion

    Will you follow shiah?